logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Using Smartphone NFC as SATEL Access Control Card: RFID Key Duplication & Compatibility

PLukowiak 25377 16
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 18049849
    PLukowiak
    Level 9  
    Hello

    I am looking for information whether it is possible to use a smartphone with NFC as an access card for SATEL's access control. From what I can see from the documentation, 125kHz passive transponders are supported. I saw videos on Youtube about copying the RFID key from key fobs, but it does not work too much on the access card.

    Regards
    Peter
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 18310254
    345
    Level 15  
    He has not yet invented a system integrated with the Satel bus. They only give 125khz
  • #3 18314589
    Serwis_LX

    Level 22  
    Recently, we discussed a similar topic with the constructor in the company (it was about an intercom with NFC as a key) - the conclusion was that there was no point in introducing "as standard" a little more complicated to implement and secure technology for the "selected few" and to order people exchange electronic tags when we have perfectly working, simple and widely available technology now. NFC takes some time to roll out to the public sector before it becomes the standard of everything.

    You can always try to copy an RFID tag with youtube or check with Asians - they seem to be living a few years ahead

    You can read about these technologies, for example, here: https://www.nfc24.pl/rfid-nfc and here (it's a study for an economic university): https://www.researchgate.net/publication/3183...hnologii_RFID_i_NFC_w_zastosaniem_biznesowych

    Besides - attack manufacturers with applications for such solutions - nothing but profit works so well for the constructors and company management as a list of e-mails and transcription of telephone calls with customer requests for new functions :)
  • #4 18343328
    Paweldoradca
    Level 13  
    In my opinion, all you need is a mifare card reader and an application on your phone that emulates a card with a permanent id number
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #5 18367985
    345
    Level 15  
    In my opinion, technology is in phones and people cannot do without them. What they have at hand is the most convenient and NFC is already on the market needed in the satellite. This is my opinion, but not only.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #6 18368044
    suworow
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl
    Serwis_LX wrote:
    Recently, we discussed a similar topic with the constructor in the company (it was about an intercom with NFC as a key) - the conclusion was that there was no point in introducing "as standard" a little more complicated to implement and secure technology for the "selected few" and to order people exchange electronic tags when we have perfectly working, simple and widely available technology now.

    And competition (vect) introduced :)
  • #7 18652939
    bercik_gsi
    Level 15  
    I am also thinking about such an application.
    In my opinion, there are at least two roads.
    1. SATEL + ARDUINO / RASPBERRY WITH MODULE
    2. SATEL + INT-RS Plus + RS232 RFID NFC 13.56 MHz (I don't know how yet, because it requires implementation on the side of the reading module)
    3. SATEL + ROGER and MCT80M-BLE module

    Of course, only the integrated control panels come into play ...
  • #8 18654481
    Mscichu
    Level 18  
    Paweldoradca wrote:
    In my opinion, all you need is a mifare card reader and an application on your phone that emulates a card with a permanent id number


    Do you have any proven MIFARE emulator?
  • #9 18999780
    slavo_s2k
    Level 14  
    I am also looking for a solution, at home I have a BCS intercom and an external panel with a MIFARE reader, the phone can be easily recognized when applied, but unfortunately each time a different ID, so I will not save it in the database to open the gate, I have not found a solution for this yet :( so I'd like to hear from you ...
  • #10 18999926
    bercik_gsi
    Level 15  
    I think the intermediate output will be a PROGRAMMABLE STICKER compatible with MIFARE 13.56MHz
  • #11 18999944
    slavo_s2k
    Level 14  
    I did this to my wife, only it has a case and I managed to hide it between the case and the phone, for me without the case it will look average, these stickers are 2.5cm in diameter. [/ U]
  • #12 20520526
    345
    Level 15  
    I don't think the company would lose on Mirafe, on the contrary.
  • #13 20526035
    przeqpiciel
    Network and Internet specialist
    This will sound like a sculpture. However, based on my experience, it would be doable.

    I have a Satel control panel with an ETH module, thanks to which I can arm / disarm the alarm using the external HomeAssistant software. For this reason, if you are able to place something that your phone will read, you will be able to do something with the alarm.
  • #14 20528733
    slavo_s2k
    Level 14  
    Or are there any NFC readers that simply read the signal from a specific phone and change the state of the relay and that's it? this would solve my problem of opening the gate, currently only by application or sticker (which is problematic to use because it is quite thick)?
  • #15 20528976
    gkwiatkowski
    CCTV and Stationary Alarms specialist
    slavo_s2k wrote:
    And are there any NFC readers that simply read the signal from a specific phone and change the state of the relay and that's it? this would solve my problem of opening the gate, currently only by application or sticker (which is problematic to use because it is quite thick)?


    There are NFC/Bluetooth readers, but they require an external controller with a relay.

    https://www.roger.pl/produkty/system-kontroli...s-zblizeniowe-mct/mct80m-ble-terminal-dostepu
  • #16 20528984
    sosarek

    Level 43  
    @gkwiatkowski Centrali with a controller for a given number of passages - totally unprofitable in the case of one door, secondly, the handling of this is also not "pink" because you have to act through the application on the phone, it does not automatically read NFC tags.
    Helpful post? Buy me a coffee.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #17 20528997
    gkwiatkowski
    CCTV and Stationary Alarms specialist
    sosarek wrote:
    Control panel with a controller for a given number of passages - totally unprofitable in the case of one door


    And who will forbid the rich to have an NFC reader opening with the entire access control system?

    Added after 31 [seconds]:

    sosarek wrote:
    secondly, the handling of this is also not "pink" because you have to work through the application on the phone, it does not automatically read NFC tags.


    And that's really pointless.

    Added after 11 [minutes]:

    STid readers

    https://stid-security.com/en/products/categories/210:architect-blue-readers

    They can be configured to read NFC without unlocking the phone. The application must run in the background.
    The price isn't even killer.

Topic summary

The discussion revolves around the feasibility of using a smartphone with NFC technology as an access control card for SATEL systems, which primarily support 125kHz passive RFID transponders. Participants express skepticism about the current integration of NFC into SATEL's offerings, noting that while NFC technology is convenient and widely used, it has not yet been standardized in access control systems. Suggestions include using MIFARE card readers and applications that can emulate card IDs. Some users propose integrating SATEL systems with Arduino or Raspberry Pi for custom solutions, while others mention the potential of programmable stickers compatible with MIFARE technology. The conversation also touches on the need for external controllers and relay systems to facilitate NFC access, with references to specific products that could enable such functionality.
Summary generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT