logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda
Advanced Search
logo elektroda
Give yourself a gift! »
Give yourself a gift! » Print 3D • Smart Home • Flipper
ADVERTISEMENT
Dostępna jest polska wersja

Czy wolisz polską wersję strony elektroda?

Nie, dziękuję Przekieruj mnie tam

[Solved] Baofeng UV-5R Police Eavesdropping in Poland: Legality, Punishment & Detection Risks

mnbvcxzzxcvbnm031120 38826 19
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
Report a violation of the law
| New topic
  • #1 18483646
    mnbvcxzzxcvbnm031120
    Level 4  
    Is it possible to eavesdrop on the police in Poland? Sample Baofeng UV-5R radio. And is it punishable or not? And is it possible to detect such a person who eavesdrops on the police?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 18483650
    SP5IT
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl  
    It's not possible. You can drop the subject.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #3 18483660
    mnbvcxzzxcvbnm031120
    Level 4  
    SP5IT wrote:
    It's not possible. You can drop the subject.
    but what can't
  • #4 18483673
    SP5IT
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl  
    Eavesdropping on the police with a baobab.
    The way it works is if you stand near the strikers and overhear what they're talking about :)
    And if you want to hear more, get a job at the ministry.
    m
  • #5 18483682
    mnbvcxzzxcvbnm031120
    Level 4  
    Okay thanks for the info.
  • Helpful post
    #6 18483820
    7936
    Level 18  
    How can you not, if you can. Provided that the services broadcast in the analogue system. Because if it's digital, that's a problem. But it can too. Only there is a paragraph for breaking any security in their communications.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #8 18487879
    władziowek
    Level 24  
    don_viking wrote:
    Below is a link to the article.

    Article


    In the case of listening to analog (non-coded) transmissions, this paragraph goes into shoes. I can listen as long as I want, but it is not allowed to transfer and share the content with third parties.
  • #9 18488557
    Jap
    Level 29  
    In analog you have a militia from 172 to 174MHz. In my vicinity (Zdolny Śląsk) so far all cities operate in analog. Even for a few days, Wałbrzych has installed an analog repeater that significantly increases the listening area.
    The eavesdropping is fully legal and you can't be traced, provided that you don't connect Bao to a 100W audio amplifier and half the district hears the teddy bears' correspondence.
  • #10 18489252
    yes2mike
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl  
    Provided you're listening to this militia with a RECEIVER and not some baofeng.
    Then you listen, already breaking the law.
  • #11 18489323
    robokop
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl  
    yes2mike wrote:

    Provided you're listening to this militia with a RECEIVER and not some baofeng.
    Then you listen, already breaking the law.
    As long as you listen and don't flaunt it too much, nothing bad happens. Worse when using the transmitter, especially to activate security infrastructure devices :P
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #12 18489644
    don_viking
    Level 21  
    yes2mike wrote:
    Provided you're listening to this militia with a RECEIVER and not some baofeng.
    Then you listen, already breaking the law.


    More precisely, the point is that the device used for listening should not be able to broadcast the services referred to in the subject in the band. Otherwise, it may be uninteresting, especially when such a knowledgeable officer, for example, during a car inspection, takes such a radio and pressing the carrier will be heard on the service radio. Then confiscation of property and criminal case.
  • #13 18490215
    yes2mike
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl  
    The mere possession of a transmitting device without the required permission is punishable under the Telecommunications Law.
    Not quite wise heads in revenge for eavesdropping can be brought under the penal code.
    Better be careful. Unfortunately, I know something about it.
  • #14 18490634
    .Labrador
    Level 26  
    yes2mike wrote:
    The mere possession of a transmitting device without the required permission is punishable under the Telecommunications Law.

    How does this relate to sellers, such equipment? in the store, on the net, at the qrz exchange. e.t.c
    Also, to sell a transceiver, they must have a license? or a license for alcohol?
    There's something wrong with what you're saying, unless I'm mistaken.
  • #15 18490643
    Rezystor240
    Level 42  
    .Labrador wrote:
    Something is wrong with what you write.


    Nothing spins, this is equipment for hams. For people who have the right ID, call sign and stuff like that. But not for what you don't need. The topic is complicated...
  • #16 18490654
    .Labrador
    Level 26  
    Rezystor240 wrote:
    This is amateur radio equipment

    I know about it, there is a rule where you can and where you can't and finito, that's me with a car, I have a truck and I don't have trailers, so I don't hook it up and I can.
    And to be honest, that's the purpose of listening to the services, I don't quite understand it.
    There is a road traffic program and that should be enough.
  • #17 18490718
    robokop
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl  
    yes2mike wrote:
    The mere possession of a transmitting device without the required permission is punishable under the Telecommunications Law.
    No, it's not allowed to use. It's like rape equipment - you can have it, but you have to use it with permission.
  • #18 18490751
    Rezystor240
    Level 42  
    .Labrador wrote:
    And to be honest, that's the purpose of listening to the services, I don't quite understand it.


    You will understand when you listen... Not bad stories of strange content are so mostly from Friday evening to Monday morning.
    You can fall asleep, I won't quote because you can't. :wink:
  • #19 18491022
    OPservator
    Level 39  
    If you want to have fun, jump to the amateur radio course - you will learn how much is the penalty for accidentally sending a signal where you can't.
    To quote Spiderman, with great power comes great responsibility.
    Can you listen, is it worth it?... The less you know, the shorter you will be interrogated - as my father, a police officer, says ;)
    Moderated By c2h5oh:

    Regulations point 3.1.9. Don't be ironic or mean to the other side of the discussion. Please respect dissent and other opinions on the forum.

  • #20 18492333
    mnbvcxzzxcvbnm031120
    Level 4  
    Thanks for the answer
| New topic
Report a violation of the law

Topic summary

✨ Eavesdropping on police communications in Poland is technically feasible if the transmissions are analog and not encrypted. Users can listen to analog frequencies, such as those used by the police, without legal repercussions as long as they do not transmit or share the information obtained. However, using a device like the Baofeng UV-5R for eavesdropping can lead to legal issues if it is capable of transmitting on police frequencies. The possession of transmitting devices without proper licenses is punishable under the Telecommunications Law. While listening is generally legal, flaunting the activity or using transmitting capabilities can attract law enforcement attention and potential penalties.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: In some Polish cities, analog police operate around 172–174 MHz; "eavesdropping is fully legal and you can't be traced." Detection risk is negligible unless you loudly rebroadcast traffic. [Elektroda, Jap, post #18488557]

Why it matters: This FAQ helps Poland-based hobbyists using scanners or a UV-5R understand legality, penalties, and detection risks.

Quick Facts

Can I eavesdrop on Polish police with a Baofeng UV-5R?

Yes, where police still use analog VHF. One user reports activity near 172–174 MHz and says it is receivable. He adds you won’t be traced unless you loudly rebroadcast what you hear, like through a 100 W amplifier. [Elektroda, Jap, post #18488557]

Is it legal to listen to analog police radio in Poland?

A forum contributor states listening to uncoded analog is allowed. However, transferring or sharing the heard content with others is not. Keep monitoring private to avoid issues. [Elektroda, władziowek, post #18487879]

What if the police use digital or encrypted radio?

Digital systems are harder to monitor. Attempting to break or bypass security is a criminal matter. Do not try to decode protected communications. [Elektroda, 7936, post #18483820]

Can the police detect me if I only listen?

Passive listening does not emit. One user claims you “can’t be traced” unless you rebroadcast audio loudly. His example was blasting audio via a 100 W amplifier, which draws attention. [Elektroda, Jap, post #18488557]

Is owning a Baofeng UV-5R legal without a license in Poland?

A member explains the issue is transmitting, not possession. In his words, “you can have it, but you have to use it with permission.” Transmitting without authorization is the problem. [Elektroda, robokop, post #18490718]

What penalties could apply for unlawful interception or breaking security?

Polish Penal Code Article 267 penalizes unlawful obtaining of information from transmissions. It covers intercepting messages not intended for you and defeating protections. Sanctions apply under this article. [“Naruszenie tajemnicy korespondencji – art. 267 k.k.”]

Should I use a scanner instead of a UV-5R to monitor?

One user advises using a receiver-only scanner. He warns that listening with a transceiver like a Baofeng may be treated as breaking the law. Use a scanner to minimize risk. [Elektroda, yes2mike, post #18489252]

Could accidental PTT expose me during a traffic stop?

Yes. A knowledgeable officer could press PTT and hear you on their service radio. That edge case can lead to confiscation and a criminal case. Avoid carrying TX-enabled gear on service bands. [Elektroda, don_viking, post #18489644]

Which frequencies are used where analog police is still active?

A listener notes analog activity near 172–174 MHz. In Lower Silesia, he says all cities still operate analog and Wałbrzych added an analog repeater, increasing coverage. [Elektroda, Jap, post #18488557]

How can I minimize legal risk while monitoring?

Use receiver-only equipment and avoid transceivers on service bands. The same user stresses listening with a RECEIVER, not a Baofeng. How-To: 1. Use a scanner-only receiver. 2. Do not use a transceiver to monitor services. 3. Never press PTT on service frequencies. [Elektroda, yes2mike, post #18489252]

What are the dangers of transmitting on service frequencies?

A poster warns that transmitting can trigger or interfere with security infrastructure devices. That is far riskier than passive listening and invites serious consequences. [Elektroda, robokop, post #18489323]

Do sellers need a license to sell ham transceivers like the UV-5R?

A member notes the gear targets licensed amateur operators. He adds the topic is complicated and not everything is for everyone. Buyers remain responsible for lawful use. [Elektroda, Rezystor240, post #18490643]

Why do some say eavesdropping with a Baofeng is “not possible”?

An experienced user dismissed the idea and joked you’d only overhear people nearby or need a ministry job. His point: typical gear won’t access protected systems. [Elektroda, SP5IT, post #18483673]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT