logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

[Solved] Dell R210 or another quiet and energy-efficient server for learning Hyper V and VMware virtualizatio

xendenn 5841 11
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 18954290
    xendenn
    Level 3  
    Hello,

    I am looking for a quiet and energy-efficient home server in a rack housing. I would use it to learn hyper V and VMware virtualization.
    I was thinking about Dell R210, but I`m afraid it will be too noisy in a small apartment. What model can you recommend?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • Helpful post
    #2 18954320
    KOCUREK1970
    Network and Internet specialist
    xendenn wrote:
    I am looking for a quiet and energy-efficient home server in a rack housing.

    Is the rack server quiet and energy-saving - I have doubts.
    xendenn wrote:
    What model can you recommend?

    Look for something similar, but in a tower case (usually neither the processor nor the case itself has a fan).
    The rack-mount ones have fans so small and in such quantity that when you get tired of them, the howler fires up so much that you can`t sit still in the room with it.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 18973765
    xendenn
    Level 3  
    KOCUREK1970 wrote:
    xendenn wrote:
    I am looking for a quiet and energy-efficient home server in a rack housing.

    Is the rack server quiet and energy-saving - I have doubts.
    xendenn wrote:
    What model can you recommend?

    Look for something similar, but in a tower case (usually neither the processor nor the case itself has a fan).
    The rack-mount ones have fans so small and in such quantity that when you get tired of them, the howler fires up so much that you can`t sit still in the room with it.


    I found a primergy tx120 s3p server. Anyone use ? Do you think it will be ok?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #5 18974111
    pitron
    Level 24  
    Compatibility of newer versions is a processor issue.
    I couldn`t upgrade to 6.7 on a several-year-old server, but an even older HP laptop had no problem with it.
    I don`t think you need a server, just a PC with more RAM and an appropriate processor.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #6 18974578
    m.jastrzebski
    Network and Internet specialist
    xendenn wrote:
    Hello,

    I am looking for a quiet and energy-efficient home server in a rack housing. I would use it to learn hyper V and VMware virtualization.
    I was thinking about Dell R210, but I`m afraid it will be too noisy in a small apartment. What model can you recommend?

    Rack and quiet? With these small fans it will always be noisy.
    There are passive cases for desktop and home computers - basically, they are one large heat sink. There are no typical server alds.
  • #7 18975338
    KOCUREK1970
    Network and Internet specialist
    xendenn wrote:
    I found a primergy tx120 s3p server. Anyone use ? Do you think it will be ok?

    I would rather suggest something like this: Allegro Offer number: 9450728514
    This proposal has a double power supply (power consumption), but you can look for something else with a "normal" single power supply.
    I`m more interested in showing you what it looks like inside - a passive processor, the case itself without a fan.
    And an additional question is where you will keep it in terms of climatic conditions (room, living room, basement, attic, etc.) - this is a passive server, but they work in a strictly defined environment, which in such a case is created in the server room itself (temperature, air humidity) - in this case, you do not have to worry about heat exchange because air circulation is maintained in the server room itself.
    To conclude - I would not go for completely passive solutions, but leave some possibility of installing a fan, at least on the casing. A 12 or 14 cm valve does not spin as terribly fast as those rack jets.
  • #8 19011316
    xendenn
    Level 3  
    KOCUREK1970 wrote:
    xendenn wrote:
    I found a primergy tx120 s3p server. Anyone use ? Do you think it will be ok?

    I would rather suggest something like this: Allegro Offer number: 9450728514
    This proposal has a double power supply (power consumption), but you can look for something else with a "normal" single power supply.
    I`m more interested in showing you what it looks like inside - a passive processor, the case itself without a fan.
    And an additional question is where you will keep it in terms of climatic conditions (room, living room, basement, attic, etc.) - this is a passive server, but they work in a strictly defined environment, which in such a case is created in the server room itself (temperature, air humidity) - in this case, you do not have to worry about heat exchange because air circulation is maintained in the server room itself.
    To conclude - I would not go for completely passive solutions, but leave some possibility of installing a fan, at least on the casing. A 12 or 14 cm valve does not spin as terribly fast as those rack jets.



    This Dell is interesting, but I`m afraid it will be power-hungry. I want the equipment to work 24 hours a day. I was thinking about virtualizing the Sophos xg home software, and viewing the reports. See what it looks like in practice. I would also like to set up an exchange server to check how such a mail server is operated. That`s why I want the power consumption to be as low as possible.
  • #9 19011330
    mick1
    Level 22  
    Wait, you need a quiet computer in a rack case - each server will be rather quiet and not very energy efficient (especially when we are talking about post-lease users).
    A better solution is to buy a rack case and put a desktop motherboard + processor inside.
    Moreover, learning hyper-v or VMware on one server makes no sense (unless you nest virtualization, but then the server makes no sense).
    And the one from auction 9450728514 - it is neither energy-saving (and not because of two power supplies - it doesn`t really matter - TDP 95W processor) or rack-mount.
    I had 3 "servers" based on C2558 to learn (but these were the times of ESX 6.0 - 6.5)
  • #10 19011730
    KOCUREK1970
    Network and Internet specialist
    @xendenn
    Or maybe instead, some ready-made Mabo with SoC? - the casing is used, the frame is the same, the power supply does not have to be of the high-end class and the power of 1kW is used, there is also a used disk for it, and also a used device.
    Here is a link to see what I mean:
    https://www.morele.net/kategoria/plyty-glowne-42/,,,,,,,,,,8173O364779/1/
  • #11 19012176
    MrGruffi
    Level 12  
    I had a Dell T110 16GB RAM with a 4-port Intel card. The size of a regular PC and grows like a PC-et ;)
  • #12 19540770
    xendenn
    Level 3  
    I chose HP Microserver Gen10 - quiet, efficient equipment.

Topic summary

The discussion revolves around finding a quiet and energy-efficient server suitable for learning Hyper-V and VMware virtualization in a home environment. The Dell R210 is initially considered, but concerns about its noise levels in a small apartment arise. Participants suggest alternatives, emphasizing that rack-mounted servers typically have noisy fans and may not be energy-efficient. Recommendations include looking for tower cases or desktop solutions, such as the Primergy TX120 S3P and HP Microserver Gen10+, which are noted for being quieter and more efficient. The importance of compatibility with newer virtualization software versions is also highlighted, along with the suggestion that a desktop PC with sufficient RAM and a suitable processor might suffice for learning purposes.
Summary generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT