logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Recommended Affordable Car Repair Tool Brands & Sets: Yato, Craftsman, KS Tools, Husky, & Lidl

cynamonik 24819 36
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 17397181
    cynamonik
    Level 9  
    Colleagues, what companies do you recommend for car repair keys?

    Of course, we omit top brands and typical for workshops, factories (Snapon, Hazet, Facom, Stahweelie) where it is necessary to ensure maximum quality with very frequent use.

    Personally, I have been using with satisfaction for many years: Craftsman, KS tools, Husky, Yato, Lidl, however, I need to update a bit and optimize the set of tools by buying a new suitcase :)

    I initially selected a few Yato sets:
    http://yato.com/products/4/YT-38782
    http://yato.com/products/4/YT-38875
    http://yato.com/products/4/YT-38872

    on Olx as if a copy of one of them:
    https://www.olx.pl/oferta/zecja-kluczy-nasadowych-108-el-CID628-IDbnyEw.html#00a79223d5
    but the price of 115 PLN is suspiciously low. For example, with Yato, a 50-piece set that is half the size costs about PLN 200 :)

    Lidl offers a nice suitcase:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zY1OWblOrYs
    https://www.lidl.de/de/powerfix-steckschluesselsatz-216-teilig/p242901
    unfortunately not available at the moment.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 17397222
    stalker1995
    Level 21  
    Yato sets will fulfill their role as much as possible, I would look for Toptul or Hans, they are also good sets, the price is also ok.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #3 17397285
    andrzej20001
    Level 43  
    I prefer NEO
  • #4 17397303
    SKM 1964
    Level 34  
    I also have YATO sets, but in single boxes, each of one type. I bought them a long time ago and they still serve me today. They don't advertise the company here, they just fulfill their role. In fact, I use them for my own needs, so rather amateurish. I do not know how with the durability of these keys would be in the workshop ??
    They are in use there all the time. :|
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #5 17397365
    Romek T.
    Level 14  
    The MaXgear suitcase works well, I use it moderately and it lasts :)
    Recommended Affordable Car Repair Tool Brands & Sets: Yato, Craftsman, KS Tools, Husky, & Lidl
  • #7 17397535
    badyl666
    Level 18  
    Hello. I bought a Honiton 94 elements suitcase a few years ago. It is enough for an amateur. Regards
  • #8 17399701
    cynamonik
    Level 9  
    Nice, thanks. It seems like something worth buying at the level of Yato or the other companies you mentioned.

    For me, the most important thing is the quality of workmanship, e.g. narrow tolerance so that they fit the sockets and heads as well as possible.

    I suspect that a lot of opinions come from the fact that you do not use knobs, but rattles at once .. I see such situations in almost all workshops. I will let you know what I finally bought.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #9 17400020
    SKM 1964
    Level 34  
    And this is a very bad habit, as the key knob withstands much greater forces than the ratchet. The Noise Maker can be broken when unscrewing and tightening with greater force. But I also noticed it during the workshops, that no one is playing with the shifting of the keys, but is working on the rattle right away. Apparently it's so more comfortable. :|
  • #10 17404958
    gieniek
    Level 12  
    I have Coval sets, and some Neo. Coval has been through a lot and is still doing it.
  • #11 17405052
    freebsd
    Level 42  
    I have also been using the Yato set for several years. I also have power tools from this company. And I don't use ratchets for "hard" unscrewing :-)
    Only the bits (T40 type) have weak bits, but I'm not sure about that, because I lost them while unscrewing very seized screws.
  • #12 17416332
    SKM 1964
    Level 34  
    And I'm curious what happened to them exactly ?? Cracked, twisted or something else ?? :|
  • #13 17416336
    szymitsu21
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl
    Yato is suitable for bicycles. It's hard to unscrew anything with them.

    A seized wheel bolt is a serious challenge, NEO, King tons (price and somehow great in my opinion) asta (I also use everything for 1100nm pneumatics for years and nothing breaks.
    SATA is terrible crap.


    This is probably all of the tools that really work and are at a good price.

    Besides, Manessman and Magnuson are also really good, I have such sets and I use them outside the workshop.
  • #14 17416531
    Aleksander_01
    Level 43  
    szymitsu21 wrote:
    Yato is suitable for bicycles. It's hard to unscrew anything with them.

    A seized wheel bolt is a serious challenge


    So we take, for example, a 13th Yato ring spanner and for no treasures we can not unscrew the seized screw. Now we take the company's 13-eye wrench (better according to the author of the post) and unscrew the seized screw a little.

    A revelation, a revelation, i.e. the problem is not a seized screw, but poorly selected tools. One more time.
  • #15 17416560
    andrzej20001
    Level 43  
    The profile inside the eyelet sucks. If you do it, cry. A good key, as you assume, enters quite tightly and is smooth inside, tightly on the bolt, nut. Side cutters cheap after the time, two when you cut, for example, a thicker wire or a M4 screw for scrap metal. Such neo tortures a couple of 5 years and they do not bend. With the wrong key you can do a lot of additional work, not to mention fingers.
  • #16 17416671
    freebsd
    Level 42  
    SKM 1964 wrote:
    And I'm curious what happened to them exactly ?? Cracked, twisted or something else ??

    I will answer the question under my post :-)
    One broke when unscrewing the brake caliper. Two other sizes just twisted together like a screw. In each of these cases, I had to unscrew the tightly seized screws.
  • #17 17416682
    Aleksander_01
    Level 43  
    andrzej20001 wrote:
    The profile inside the eyelet sucks. If you do it, cry. A good key, as you assume, enters quite tightly and is smooth inside, tightly on the bolt, nut.


    It gets better and better, i.e. Yato cannot make a key where there is, for example, 10 mm between the walls. Smooth inside and non-smooth?
    I have been using the Yato socket from 5.5 to 13 mm for over 10 years and professionally, fact 10 very rarely, but it can pass (the screw head is rusty). I note that this is a key that works almost non-stop.

    Each company will make a very good key, the only question is how much material will be used for this. The problem is that with the thinnest wall possible, transfer the greatest possible oblique forces.
  • #18 17416688
    SKM 1964
    Level 34  
    Thanks for the info !! Now I will be careful not to let them ...... live.
    The moderator wrote that YATO is only for a bicycle ?? In my opinion they can do a little more ?? :D
  • #19 17416690
    marek49ae
    Level 24  
    gieniek wrote:
    I have Coval sets, and some Neo. Coval has been through a lot and is still doing it.
    I also recommend Coval, I have practically all flat wrenches, ring wrenches and sockets from this company, which used to be with a lifetime guarantee. They've been through a lot and they're all alive. Only for the torx tips I have reservations because they break, I bought Yato they also break, now I bought a KingTony, we will see how long they will live.
  • #20 17416697
    szymitsu21
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl
    SKM 1964 wrote:
    Thanks for the info !! Now I will be careful not to let them ...... live.
    The moderator wrote that YATO is only for a bicycle ?? In my opinion they can do a little more ?? :D



    I believe that these are really average quality keys.

    And if someone says that there are others, I dare to say that he did not work with high-class keys.

    Contrary to appearances of good quality, the cap does matter. I can send you sample photos of sockets, for example YATO, what they look like after unscrewing the axle shaft with pneumatic a few times. Or long sockets 17,19,21 after seized wheels ... I don't write because I only like to see what is happening with these tools.

    I would like to add that this is my subjective opinion and no one has to stick to it ... So skip any unnecessary comments.
  • #21 17416706
    E8600
    Level 41  
    szymitsu21 wrote:
    Yato is suitable for bicycles.

    The friend is right in part. For me, the brand went too much towards marketing and attractive design, unfortunately the product suffered from it (perhaps a Ukrainian found fakes in the video). I admit YATO was my favorite but now I would choose NEO.


  • #22 17416753
    ewoo
    Level 30  
    I have the Honiton set myself, I bought them for my brother and friend. We are very pleased. Most often used with agricultural machinery and tractors. easy they don't have but no problems. They are not cheap because the set cost me about PLN 230 from 6 years ago, but it's worth the price. Recommended Affordable Car Repair Tool Brands & Sets: Yato, Craftsman, KS Tools, Husky, & Lidl
  • #23 17416767
    freebsd
    Level 42  
    I wonder if such divergent opinions are not due to the fact that under the Yato brand you can find different designs and quality. So everyone writes the truth, according to what he managed to buy. For example, if I get the complete set of Yato rattles, I will probably buy SATA rattles, because at some point in the demolition of cars, only the SATA rattles of five peasants have not been able to destroy for almost a year, which is a record compared to other mid-priced rattles. And this also does not mean that I will get a rattle of the same quality :-(

    I'm just spinning the front of the suspension, including the sled, from the Espace. And I use my Yato set for this, although I have sets of Stanley flat, ring and bent wrenches on my shelf. I also have bulk Profiline, Proxxon, Corona exclusive wrenches: -> Often, I also use regular Yato sockets for stroke (
  • #24 17416799
    siewcu
    Level 35  
    Neo, Proxxon - I would have taken these if I hadn't got Yato as a gift.
  • #25 17416806
    darek.jacek
    Level 13  
    Gedore. However, the price of some will not allow them to buy. They are indestructible.
  • #26 17416818
    ewoo
    Level 30  
    darek.jacek wrote:
    Gedore. However, the price of some will not allow them to buy. They are indestructible.

    In the first post, the author omits any of this type.
  • #27 17416939
    tzok
    Moderator of Cars
    I have a YATO suitcase - YT-1268 and it is generally ok, although these plastic-rubber ratchet handles are comfortable but difficult to clean (this rubber part is not very resistant to oil and gasoline). The set included one socket (5.5), which could not be put on the ratchet, because the socket is as if not fully machined. Besides, for amateurs, it is ok. I also have combination wrenches with a "ratchet" from Yato - YT-0208 and an additional set of extended 12-point TORX bits (spline) - YT-0400. Of course, I only use it for unscrewing / tightening by hand (I don't have a "pneumat", but you need more solid caps for them).
  • #28 17417659
    jkrotki
    Level 9  
    Writing that mid-range caps fall apart from a decent pneumat is a bit like buying a crossover and expecting it to go wherever the old Land Rover goes - it might work, but it should come as no surprise that it will fall apart after such treatment tools ;) There are YATO wrenches for other applications, for other Top Tools from the market, and decent impact sockets for still others. In my opinion, both YATO and Magnussons are enough for amateur use, and they surprised me positively with their durability several times.
  • #29 17417727
    freebsd
    Level 42  
    szymitsu21 wrote:
    I believe that these are really average quality keys.

    And if someone says that there are others, I dare to say that he did not work with high-class keys.

    My situation from today, as to be exactly confirmed by the above-mentioned quotes. It's not about Yato, because here the flat and ring wrenches end in size 22. Today I unscrewed the rocker pin. I wanted to use a Corona exclusive broken ring spanner, which already served two similar bolts. The third time, however, the screw was too rusty and the wrench slipped. But he grabbed Stanley's key without any problem.
  • #30 17417778
    siewcu
    Level 35  
    Stanley ... You have to watch out for that. Once good tools, now mediocre at best. They broke down qualitatively terribly.

Topic summary

The discussion centers around recommendations for affordable car repair tool brands and sets, specifically excluding high-end brands like Snapon and Hazet. Participants share their experiences with various brands, highlighting Yato, Craftsman, KS Tools, Husky, Lidl, NEO, Coval, and Honiton as viable options for amateur use. Users express satisfaction with Yato sets for personal use, while some caution about their durability under professional conditions. Other brands like NEO and Coval are noted for better performance, particularly in demanding situations. Concerns about the quality of tools, especially regarding the fit and strength of sockets and wrenches, are prevalent, with some users reporting issues with Yato tools under heavy use. The conversation also touches on the importance of selecting the right tools for specific tasks to avoid damage and inefficiency.
Summary generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT