Anjali... the most obvious problem I could see was that your Non-Inverting input does not have any path to ground. I ran your circuit in Multisim as follows
Sorry - it's a bit small. Now as you see I put in a 1K resistor to ground from the NI input. This should have the effect of reducing the gain by half so you should get a 2.5V output, however it is 2.74 V as you see.I also tried removing R4 and I got an output of 5.225V. So this is what you should have got.I am at a loss to find where the discrepancies come in...I have a theory but need more time to work through it. I think it is because this is a Non-Inverting configuration (in fact effectively it is a differential amp) so the gain equations are not quite the same as the inverting configuration.I'll try and come back to this a bit later, but meantime you should be able to get these results, I suspect you have a wiring fault or bad component somewhere if you do not get these.