Best Battery Impact Wrench: Bosch GDS 18V-LI HT vs. DeWALT DCF899P2 & DCF889HP2 - Budget PLN 1500

Hello, what battery impact wrench do you recommend? budget about PLN 1,500, I am inclined to bosch gds 18 v li ht due to the fact that I already have several equipment of this brand and I could buy only the body itself, but there is a brush motor from what I orientate, but equipment with a brushless motor according to this is me, on the other hand dewalt dcf899p2 appears on the horizon, users complain about the rotation change button, there is also the dcf889hp2 version, but I can't find the difference between these two keys except that the other one is about PLN 300 more expensive I am asking for help those who have knowledge in the subject Regards

@wojtek@ wrote:

i think that's it

Because...?

If you have batteries, take BOSCH.

@wojtek@ wrote:

users complain about the rotation change button

http://service.dewalt.pl/DEWALT/PL/pl-PL/Part/PartsForProduct?productId=11939

who works with brushless equipment knows what is going on and it makes no sense to write here about the advantages of this solution because I did not assume this topic, if a colleague is curious, please look for a lot of articles on this topic, just having batteries is not the only one for me selection criterion, it is better to pay extra and have a reliable and tested by other more experienced equipment

@wojtek@ wrote:

who works with brushless equipment knows what is going on and it makes no sense to write here about the advantages of this solution because I did not assume this topic if

I know very well ...

@wojtek@ wrote:

then look for a lot of articles on the subject

Marketing gibberish and nothing at all,

@wojtek@ wrote:

it is better to pay extra and have a reliable and tested by other more experienced equipment

So you are looking for the opinion of someone who has both keys, worked with them for at least half a year and can provide an objective opinion. It will be rather difficult.

@wojtek@ wrote:

owning batteries is not the only selection criterion for me

This is a mistake.
Device compatibility is of the utmost importance, I'm surprised you don't see it.

I gave the part prices in the link, there is an argument against DeWalt, as important to me.

I see that the beating of the foam is nothing else, my colleague, thank you for your help, please tell others

@ wojtek @ writes:
I see that the beating of the foam is nothing else, my colleague, thank you for your help, please tell others

3.1.9. Don't be ironic and don't be mean to the other side of the discussion. Respect the disagreement and other opinions on the forum.
Col. got relevant information, the sentence begins with a capital letter [TM]

płetwa wrote:

Device compatibility is of the utmost importance, I'm surprised you don't see it.

The author seems to notice that he writes:

@wojtek@ wrote:

owning batteries is not for me only selection criterion

For me, the criterion of "common battery" is one of the most important ... Once, that it is very comfortable at work, it falls in the corner, you change from the radio you have next to each other and the work goes on and the radio will play for another hour. Two - cheaper tools - I don't have to buy whole sets with batteries and charger, I just take the body. I've already seen teams having each tool from a different parish ... A dozen different chargers, four extension cords and a kilowatt of electricity ...

Brush or brushless motor - I have both tools, and each has its pros and cons. Brushes sometimes need to be replaced, but in professional equipment there is no problem with this, everything is at hand and ready for quick replacement.

It is known that one equipment a given company makes better, the other one a little less. However, service also speaks for one brand of tools. It is cheaper to send several tools for review in one package than several in different places, and you can get better offers than for a single tool.

I would take sets with another battery if they gave a really good price for it and there was some expansion of it ...

I am asking only for technical advice (what model, manufacturer, what parameters and explanation why exactly) and instead I get a lot of general things that I do not ask for an answer for that, which do not bring anything new and specific to the conversation, I have not been here for a long time forum, but I see a lot has changed

Have you decided on something? I have had AEG BSS18C12Z LI-402C for several weeks. The battery is very durable, it can be worked for a long time, it has a lot of power, it is solidly made, when I fell, I didn't notice any cracks, and the fall was from a considerable height. Placing the led diode does not suit me a bit but maybe it's a matter of habit. These 4Ah are enough for quite a long work.

I bought a Bosch GDS 18 V-EC 250 impact wrench
Due to compatibility (it won compatibility), it fell from about 2.5 m and only a small scratch. It works fairly well, not too heavy, not too big, but you have nothing to count on to unscrew the bolt at the wheel that someone was tightening with your foot, or some very tight. At the moment, I "mechanize" occasionally, so for my needs it is enough if I do something seriously, I will certainly buy a Bosch, only the larger one.