logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Choosing an Aluminum Radiator for a 25 sq m Room with a 12-Rib Cast Iron Radiator

nprince 39312 11
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 15121331
    nprince
    Level 10  
    I intend to replace a cast iron radiator with an aluminum one. Currently, I have a 12-rib cast iron radiator, a room of 25 sq m, tight plastic windows, walls and insulated ceilings. I keep the temperature on the stove at 60 degrees. Unfortunately, it is difficult for me to heat this room with such a temperature on the stove.
    Which aluminum radiator do you recommend using and how much space does it need along with the accessories?

    Choosing an Aluminum Radiator for a 25 sq m Room with a 12-Rib Cast Iron Radiator
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #3 15122655
    Jamesbond664478
    Level 20  
    12 ribs per 25m2 is a bit too little. At least 20 ribs. The longer radiator (e.g. 20 fins) must be cross-connected, i.e. the supply on the opposite side of the return, if the radiators are side-fed. Buy a radiator with more fins
  • #4 15122929
    Zbigniew Rusek
    Level 38  
    What all this for. I have 10 S-130 ribs in 19m2 - the equivalent of a T-1 (flat in a block of flats, 6th floor, theoretically moderately insulated, windows leaky from the People's Republic of Poland) and it is often overheated and practically needs to be screwed on all the time. The supply temperature rarely exceeds 60 degrees (with greater frosts) and 70 degrees is already in a really harsh winter (theoretically the maximum is 80 degrees). In general, one thing is the temperature on the stove and the other is the flow through the radiator. It may be that, for example, the supply water is hot (e.g. 70 degrees) and the radiator heats only slightly with the top, and the bottom is cold at all, because there is poor flow. Maybe it is worth increasing the flow through the already existing radiator and the number of fins will be sufficient (by the way, for me the supply and return twig is only 3/8 '' in diameter). And is the heating pump or gravity? With gravity the flow is always smaller (despite the larger diameter of the pipes) and more fins are always given than with pump heating.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #5 15123162
    Anonymous
    Level 1  
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #6 15123814
    nprince
    Level 10  
    101pawel wrote:
    Assuming you have this room insulated reasonably well, use about 80 W / m? - this gives the required power of a set of about 2000 W, which will be around 14 to 16 ribs. So that you do not think too much, - buy 16 pcs.

    I am considering a combination of 2 10-rib radiators type G 500 F KFA 789-100-44

    Choosing an Aluminum Radiator for a 25 sq m Room with a 12-Rib Cast Iron Radiator


    After shortening the current twigs (0.5 inch), I will have a usable space of 180 cm
    2 radiators is 160 cm - so there is about 20 cm for the accessories. Is it enough and what accessories do I need to purchase?
    There must be a thermostatic head and shut-off valves. Is 20 cm enough for this equipment?
    How many cm is needed to connect both radiators?
    Thermostatic heads are in the price range from 40 to 200 PLN - how do they differ?
    Is it worth combining with a cross connection? The extra 0.5 inch tube under the radiator looks boring :(
  • #7 15123876
    Wlodek22
    Level 31  
    What about the rest of the installation?
    If it is supposed to be the only new one among the old ones, you will not be too warm.
  • #8 15124753
    Jamesbond664478
    Level 20  
    It all depends on whether the installation is pumping or gravity. You didn't write this. The radiators are screwed from the inside with special radiator nipples "to the forehead" and you do not know the radiator connection. If you are on gravity, then there must be a cross connection, otherwise the radiator will only heat up to half its width, and then it will be cooler
  • #9 15124928
    nprince
    Level 10  
    The installation is pumped, so there will be no problem.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #10 15125998
    Wlodek22
    Level 31  
    More than one was surprised.
  • #11 15127194
    Zbigniew Rusek
    Level 38  
    20 ribs will be too much for this room, the more that the aluminum ones are more efficient than the cast iron ones. Even the 16 ribs proposed in one post will be too many.
  • #12 15519889
    nprince
    Level 10  
    I have 20 aluminum fins and it is much warmer than with cast iron. There were no problems with the replacement because the spacing of the twigs at the cast iron and aluminum radiators is the same.

Topic summary

The discussion revolves around replacing a 12-rib cast iron radiator with an aluminum radiator in a 25 sq m room. Users suggest that the current radiator is insufficient for heating, recommending at least 16 to 20 ribs for adequate warmth, considering the room's insulation and the heating system's efficiency. The importance of proper flow and installation type (pumped vs. gravity) is emphasized, with suggestions for accessories like thermostatic heads and shut-off valves. The user contemplates using two 10-rib G 500 F KFA radiators, ensuring enough space for connections and accessories. The efficiency of aluminum radiators compared to cast iron is noted, with some users reporting significant improvements in heating performance.
Summary generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT