logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Cortanin F: Effectiveness for Restoring Old Agricultural Machine with Rust Issues

Xantix 66468 18
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 15646525
    Xantix
    Level 41  
    Hello colleagues. I have a question. Well, I wanted to restore an old agricultural machine that had been standing outside for over a dozen years. Paint peeled off in many places and rust appeared. I have nothing to clean the rust from the bare sheet metal and therefore I thought to bind it with the preparation: Cortanin F. And here is my question - have any of your colleagues met with this preparation? How effective is it? Is it profitable to use it? Or is it a waste of money? Or maybe there is a better means to this end? Greetings.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • Helpful post
    #2 15646636
    tzok
    Moderator of Cars
    It's a waste of money ... its only advantage is a nice smell, because it is a spirit varnish with tannin (or "oak bark tincture"). There are more effective preparations such as R-Stop or Kompleksor 2000, but it still makes sense to use them as a last resort, only where there is no access to mechanically remove rust.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • Helpful post
    #3 15649461
    deus.ex.machina
    Level 32  
    It is a preparation based on orthophosphoric acid that converts the rust into a stable form of oxide that provides adequate protection.
    The mentioned tannin acts as a corrosion inhibitor.
    As for effectiveness - it all depends on the substrate - almost every rust preparation uses a similar mechanism.

    Much more expensive formulations may offer higher efficacy, but in the end, nothing lasts forever and only full passivation of the object provides lasting protection.

    Cortanin F prepares the substrate for painting, you can look for reactive primers that offer greater durability, you can use ready-made reactive coatings - it all depends on what you are protecting and under what conditions and what it is exposed to.

    There are various industrial preparations (shipbuilding, hydraulic installations, etc.), unfortunately, sometimes difficult to obtain, but rather decent quality due to their intended use.

    Cortanin himself is not bad (just like Corin's paint) - you just have to be able to use it and secure it properly in practice, it means that you do not have to reckon with someone who performs the service for a fee - if you do not do it yourself, you have a problem.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • Helpful post
    #4 15649585
    brofran
    Level 41  
    I have used Cortanin and Fosol. In my opinion, Fosol is doing better. Both preparations require removal of loose rust before removing Fosol with water. You can also use Hamerait and its counterparts, but it is more expensive to play with.
  • #5 15649608
    Xantix
    Level 41  
    And this Fosol, if I'm not mistaken, is such a caustic agent that removes rust? Because Cortanin, as far as I know, is associated with rust, not removing it ...
  • Helpful post
    #6 15649751
    deus.ex.machina
    Level 32  
    Xantix wrote:
    And this Fosol, if I'm not mistaken, is such a caustic agent that removes rust? Because Cortanin, as far as I know, is associated with rust, not removing it ...


    This is the same with the difference that Cortanin has a tannin that acts as a corrosion inhibitor - both agents convert the rust or iron III oxide to iron phosphate.
    A condition for any rust removal to be successful is that any loose rust is removed but not bare metal. This is the most common mistake - people will clean it down to metal, give it a complexor and then they are surprised that everything flakes off and falls off - reactive preparations have to react with iron oxide and not with iron as such (simplify because it is about iron alloys mainly with carbon).
  • Helpful post
    #8 15650100
    KaW
    Level 34  
    I use Cortanin F. Simple - it does not require any special treatment
    surface. Wet the corroded coating and then set the agent
    rust and its products. Dries and forms a coating-primer for painting. It is worth buying more to have the freedom to paint the surface - with a small excess. Running for missing amounts is more expensive.
  • Helpful post
    #9 15650800
    kgs245
    Level 17  
    At the end of the 1980s (Cortanin was a novelty then) I painted some metal elements, red, but without loose rust, twice, the second time after the first layer had dried, and then heated while still wet, or you can say baked on an electric cooker plate. These elements were not covered with any other paint after this treatment, and to this day they look as if they were covered with a colorless varnish and so far no new traces of corrosion can be seen. I also used a reactive primer used in car varnishing, but the metal was probably too little ore because after a year, the acrylic lacquer, exposed to weather conditions, went away together with the primer. With the brunox preparation, the story was that it created a nice surface for the varnish, but after some time it fell off together with the rust layer in places where it could not be removed thoroughly. As you can see, there are many different methods and only the right choice for specific conditions will give a good effect and you will not be able to do without your own attempts, an extremely important condition to read the instructions for use and strictly stick to it
  • Helpful post
    #10 15650955
    tzok
    Moderator of Cars
    Cortanine works but only on a completely rusty surface, there must be no healthy sheet metal or paint residues ... when reacted, it is basically waterproof. Before painting, you need to wait a few days until it dries well, and the unreacted coating (in places where it was applied too thick or where there was no corrosion) must be thoroughly washed off with water.

    Unfortunately, I was also disappointed on Brunox ... this season I will be testing the R-Stop.
  • Helpful post
    #11 15654730
    Dobromir pomysłowy
    Level 23  
    deus.ex.machina wrote:
    A condition for any rust removal to be successful is that any loose rust is removed but not bare metal. This is the most common mistake - people will clean it down to metal, give it a complexor and then they are surprised that everything flakes off and falls off - reactive preparations have to react with iron oxide and not with iron as such
    I trust you know each other. I painted a cleaned sheet with Fosol a long time ago, something rust remained, but the sheet metal without any painting in dry conditions, without a trace of corrosion.
  • #12 15654923
    deus.ex.machina
    Level 32  
    Dobromir pomysłowy wrote:
    deus.ex.machina wrote:
    A condition for any rust removal to be successful is that any loose rust is removed but not bare metal. This is the most common mistake - people clean to metal, give a complexor and then are surprised that everything flakes off and falls off - reactive preparations have to react with iron oxide and not with iron as such
    I trust you know each other. I painted a cleaned sheet with Fosol a long time ago, something rust remained, but the sheet metal without any painting in dry conditions, without a trace of corrosion.


    https://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fosforanowanie

    Fosol, Cortanin and the mass of preparations based on phosphoric acid do exactly the same. While maintaining the technological regime described by the manufacturer and additional protection (coating increasing the mechanical parameters), such a process is really good.

    In the case of car body repairs (but not only - wherever possible), I would personally choose tinning / thermal lead as a substitute for electrolytic cadmium plating.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0X6E5HuOd4
  • #13 15656585
    Dobromir pomysłowy
    Level 23  
    Wiki does not confirm what you write, it even contradicts it. And when it comes to tinning, if you pay 1000 papers, you can do it anyway :)
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #14 15657564
    deus.ex.machina
    Level 32  
    Dobromir pomysłowy wrote:
    Wiki does not confirm what you write, it even contradicts it. And when it comes to tinning, if you pay 1000 papers, you can do it anyway :)


    Seriously? And where does it even deny it?

    Come on with that 1000 bits - it's a matter of laziness and lack of knowledge rather than money. Few of them offer such a service, even if they could expect a higher payment.
  • #15 15658083
    Dobromir pomysłowy
    Level 23  
    deus.ex.machina wrote:
    they have to react with iron oxide and not with iron
    -
    ... the process of chemical production of a protective matt-gray phosphate coating on the surface of metals (mainly steel). It can be used in both tool steel and stainless steel knives.
  • #16 15659961
    deus.ex.machina
    Level 32  
    Dobromir pomysłowy wrote:
    deus.ex.machina wrote:
    they have to react with iron oxide and not with iron
    -
    ... the process of chemical production of a protective matt-gray phosphate coating on the surface of metals (mainly steel). It can be used in both tool steel and stainless steel knives.


    Hot acid bath and before the corrosion process begins - creating a phosphate layer prevents corrosion, but when the oxide layer (rust) already exists, the oxide is converted to phosphate.

    There is no contradiction to the wikipedia article and derusting - the difference is simply the way and when the process takes place and the layer itself.
    It seemed obvious to me that the point here is to show that the process itself using a specific substance (phosphoric acid) is an industrial and quite common process.
  • Helpful post
    #17 15660227
    Anonymous
    Level 1  
  • Helpful post
    #18 15660457
    Dobromir pomysłowy
    Level 23  
    As the rusty metal will form a coating faster, you can paint it at once, top 2 and the end. It will create a coating resistant not only to water and oxygen, etc., but also mechanically weak. And when we have the next paint, apply it after a few hours, rinse off the remnants of the preparation (because the paint may flake off). Unless there is thick rust or you paint with a diluted preparation, you should paint 2-3 layers. In the case of non-rusted metal, it takes longer time and hot can be used.
  • #19 15705781
    Xantix
    Level 41  
    Thanks to colleagues for helpful advice. I close the topic.

Topic summary

Cortanin F is a rust treatment preparation that converts rust into a stable oxide, providing a protective layer for metal surfaces. Users report mixed effectiveness, with some suggesting it is not the best option compared to alternatives like R-Stop, Kompleksor 2000, and Fosol, which may offer better results. Cortanin F is noted for its ease of use, requiring no special surface treatment, and it acts as a primer for painting. However, it is essential to remove loose rust before application for optimal results. Some users have had success with Cortanin F over long periods, while others have experienced flaking when not applied correctly. The discussion emphasizes the importance of proper surface preparation and the potential for using reactive primers for enhanced durability.
Summary generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT