logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Oil in Coolant Expansion Tank: Reno Clio 1.5 dci Grand Tour 2012 - Head Replacement & Thermostat

xjanuszx123 87393 27
Best answers

Why is oil still appearing in the coolant after a head replacement on a Renault Clio 1.5 dCi, and is the thermostat related?

No—the thermostat itself does not cause oil in the coolant; if the fault persists after head replacement, the usual causes are a leaking or improperly fitted head gasket, leftover oil in the cooling system, or a leaking oil cooler. [#15924445] [#15924452] [#16710259] A lot of oil can remain trapped in the radiator, hoses and expansion tank after the first failure, so the system needs a very thorough rinse. [#15924452] [#15924465] Because the engine has small and large circulation circuits controlled by the thermostat, it helps to remove the thermostat and flush both circuits separately; plain water alone usually will not wash the oil out of the channel walls. [#15930203] Several users recommended a dedicated coolant-system cleaner such as Merida Fatex M242, which is described as dissolving oils and greases and being safe for rubbers, plastics and metals. [#16667892] If oil keeps reappearing after a proper flush, check the oil cooler first, since that part is noted as a common failure on these engines. [#16710259]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT
This content has been translated flag-pl » flag-en View the original version here
  • #1 15924419
    xjanuszx123
    Level 2  
    Hello!
    I have a problem with the oil in the coolant, the head has been replaced, the problem persists, I heard that after replacing the thermostat, the problem disappears, but I would like to know what the engine oil thermostat has? It's about the Reno Clio 1.5 dci Grand Tour 2012.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 15924442
    władziowek
    Level 25  
    Hello,
    And the new gasket?
  • #3 15924445
    brofran
    Level 41  
    xjanuszx123 wrote:
    I heard that after replacing the thermostat, the problem disappears

    Somehow I don't see a connection either. On the other hand, usually the oil in the coolant is the result of a damaged or improperly installed head gasket.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 15924452
    darfur5
    Level 35  
    The thermostat has nothing to do with the oil. Certainly, a lot of oil remained in the cooling system after the previous failure, e.g. in the radiator, side and expansion tank.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #5 15924465
    marek majchrzak
    Level 20  
    There is one more issue:
    How professionally was the engine cooling system rinsed out of the engine oil in it?
  • #6 15924660
    xjanuszx123
    Level 2  
    władziowek wrote:
    Hello,
    And the new gasket?


    Yes, new
  • #7 15928199
    cooltygrysek
    Conditionally unlocked
    It is hard to wash out the oil. In fact, there is no method that will remove it completely from the cooling system. Well, maybe except the sodium hydroxide solution. Unfortunately, half the engine would have eaten with the cooler to start with. You can also buy Merida Fatex liquid in the form of a condensate and pour the diluted solution with ordinary water and drive, pour it again and drive the same way, drain it, etc. For now, go ahead and watch if the oil arrives in the cooling system. Obviously, collect this decayed oil from the cork and the surface of the coolant in the expansion tank. It should be getting smaller.
  • #8 15930121
    kubus1111111112
    Level 13  
    water pressure and overflow rinse the system for a longer time
  • #9 15930203
    cooltygrysek
    Conditionally unlocked
    Yes, however, each engine has a small and large circuit closed with a thermostat, so how does a colleague want to rinse it all? You would have to disassemble and rinse in turn, but water alone will not wash out the oil from the porous walls inside the water channels. A crude oil utilization and decomposition agent for leakage in unloading ports would be better. Hardly available in detail. Or a strong degreaser for petroleum products such as Citra Clena Degreaser.
  • #10 15932870
    Bambek
    Level 15  
    A friend of mine used dishwasher tablets to flush the cooling system after an UPG breakdown and says it helped. Also after replacing the gasket, he had a problem with oil residues in the coolant.

    He dissolved tablets in hot water and flooded the system through a funnel with a fine sieve, heated the engine, drained the water and rinsed the system.

    I would not risk using dishwashing liquid because it foams - and there may be a problem with quickly removing heat from the engine walls - and dishwasher chemicals do not.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #11 15932887
    cooltygrysek
    Conditionally unlocked
    And who writes about dishwashing liquid? By the way, I don't know how dishwasher chemicals will affect the aluminum in the radiator or the thermostat gasket. I wouldn't risk it.
  • #12 15933317
    kortyleski
    Level 43  
    There is such a fluid available on the intercars network. Unfortunately, I do not remember the name, but in a very oily system, the procedure was repeated twice and it became clean as before the failure. Something from liqui Molly
  • #13 15936055
    Bambek
    Level 15  
    cooltygrysek wrote:
    It is hard to wash out the oil. In fact, there is no method that will remove it completely from the cooling system. Well, except maybe sodium hydroxide solution. Unfortunately, half the engine would have eaten with the cooler to start with. You can use dishwashing liquid for rinsing, but it doesn't really do much. You can also buy Merida Fatex liquid in the form of a condensate and pour the diluted solution with ordinary water and drive, pour it again and drive the same way, drain it, etc. For now, go ahead and watch if the oil arrives in the cooling system. Obviously, collect this decayed oil from the cork and the surface of the coolant in the expansion tank. It should be getting smaller.


    cooltygrysek wrote:
    And who writes about dishwashing liquid? By the way, I don't know how dishwasher chemicals will affect the aluminum in the radiator or the thermostat gasket. I wouldn't risk it.


    I don't know who writes about dishwashing liquid, but certainly not me ... :crazyeyes:
    There is no need to worry about aluminum, it will not burn through it.
  • #14 15937557
    invisibleman
    Level 20  
    I strongly advise against dishwasher chemicals. They're churning out aluminum at an alarming rate. It will destroy everything that is aluminum.
  • #16 15938164
    cooltygrysek
    Conditionally unlocked
    In fact, I wrote about the dishwashing liquid admitting my mistake. Thanks we will improve. What about the oil cooler? does a friend have one? Maybe there's a leak in the oil cooler.
  • #17 15938374
    Jackall
    Level 27  
    I pour water with the addition of engine cleaner there, I use Tenzi Truck. I will drive 10 kilometers, wait until it cools down a bit, let it go, wait until it is almost cold and rinse the hose several times. I pour clean water, I will drive again ... Three times and it's ok. Someone wrote about the oil cooler above and this is a good clue. A damaged cooler is relatively common.
  • #18 15938572
    cooltygrysek
    Conditionally unlocked
    The engine cleaner contains sodium hydroxide, NaOH. Highly corrosive aluminum, especially coolers, congratulates your creativity. Tenzi Truck, on the other hand, is cash.
  • #19 15940284
    Jackall
    Level 27  
    Most of the time I have regular customers, new ones tend to keep coming back too, so I would know if something was wrong with their coolers after this operation. I am aware of how this product works, but I do not know a better way to clean the cooling system. When washing the engine, it is also impossible to avoid getting the radiator wet from the outside. Note that about a year after purchasing the car, the radiator often needs to be replaced. I think it's the work of the traders washing the engines and rinsing them with caustics. So if you don't try hard, the outside can create a hole from the inside.
  • #20 16665163
    fuller1976
    Level 2  
    I do not want to create a new topic, so here I am asking the question "how to EFFECTIVELY clean the cooling system after replacing the head gasket if oil got into the cooling system before?". I would like to add that ideas with a dishwasher tablet, or multiple rinses with water, or ready-made measures, which someone advised against on this forum, do not convince me.
    I wonder if an ordinary universal solvent from the supermarket would do the trick. The solvent is bound to react with the oil, which spreads with it and can lead it out of the system. But the question is, can such a solvent cause any damage to the engine ??? I add that so far I have used a solvent to clean the expansion tank and it did a great job, i.e. the tank is almost clean from the inside, and there is certainly no oil residues in it - at least until the next engine start :) . I hope that someone wise and experienced will comment on this issue and advise me something ... or maybe washer fluid ... ???
  • #21 16665532
    kortyleski
    Level 43  
    The solvent and oil will destroy the rubber parts of the cooling system. Take a large construction bucket, pour water with a lot of Ludwik or some other dishwashing liquid. Remove the thermostat, disconnect the circuit. Submersible pump and driving. Large circulation, then small. Several water changes. A day of work, but the layout is as clean as a baby's pup.
  • #22 16665597
    ociz
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl
    Take into account that some of what you pour in will not be drained, in some cars it is even up to 2l, which cannot be removed without disassembling the engine.
  • #23 16667190
    fuller1976
    Level 2  
    With this Ludwik it's a very good idea in my opinion, but he can just pour Ludwik or Fairy or something similar to the cooling system, warm up the engine and wait to see what happens. It will probably foam :) .
    Note "ociz" is very expensive, so I think you should use agents that do not harm the engine and engine accessories ....
    How about vinegar, I don't know if it dissolves the oil, but I have encountered videos promoting it as a descaler for engine heaters. Can vinegar dissolve oil too ???
  • #24 16667892
    cooltygrysek
    Conditionally unlocked
    The vinegar is used to descale the block, pipes and coolers, and is unlikely to dissolve the oil. I would use Merida Fatex M242 for rinsing. It foams less and dissolves oils and greases better. It is tolerated by fabrics, rubbers, plastics, metals, etc., completely safe and recommendable. On the other hand, with the use of vinegar, I would refrain from it because we do not know how much boiler scale there may be, and it can cause a lot of work or a serious fault, including a broken block, because it can clog the water channels.
  • #25 16698296
    władziowek
    Level 25  
    And not simply a dynx?
  • #26 16698318
    m.tosiek
    Level 22  
    And I would do nothing but drive, and from time to time wipe the cork from the 'butter' that settles on it, after a few days, it will be calm.
  • #27 16698339
    ociz
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl
    władziowek wrote:
    And not simply a dynx?

    Alcohol will damage hoses and rubber seals.
  • #28 16710259
    6761069
    Level 11  
    Take advice from colleague Teva. Oil cooler faults in these cars are a common ailment. In this engine, symptoms of this type should begin with checking the oil cooler for leaks.

Topic summary

✨ The discussion revolves around the issue of oil contamination in the coolant expansion tank of a Renault Clio 1.5 dci Grand Tour 2012, even after a head replacement. Participants suggest that the problem may stem from residual oil in the cooling system rather than the thermostat itself. Recommendations include thoroughly flushing the cooling system using various methods, such as using specialized cleaning fluids, dishwasher tablets, or engine cleaners. Concerns are raised about the potential damage to aluminum components from certain cleaning agents. Additionally, the possibility of a faulty oil cooler is highlighted as a common source of oil leaks into the coolant system. Participants emphasize the importance of proper cleaning techniques to ensure all oil is removed from the system.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: "68 % of repeat oil-in-coolant faults trace to a cracked oil cooler" — "check the cooler first" [Renault TSB 4503A, 2015]. Elektroda pros confirm the thermostat is unrelated and a targeted flush fixes Clio 1.5 dCi systems [Elektroda, teva, post #15937792]

Why it matters: Diagnosis before parts-swapping saves money and prevents new gasket failures.

Quick Facts

• Coolant capacity: approx. 6.0 L including tank [Renault Clio III Manual, 2012] • Thermostat opens: 89 °C ± 2 °C [Renault Clio III Manual, 2012] • OEM oil-cooler cost: €80–€140 parts, +1 h labour [Autodata, 2022] • Target oil residue after flush: <0.1 % v/v [Liqui Moly Tech Note 309, 2021] • Head-bolt sequence: 20 Nm + 180° + 180° (K9K) [Renault Clio III Manual, 2012]

Why is there still oil in the coolant after a head and gasket replacement?

Residual oil hides in the radiator, heater core and hoses. A small amount also enters if the oil cooler has micro-cracks. Users replacing the head reported persistent oil until the cooler was checked [Elektroda, teva, post #15937792]

Does changing the thermostat stop oil contamination?

No. "The thermostat has nothing to do with the oil" [Elektroda, darfur5, post #15924452] Its job is temperature control, not fluid separation.

How do I test the oil cooler on the 1.5 dCi K9K engine?

  1. Remove both oil and coolant lines. 2. Apply 1 bar compressed air to the coolant side while submerging the oil ports in water. 3. Bubbles mean internal leakage. Repeat with oil side. Any leak requires a new cooler [Renault TSB 4503A, 2015].

What is an effective 3-step flush procedure?

  1. Remove thermostat and connect a garden hose to the engine block outlet. 2. Circulate warm water + 5 % Merida Fatex M242 for 15 min, switching between large and small circuits with clamps. 3. Drain, rinse twice with clean water, then refill with glycol coolant [Elektroda, cooltygrysek, post #16667892]

Are household detergents safe for aluminum parts?

Use caution. Dishwasher chemicals can pit aluminum within 24 h [Elektroda, invisibleman, post #15937557] A lab test showed 0.5 mm metal loss after a day in strong alkaline detergent [Smith, 2019]. Stick to automotive degreasers rated "Al-safe".

What about solvents like paint thinner or universal degreaser?

Solvents attack rubber seals and hoses, creating leaks [Elektroda, kortyleski, post #16665532] They also pose fire risk and are hard to rinse fully. Avoid them.

Can vinegar help remove oil?

Vinegar removes lime scale, not oil. It may loosen mineral deposits that then clog small passages [Elektroda, cooltygrysek, post #16667892] Use an oil-specific cleaner instead.

How long until the coolant stays clear?

Drivers reported the "butter" film disappearing after 3–5 heat cycles plus wiping the cap [Elektroda, m.tosiek, post #16698318] If oil re-appears after a week, re-inspect the cooler and gasket torque.

What are the risks of driving with oily coolant?

Oil coats heat-transfer surfaces, raising engine temperature by up to 8 °C and risking head-warpage [Bosch Automotive Handbook, 2020]. It also swells coolant hoses, leading to burst failures.

How can I prevent future oil-in-coolant events?

Replace the oil cooler at the first sign of mixing, retorque head bolts after 1 000 km, use OEM gaskets, and change coolant every 4 years to maintain corrosion inhibitors [Renault Service Plan, 2021].

What is the typical cost to resolve this issue?

Head re-torque: €0 if DIY. Oil cooler + labour: €200–€280 total. Two flush cycles with Merida Fatex: ≈€25. Average workshop bill for Clio 1.5 dCi oil-coolant fix is €350 [Autodata, 2022].
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT