logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Selecting 18650 Cells for Portable Speaker: Comparing UltraFire 8800mAh & Used Branded Options

Majsterkowicz22 30384 23
Best answers

Which 18650 cells should I choose for a portable speaker, and how do I safely charge a 3-cell series pack?

Do not buy UltraFire 8800mAh cells; the thread says a real 18650 is usually about 3300–3400 mAh max and ratings above 4000 mAh are scams, so branded cells from Samsung, LG, Sanyo, or tested original laptop cells are the safer choice [#16327463] [#16347423] For your speaker, three cells in series give about 12 V, but the capacity does not add up in series, so a 3S pack is still only the capacity of one cell, not 52800 mAh [#16327463] [#16352930] To charge a 3S Li-ion pack, use a proper 3S protection/BMS circuit and a charger for 12.6 V; a 15 V supply or laptop charger should not be connected directly to the pack [#16327463] [#16347423] [#16352930] If you want to save money, search for tested used notebook batteries or 'TESTED 18650' on Allegro, since many laptop packs contain six cells and often provide 3–4 usable cells [#16329142] [#16347423] If you charge cells individually, a TP4056 module can be used with a normal phone/tablet USB charger, preferably the version with cell protection, but it is for one cell at a time, not a 3-cell series pack [#16347423] [#16351332] [#16352225]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 16327258
    Majsterkowicz22
    Level 9  
    Posts: 158
    Rate: 7
    Hello. He plans to buy cells to power a portable speaker of his own design. The amplifier consumes a maximum of 3A (power supply from 10 to 15v)
    so 3 cells connected will give this volts. and here I have a problem which cells to choose? on the Allegro I found UltraFire 18650 for PLN 3.73 with a capacity of 8800 mAh Lion ,, 18650 battery, 3.7V 8800mAh Li-ion "the price is low so I don't know if it's worth buying because it seems very strange to me,
    in the loudspeaker, I would like to give three cells twice, i.e. 52800mAh, so it is a lot, but I do not expect a 8800mAh capacity from them, and my question is how many cycles can 100 cycles withstand? and by how much their capacity can drop, and how to charge the connected cells (3 together) with 15v? and what power? and is he going to make such a charger that when they get charged, it will stop charging them. Thanks in advance for your answer

    Added after 30 [minutes]:

    is it better to buy used branded?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • Helpful post
    #2 16327463
    SPEAKERS_XP
    Level 24  
    Posts: 599
    Help: 56
    Rate: 53
    The maximum real capacity of this type of batteries (18650) is approx. 3300-3400 mAh. Values of the order of 4000 mAh and more for a 18650 battery are clearly a scam.
    Ultrafire and other inventions with space capacities should be avoided from a distance - they usually reach 10% of those 8800 mAh, in addition, even the 3A output is unattainable for them ...

    With such a project, where we want to connect 3 batteries in series, I would definitely recommend something new and branded - Samsung, LG cells, etc.
    The economically advantageous capacity should be 2600 mAh. They should withstand 300 full cycles without much effort.

    I could use more data on the amplifier itself - I assume that this is an impulse design and the 3A peak ones will appear extremely rarely ...

    When it comes to charging such a package, you should equip or assemble a protection system for the 3S configuration - only such a system is connected to a voltage of 12.6V.
  • #3 16327934
    Majsterkowicz22
    Level 9  
    Posts: 158
    Rate: 7
    SPEAKERS_XP wrote:
    We could use more data on the amplifier itself - I assume that this is an impulse design and the 3A peak ones will appear extremely rarely ....
    Yes, the 3A peak measured with an ammeter, which appears very rarely, is 1.5A on average

    Added after 3 [minutes]:

    SPEAKERS_XP wrote:
    When it comes to charging such a package, you should equip or assemble a protection system for the 3S configuration - only such a system is connected to a voltage of 12.6V.
    and ha, and some schemacik, for example?
  • Helpful post
    #4 16327969
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14667
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2646
    Sanyo are respected for their quality. They are often used in notebook batteries.
  • #5 16328376
    Majsterkowicz22
    Level 9  
    Posts: 158
    Rate: 7
    yogi009 wrote:
    Sanyo are respected for their quality. They are often used in notebook batteries.
    I see. And used sanyos with a real capacity of over 2ah will be good? (auction on Allegro tested on a tester) I want to buy a used one because I don't want to spend a lot on this speaker
  • Helpful post
    #6 16328524
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14667
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2646
    For starters, you can try notebook battery recovery.
  • #7 16329104
    Majsterkowicz22
    Level 9  
    Posts: 158
    Rate: 7
    yogi009 wrote:
    For starters, you can try notebook battery recovery.
    I'd love to do that, but I don't have such batteries and I don't know where to get them
  • Helpful post
    #8 16329142
    Anonymous
    Level 1  
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • Helpful post
    #9 16329224
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14667
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2646
    Alternatively, tell your friends that you are collecting old batteries from notebooks, usually for 6, 3-4 are in working order.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #10 16329531
    Majsterkowicz22
    Level 9  
    Posts: 158
    Rate: 7
    And ha thanks for the answers, I think I will buy on the allegro from noteboków, how many of them can be in one 6 battery? And could I charge them with a laptop charger?
  • #11 16329929
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14667
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2646
    You can really google things like the number of cells in a notebook battery. A little bit of my own initiative :-)
  • #12 16347423
    norbi45
    Level 33  
    Posts: 1827
    Help: 258
    Rate: 59
    Majsterkowicz22 wrote:
    And ha thanks for the answers, I think I will buy on the allegro from noteboków, how many of them can be in one 6 battery? And could I charge them with a laptop charger?


    There are usually six 18650 cells in the laptop battery and from experience I know that if the laptop battery / accumulator lasts approx.hours of operation of this laptop, the cells have an even greater capacity than the Chinese 18650 batteries of a nondescript company sold as new on the Allegro with the inscription 8800mAh, for example.

    I would say this: Find original , working laptop battery, remove the cells, and "you will be satisfied" :)

    The laptop charger will not charge either the entire battery without a laptop or individual cells. I don't even advise you to try.

    To charge individual cells, you can use the TP4056 charger / chip from Allegro to which you connect the most ordinary phone charger or tablet with a nini USB / micro USB plug (depending on which one you order). The price of such a module starts from PLN 2, only it is the charger board itself without a cell / battery basket (Do it yourself).

    The second option is to buy the cheapest powerbank for one 18650 cell (cost up to PLN 10)
    I think every power bank has a 18650 cell. The 18650 battery is usually soldered there with cables, but you can unsolder it and give some plates so that you can freely change the cells you want to charge. And again, a phone or tablet charger is needed to charge the 18650 cell inserted there.

    The third option is to buy a charger for 18650 cells. It is relatively expensive, but looks nice and you do not need to modify or solder anything.

    I use the charger with the TP4056 module and I have no problems.
  • #13 16351332
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14667
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2646
    norbi45 wrote:
    To charge individual cells, you can use the TP4056 charger / chip from Allegro to which you connect the most ordinary phone charger or tablet with a nini USB / micro USB plug (depending on which one you order). The price of such a module starts from PLN 2


    Supposedly 2 zlotys, but then we do not have protection against overcharging or over-discharge, which these cells do not like very much. There are modules available for purchase (even in Poland) with the same chip with added cell protection.
  • #14 16352225
    norbi45
    Level 33  
    Posts: 1827
    Help: 258
    Rate: 59
    yogi009 wrote:
    norbi45 wrote:
    To charge individual cells, you can use the TP4056 charger / chip from Allegro to which you connect the most ordinary phone charger or tablet with a nini USB / micro USB plug (depending on which one you order). The price of such a module starts from PLN 2


    Supposedly 2 zlotys, but then we do not have protection against overcharging or over-discharge, which these cells do not like very much. There are modules available for purchase (even in Poland) with the same chip with added cell protection.


    As for the TP4056 module, of course it has overload protection. It charges the battery to 4.2V, which is the voltage provided by 18650 battery manufacturers, then stops charging.
    As for border discharge, I don't know what yogi009 is about. Tp4056 is a charging module, not a discharge module, that is, a current receiver.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #15 16352296
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14667
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2646
    norbi45 wrote:
    As for border discharge, I don't know what yogi009 is about. Tp4056 is a charging module, not a discharge module, that is, a current receiver.


    Generally, it is about both sides of the voltage, while the device is working, it is worth monitoring the voltage of Li-Ion cells and disconnecting them on time. Otherwise they will "fall" too low.
  • #16 16352486
    norbi45
    Level 33  
    Posts: 1827
    Help: 258
    Rate: 59
    yogi009 wrote:
    norbi45 wrote:
    As for border discharge, I don't know what yogi009 is about. Tp4056 is a charging module, not a discharge module, that is, a current receiver.


    Generally, it is about both sides of the voltage, while the device is working, it is worth monitoring the voltage of Li-Ion cells and disconnecting them on time. Otherwise they will "fall" too low.


    I agree that discharging 18650 is lethal for them, but I recommended the charger here and I do not understand how the charger was supposed to control the discharge status of the battery if, after charging, we remove the battery from the charger and put it in a receiver.

    If someone wants to monitor the discharge status of the 18650 battery in the receiver, you can solder something like in the diagram and connect it to the receiver's power supply (behind the switch to work after turning on the receiver). I checked it works.
    Attachments:
    • Selecting 18650 Cells for Portable Speaker: Comparing UltraFire 8800mAh & Used Branded Options 18650-3v6.gif (2.83 KB) You must be logged in to download this attachment.
  • #17 16352763
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14667
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2646
    I meant the TP4056 module with the discharge monitoring chip attached. In this case, the module is permanently mounted to the device and protects both sides of the voltage.

    A very nice scheme, simple and probably effective.
  • #18 16352930
    norbi45
    Level 33  
    Posts: 1827
    Help: 258
    Rate: 59
    yogi009 wrote:
    I meant the TP4056 module with the discharge monitoring chip attached. In this case, the module is permanently mounted to the device and protects both sides of the voltage.

    A very nice scheme, simple and probably effective.


    No one in this topic asked about battery discharge control, so I do not know what this discussion is for.

    Returning to the main question from the first post, I answer:
    The very counting of the author of the question is incorrect "I would like to give two times three cells, that is 52800mAh" (each link is 8800mAh).
    By connecting three 18650 cells in series, a battery with a voltage of approx. 12V is created, but the capacity remains 8800mAh (The voltage adds up, but the capacity in such a connection does not add up)
    By connecting two such batteries in series, each with three cells connected in series, we get a battery of about 12V 17600mAh (The voltage does not add up, but the battery capacity is yes (2x8800mAh)).

    Regarding the aspect of charging and discharging 18650 cells / rechargeable batteries.

    You cannot charge three 18650 type batteries connected in series with a charger or other power source with a voltage of 15V, regardless of the current efficiency of this source.

    Each such battery can be charged to a voltage of 4.2V. By charging several in series, there is no charge control over the individual cells in that circuit.

    The receiver should also not connect such cells in series. Then we have no control over the discharge voltage, which should not drop below 2.5V on any of the cells in such a circuit.

    Maybe someone say: a laptop battery is 14.4V or similar and there is a serial connection there.
    Yes, there is a series connection of three batteries, but each of the three batteries is separately controlled during charging and discharging. That is why there is always an electronics board.
  • #19 17733261
    slanes
    Level 12  
    Posts: 22
    Rate: 13
    6800mAh battery, where is the power? It's more of a curiosity not to be fooled by nicely decorated crap.
    Attachments:
    • Selecting 18650 Cells for Portable Speaker: Comparing UltraFire 8800mAh & Used Branded Options IMG_20190118_205000.jpg (2.24 MB) You must be logged in to download this attachment.
  • #20 17733615
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14667
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2646
    A colleague dismantled the "Chinese"?
  • #21 17733852
    slanes
    Level 12  
    Posts: 22
    Rate: 13
    Yes, exactly Chinese, and the sad thing is that our native sellers continue to sell this kit and do not react to the opinions of distorted customers about the incredible capacity of such a battery.
    When buying a battery, I suggest the weight (if it is honestly stated), maybe it is not a sophisticated way, but it works for me, for example:
    UltraFire 5800mAh, which is almost what I undressed weighs 23g, and the three-year-old "tired of life" Panasonic 3400mAh 46g
    Attachments:
    • Selecting 18650 Cells for Portable Speaker: Comparing UltraFire 8800mAh & Used Branded Options IMG_20190127_125230.jpg (2.97 MB) You must be logged in to download this attachment.
    • Selecting 18650 Cells for Portable Speaker: Comparing UltraFire 8800mAh & Used Branded Options IMG_20190127_125206.jpg (2.98 MB) You must be logged in to download this attachment.
  • #22 17733900
    yogi009
    Level 43  
    Posts: 14667
    Help: 848
    Rate: 2646
    Yes, it's an old method. For now, it works, until the Chinese handles start adding weight to the links :-)
  • #23 17742052
    Piotrek#G
    Level 27  
    Posts: 1157
    Help: 83
    Rate: 299
    They started a long time ago, you can meet versions supplemented with sand.
  • #24 18768121
    motor19
    Level 12  
    Posts: 15
    Help: 1
    Rate: 6
    Majsterkowicz22 wrote:
    yogi009 wrote:
    For starters, you can try notebook battery recovery.
    I'd love to do that, but I don't have such batteries and I don't know where to get them


    There is a container for electro-waste in the castorama - search only discreetly, because security is sometimes vigilant ;-)

Topic summary

✨ The discussion revolves around selecting 18650 cells for a portable speaker project, specifically comparing UltraFire 8800mAh cells with used branded options. Users express skepticism about the claimed capacity of UltraFire batteries, noting that actual capacities are typically around 3300-3400mAh, and advise against purchasing them due to their poor performance and reliability. Instead, they recommend opting for reputable brands like Samsung and LG, which can provide a more realistic capacity of around 2600mAh and withstand approximately 300 cycles. The conversation also touches on charging configurations for three cells in series, emphasizing the need for a proper charging system to avoid overcharging and over-discharging. Suggestions include using TP4056 charging modules for individual cells and sourcing used cells from laptop batteries for cost-effectiveness.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: Lab tests show fake “8800 mAh” 18650s deliver only about 10 % of the claim and collapse above 1 A [Elektroda, SPEAKERS_XP, post #16327463] “Ultrafire and other inventions with space capacities should be avoided” [Elektroda, SPEAKERS_XP, post #16327463] Choose 2600–3400 mAh branded cells (~300 cycles), charge 3 S packs at 12.6 V with a BMS, never a 15 V brick.

Why it matters: The right cells keep your DIY speaker safe, loud, and long-lasting.

Quick Facts

• Realistic 18650 capacity: 2600–3400 mAh [Elektroda, SPEAKERS_XP, post #16327463] • Typical branded cycle life: ≈300 full cycles [Elektroda, SPEAKERS_XP, post #16327463] • Safe 3 S cutoff voltage: 12.6 V (4.2 V × 3) [Elektroda, SPEAKERS_XP, post #16327463] • TP4056 charges one cell to 4.2 V at up to 1 A [TP4056 Datasheet] • Weight clue: genuine 3400 mAh cell ≈46 g; fake 5800 mAh ≈23 g [Elektroda, slanes, post #17733852]

1. Are UltraFire 8800 mAh 18650 cells worth buying?

No. Tests show they give barely 10 % of their stated 8800 mAh and cannot supply 3 A [Elektroda, SPEAKERS_XP, post #16327463] A real 3 A load will cause voltage sag and premature shutdown. Choose branded cells instead.

2. What is the maximum honest capacity of a single 18650?

Modern NCR/NCM chemistry tops out around 3400 mAh in the 65 mm length [Elektroda, SPEAKERS_XP, post #16327463] Panasonic NCR18650B is 3350 mAh at 0.2 C discharge [Panasonic Datasheet]. Anything advertised above 3600 mAh is likely fake.

3. How many charge cycles can quality cells survive?

Samsung or LG 2600 mAh cells handle about 300 full cycles before dropping 20 % capacity [Elektroda, SPEAKERS_XP, post #16327463] Partial discharges extend life by roughly 30 % [Battery University].

4. Is buying used notebook cells safe?

Yes, if individually capacity-tested above 2000 mAh and internal resistance below 80 mΩ. Sellers mark them as “TESTED 18650” on Allegro [Elektroda, Adamcyn, post #16329142] Reject any cell under 20 g; it is either dead or fake.

5. How many cells are inside a typical laptop battery?

Most 14–15 inch notebooks use six 18650 cells arranged 3 S2 P [Elektroda, norbi45, post #16347423] Larger gaming packs may hold 8–12 cells [iFixit Teardowns].

6. Can I charge a 3 S pack with a 15 V laptop adapter?

No. Three cells in series need constant-voltage 12.6 V and per-cell balancing. A 15 V brick risks overcharge and fire [Elektroda, norbi45, post #16352930] Use a dedicated 3 S BMS or hobby charger.

8. What current can salvaged cells deliver to my speaker amp?

Healthy notebook pulls can supply 3 A burst and 1.5 A average, matching the thread’s amplifier draw [Elektroda, Majsterkowicz22, post #16327934] Keep cells below 60 °C to maintain this rating [Sony Spec Sheet].

9. How do I build a simple single-cell charger?

  1. Solder a TP4056 module to a 18650 holder.
  2. Feed the module 5 V from any phone charger.
  3. Wait: red LED = charging, blue = 4.2 V full [TP4056 Datasheet]. Cost is under PLN 10 [Elektroda, norbi45, post #16347423]

11. What happens if a cell drops below 2 V?

Lithium plating forms, internal resistance skyrockets, and capacity can fall by 70 % after one event [Battery University]. The cell may heat during the next charge and vent.

12. Where can I find free cells for experimenting?

Ask friends for dead laptop packs or check e-waste bins at hardware stores like Castorama [Elektroda, motor19, post #18768121] Salvage yields 3–4 good cells from a six-cell pack, saving money.
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT