Shifting Gears without Clutch Depressed: Stationary & Engine Off Gearbox Damage?

Question

Hello

Recently, I was wondering if shifting gears without the clutch depressed, when stationary and with the engine off, could damage the gearboxes ??
A colleague insists yes, I don't think so.

What do the specialists say?

?

marek1977 · Answer

Not

Anonymous · Answer

Generally not, although a situation known as jammed box can occur.

romoo · Answer

This, without assuming a new topic, asks if in Laguna 1 the chests in 1.8 and 3.0 are the same to the size and I have heard that those with 1.8 will not withstand the torque from the 3.0 engine

Sorry, I can't press HELP.

Anonymous · Answer

Yes, som. How not even what the hammer is for. Works miracles, anything can be done. You need to know how to do it It is not allowed at a standstill, you can even break the clutch shaft or your forearm, if you insist.

Jarosx9 · Answer

If someone has the power of the Terminator, it can break, especially if the modes in the chest are set so that there is some resistance to the change, but when you throw it slowly, it shouldn't be a problem.

Anonymous · Answer

In my opinion, nothing can go wrong. Because if the engine is not working, what does it matter if the clutch is pressed or not? Sometimes, while waiting for someone in the car, I play with gears without pressing the clutch and nothing happens. And the fact that the clutch shaft can break, my friend wrote in jokes.

Anonymous · Answer

Yeah! This is now the rest of the FOS advice, schematics indicated. Yeah! If someone does not have the strength of the Terminator, sometimes he will not unscrew / knock out something / even download the drum. But that's not the Terminator thread, is it?

wopor · Answer

hello, I happened to drive 500 km in the days of Jaruzel without a clutch on FSO 1500 se fluid leaked, and I had to find someone who had seals, and this was outside Jaruzel's jurisdiction, under the patronage of Gorbachev so you can, as we all have the right to spoil the car , unfortunately, I failed to spoil him, continued, greetings, and so on the margins, people, however, sometimes have interesting topics for reflection

Anonymous · Answer

It's still nothing, go downstairs, only the guy rockes. If I had such advisers, I would not have undone any screw in my life.

Anonymous · Answer

Once I drove around 50 km in a polonaise with a broken clutch cable, I passed two cities. I also started off the lights a few times, nothing happened to the gearbox. Later, I had a similar situation of driving another car. Once a guy made a bet with me a liter that I would not be able to move without pressing the clutch, knock the gears one by one, then reduce it to one. We drank my winning vodka with relish.

Anonymous · Answer

Well, everyone knows that once the boxes did not have synchronizers. Somehow the gears were changing, such a magic word intergaz. I once won a bottle, because apparently it is impossible to start a toddler from three. It can be done without even burning the shield. In order to break your teeth while operating a lever, you must actually be a Terminator. Sooner the mechanism of change will crumble. Well, for this you need to know how what works, unfortunately books will not help some.

Anonymous · Answer

Well, Polonez or Escort, synchronizers rather have it.

Anonymous · Answer

Sure. You know what I'm making fun of.

romoo · Answer

Pudzianowski's truth is not enough.

KOGUT111 · Answer

Maja, but how long will it be like this !!!

marmaro · Answer

In old cars, maybe in new ones you would have to work hard to break something.

Anonymous · Answer

I guess it's the other way around. The old cars were made more solidly. I doubt if any modern car will be operational in 30 years.

kubicak · Answer

When I had a cut leg on the ankle and 16 stitches, I used the clutch only to start and then intergas and a gentle gear change without grinding. nothing was damaged for almost a month. But it's better not to risk it for the layman.

coverled · Answer

Buddy owik, I moved my toddler from four. Not tightened "lollipop" and you have to go home. After a long swing with the lever, I managed to get 4.
When it comes to changing gears without using the clutch on the so-called "intergas", it is possible to gently without scraping. Sensitive without the use of terminator power.
With a broken clutch cable, start the car on the thrown one. A few kangaroos, lightly gauze and off we go

It works well on straight sections of the road, of course, it is not necessary to drive around the city ...

Shifting Gears without Clutch Depressed: Stationary & Engine Off Gearbox Damage?

Post #1

Post #2

Post #3

Post #4

Post #5

Post #6

Post #7

Post #8

Post #9

Post #10

Post #11

Post #12

Post #13

Post #14

Post #15

Post #16

Post #17

Post #18

Post #19

Post #20

Topic summary