logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

MSI GS73VR vs Hyperbook SL970VR: Comparing Laptops, User Experience & Decision by Jan 28, 2018

BESTIAQ 10647 12
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 16984638
    BESTIAQ
    Level 10  
    Posts: 18
    Rate: 1
    I am going to buy a laptop, which is a simple thing, but a lot of dilemmas.
    Digging through the internet for weeks and exploring the topic, I finally stopped on two models.

    MSI GS73VR: link
    and
    Hyperbook SL970VR: link
    of course, both in the same configuration.

    QUESTION: Branded MSI or Hyperbook compactor, what speaks for one or the other?
    Do you have experience in operating MSI and Hyperbook models?
    The dilemma must be resolved by January 28, 2018.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 16984980
    Brozerihno
    Level 24  
    Posts: 661
    Help: 28
    Rate: 43
    Strangely similar Dream Machines GS1060-17 https://www.x-kom.pl/p/404258-notebook-laptop...s1060-17-i7-7700hq-8gb-1tb120ssd-gtx1060.html unless it same as Hyperbook but cheaper
    Intel Core i7-7700HQ (4 cores, from 2.80 GHz to 3.80 GHz, 6 MB cache)
    8 GB (SO-DIMM DDR4, 2133MHz)
    NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060
    IPS screen
    Multicolor keyboard backlight
    Built-in fingerprint reader
    NVIDIA G-Sync
  • #3 16986498
    BESTIAQ
    Level 10  
    Posts: 18
    Rate: 1
    This Dream Machines has:
    smaller SSD
    less RAM
    no Thunderbolt 3
    and matrix probably only 60 Hz
    Given the above, the price with parameters similar to the models in the first message would be higher ...

    It doesn't matter if that Hyperbook, Dream Machines or other strange name.
    They are all in the same housings and are based on hulls Clevo .

    I mean more about features such as:
    quality and reliability
    vitality
    how it works in use (Temperatures, vulnerability, fingers ...)

    As far as the compiler is known, what components were used, then in branded equipment it is not necessarily ...

    The dilemma remains - the brand MSI vs Hyperbook, Dream Machines and the rest of the world ...
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 16986506
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14652
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2645
    Neither one nor the other. I had bad experiences with one, the other is a total squadaq.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #5 16986587
    BESTIAQ
    Level 10  
    Posts: 18
    Rate: 1
    yogi009 wrote:
    Neither one nor the other. I had bad experiences with one, the other is a total squadaq.


    A bit of information ...
    Maybe some suggestions?
  • #6 16986852
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14652
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2645
    Little, not little. I just gave my opinion on the two you are thinking about. There are hundreds of others, it's probably a matter of reconciling your expectations and your budget.
  • #7 16988792
    FxJ
    Level 21  
    Posts: 589
    Help: 9
    Rate: 5
    yogi009 wrote:
    Neither one nor the other. I had bad experiences with one, the other is a total squadaq.


    Exactly, you don't buy thin laptops with the GTX 1060, the laptop work culture is also an important thing.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #8 16988983
    BESTIAQ
    Level 10  
    Posts: 18
    Rate: 1
    FxJ wrote:
    yogi009 wrote:
    Neither one nor the other. I had bad experiences with one, the other is a total squadaq.


    Exactly, you don't buy thin laptops with the GTX 1060, the laptop work culture is also an important thing.

    What is bought?
    On the other hand, the manufacturer advertises cool equipment e.g. for games with the GTX 1060 and ble, ble, ble ....
    then I have to understand that buying one model from the first post with higher loads will not cope with e.g. cooling ???

    So what to buy then?
    Appearance also matters, and most of the thicker models are totally tasteless.
    They look as if they were designed by a crumpled construction worker from "Alternative 4" ...
  • #9 16989088
    Myrasz
    Level 20  
    Posts: 543
    Help: 10
    Rate: 82
    Let's start with the question what is the laptop supposed to be used for ? I traced the topic, but everyone either advises against the model or recommends something - they do not know the purpose of the equipment themselves. Although at a price I suspect it's about games.

    I will speak on one issue:
    BESTIAQ wrote:
    So what to buy then?


    When it comes to games, I answer: PC .

    I have been working and using games for many years.
    Let's start with the fact that laptops are not just for work.
    I do not understand people, I do not know what they have in their heads and I do not know why they need a "gaming" laptop. Do they have room in the house / room, do they play on the train / bus while going to school / work, do they walk around with their laptop for friends and play CS or Minecraft together while sitting on their lap, are they lying in bed and holding a laptop on the quilt / blanket and play anything while cooking equipment.
    The facts are this:
    - for the price of a "gaming" laptop (the price for a decent one starts from 10k zlotys and above) you have a cool gaming PC - many times more efficient than this laptop);
    - I skip the fact that the 17-inch screen is a mistake when it comes to games (in my opinion. There are people who enjoy playing on a 5-inch phone screen - I do not penetrate);
    - service life and expandability (of course, at a reasonable price, because "gaming" toys can do it now) - PC beats the head;
    I could exchange it for what for? Not my money, not my toy - the author of the topic asked a question, so I answered.

    PS. I only understand people with gaming laptops who weekly they travel from their current place of residence to the place of check-in or to their woman. Although in the latter case - why the equipment for so much money, if someone is more expensive at the side? ;)
  • #10 16989093
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14652
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2645
    Buddy, this isn't about chilling or one thing. It is about the whole performance, then the comfort of use depends on this quality (from design to plastics). You won't have the comfort of a high-speed notebook in which hinges fall and you will have trouble replacing whole parts of the case. The same if it overheats. It's quite simple.
  • #11 16989210
    BESTIAQ
    Level 10  
    Posts: 18
    Rate: 1
    Myrasz wrote:
    Let's start with the question what is the laptop supposed to be used for ? I traced the topic, but everyone either advises against the model or recommends something - they do not know the purpose of the equipment themselves. Although at a price I suspect it's about games.

    I will speak on one issue:
    BESTIAQ wrote:
    So what to buy then?


    When it comes to games, I answer: PC .

    I have been working and using games for many years.
    Let's start with the fact that laptops are not just for work.
    I do not understand people, I do not know what they have in their heads and I do not know why they need a "gaming" laptop. Do they have room in the house / room, do they play on the train / bus while going to school / work, do they walk around with their laptop for friends and play CS or Minecraft together while sitting on their lap, are they lying in bed and holding a laptop on the quilt / blanket and play anything while cooking equipment.
    The facts are this:
    - for the price of a "gaming" laptop (the price for a decent one starts from 10k zlotys and above) you have a cool gaming PC - many times more efficient than this laptop);
    - I skip the fact that the 17-inch screen is a mistake ...... ;)


    I DID NOT HAVE ANYWHERE ABOUT GAME!
    I will not take the computer on my back and the equipment will be there mobile and serve mainly for work.
    Once a week, it pulls a new game for two hours, it will also be a guitar.
    And "gaming" because of the components .
    17 "because at work 15" is a bit too little for me.
    The quality of workmanship, hinges, etc. as the most important, if at all maintaining the aesthetic value it would be quite great.

    The question was: brand equipment or folding gear.

    If the models I have chosen are not very thrilling, then maybe you will propose something specific
    what is worth considering
    in the amount of 5-7k.
  • #12 16989920
    krzysztof723
    Level 30  
    Posts: 1060
    Help: 163
    Rate: 312
    BESTIAQ wrote:
    The question was: brand equipment or folding gear.

    If the models I have chosen are not very thrilling, then maybe you will propose something specific
    which is worth paying close to 5-7k.


    Most branded equipment.
    In this amount you can not recommend anything better given the MSI GS73VR Stealth Pro ...
    https://www.x-kom.pl/p/342785-notebook-laptop...3vr-i7-16-1tb256pcie-win10-gtx1060-120hz.html price PLN 7199
    You chose a wonderful, mobile, latest MSI GS73VR Stealth Pro equipment - 17.3 "Full HD screen (120Hz matrix refresh with 5ms matrix response time), very high overall performance (i7 - 7700HQ, GTX1060, SSD PCIe), highly efficient cooling system (three fans), Windows 10 Home PL, backlit RGB keyboard, aluminum housing, weight 2.4kG, prices 19.6mm etc ...
    For work (large Full HD matrix) and transfer (weight) - perfect.

    As for the heating of components during loading, e.g. with demanding games, "thick" or "thin" laptops with high performance will always heat up and then there is no difference in the work culture of such laptops ...

    Don't worry about the hinges, because this is not the price model.

    And by the way, there is nothing to upset my friend, because it damages health ...
    Sometimes I also get a headache when I read some of the comments about laptops here in this section ...

    Browse mini reviews and video reviews of this laptop:
    http://pl.ign.com/msi-gs73vr/7441/review/lapt...ry-goni-pc-ty-recenzja-msi-gs73vr-stealth-pro
    Video review
    http://pl.ign.com/msi-gs73vr/7483/videoreview/wideorecenzja-msi-gs73vr-stealth-pro

    See (just for comparison) this MSI GE73VR model (slightly cheaper) with the same equipment as the above, but here, after two SSD PCIe and HDD disks, you can still add an additional M.2 PCIe disk - it could be useful for work. ..
    Unfortunately, this model is "thicker" - 28mm and weighs 2.8kG ...
    https://www.x-kom.pl/p/399778-notebook-laptop...7-7700hq-16gb-1tb128-win10-gtx1060-120hz.html price PLN 6 699.00
  • #13 16994624
    BESTIAQ
    Level 10  
    Posts: 18
    Rate: 1
    Thank you for all statements.
    krzysztof723 :ok: :spoko:
    The decision was made - MSI .

Topic summary

✨ The discussion revolves around the comparison between the MSI GS73VR and Hyperbook SL970VR laptops, focusing on user experiences and preferences. Users express concerns about build quality, reliability, and performance, particularly in relation to gaming and work tasks. The MSI GS73VR is highlighted for its high performance, efficient cooling system, and portability, making it suitable for both work and occasional gaming. In contrast, Hyperbook models are noted for their customizable options but lack brand recognition. Ultimately, the consensus leans towards the MSI GS73VR due to its superior specifications and user satisfaction.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: For this thread’s buyer, MSI GS73VR won thanks to a 120 Hz display and a “highly efficient cooling system,” with specs fit for mobile work. [Elektroda, krzysztof723, post #16989920]

Why it matters: If you’re choosing between brand and boutique, this FAQ shows what real users weighed—thermals, chassis quality, I/O, and value—for 17-inch, GTX 1060-class laptops.

Quick Facts

Which should I pick for mobile work with light gaming: MSI GS73VR or Hyperbook SL970VR?

The thread leans MSI GS73VR for balanced mobility and performance. Users highlighted the 17.3-inch 120 Hz panel, PCIe SSD, and triple‑fan cooling in a ~2.4 kg, ~19.6 mm chassis. That mix suits travel-heavy workflows, then short gaming sessions. “Highly efficient cooling system” was a deciding phrase. [Elektroda, krzysztof723, post #16989920]

Are Hyperbook and Dream Machines basically Clevo builds? What does that mean here?

Participants noted these boutique models share Clevo barebones chassis. In this context, it means similar shells and core layouts, while component choices (SSD size, RAM, Thunderbolt 3, display refresh) vary by reseller. Evaluate the exact configuration, not just the label. [Elektroda, BESTIAQ, post #16986498]

Is a thin laptop with GTX 1060 a bad idea for thermals and noise?

One experienced user warned against pairing thin chassis with GTX 1060 due to heat and acoustic issues. Quote: “you don’t buy thin laptops with the GTX 1060.” If you prioritize quiet sustained loads, consider thicker cooling or lower‑TDP GPUs. [Elektroda, FxJ, post #16988792]

How capable is the MSI GS73VR cooling design?

It was described as having a “highly efficient cooling system” with three fans. This is notable in a ~19.6 mm body. For bursty work and short play sessions, that design was considered adequate. For prolonged heavy loads, expect heat regardless of thickness. [Elektroda, krzysztof723, post #16989920]

Do hinges or plastics pose a risk on fast, thin notebooks?

Yes, a contributor flagged comfort and durability concerns, citing hinge failures and case-part replacement hassles. Treat ultra‑thin, high‑power laptops carefully, particularly if you open and close them often or carry them daily. [Elektroda, yogi009, post #16989093]

What configuration gaps should I watch (RAM, SSD, Thunderbolt 3, panel Hz)?

The OP compared variants and found the boutique option had smaller SSD, less RAM, no Thunderbolt 3, and a likely 60 Hz panel. Check these four items first; they impact speed, I/O, and visual smoothness. [Elektroda, BESTIAQ, post #16986498]

Is a “gaming” laptop overkill if I mainly work and game for ~2 hours weekly?

The buyer here wanted mobility for work and a 17-inch screen, with occasional gaming. That use case led to a tuned “gaming” spec for responsiveness, not just games. Match GPU/thermals to your real duty cycle, then screen size to your workspace. [Elektroda, BESTIAQ, post #16989210]

Does the Dream Machines GS1060‑17 include G‑Sync or a fingerprint reader?

Yes, the cited configuration listed both NVIDIA G‑Sync and a built‑in fingerprint reader, alongside an IPS display and RGB keyboard. Confirm exact submodel before purchase, as boutique configs vary. [Elektroda, Brozerihno, post #16984980]

How do I choose between a brand name (MSI) and a boutique (Hyperbook/Dream Machines)?

Three steps: 1) List must‑haves (TB3, RAM/SSD, 120 Hz). 2) Compare chassis lineage and support terms. 3) Validate thermals, weight, and panel refresh on the exact SKU. Boutique units may share Clevo shells; details decide value. [Elektroda, BESTIAQ, post #16986498]

Is 17.3 inches worth it over 15.6 inches for work on the go?

In this thread, the buyer found 15 inches “a bit too little” for work and prioritized 17 inches. If you multitask or view timelines and code, larger screens reduce scrolling. Test portability needs against bag size and weight. [Elektroda, BESTIAQ, post #16989210]

What did the original poster finally buy, and what can I learn from that?

On January 28, 2018, the OP chose MSI. The lesson: prioritize your workload, screen needs, and thermal comfort over brand debates. Use a spec checklist, then decide. [Elektroda, BESTIAQ, post #16994624]

Is the MSI GE73VR a good alternative if I need more internal storage?

Yes. A user suggested GE73VR with similar core specs plus room for two PCIe SSDs and an HDD, with an extra M.2 slot. It’s thicker (~28 mm) and heavier (~2.8 kg), trading portability for expandability. [Elektroda, krzysztof723, post #16989920]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT