logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Affordable Scanners for PKP Frequencies: Baofeng UV-5R & Alternatives (up to PLN 200)

kzk kolejarz 8229 10
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 16570549
    kzk kolejarz
    Level 8  
    I am interested in some cheap scanner (up to PLN 200) for listening to the PKP frequency. Unfortunately, I do not know it, and I decided to ask for help here. Used devices are involved, although I must admit that I would prefer new ones.
    Thank you in advance and best regards.

    Added after 13 [minutes]:

    I will only tell you that I was interested in the Baofeng uv-5r device, but I do not know if it is suitable ... Railway range:
    150.050 - 151.975
    153.000 - 154.775
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 16570608
    AdamC
    Level 29  
    kzk kolejarz wrote:
    I am interested in some cheap scanner (up to PLN 200)

    Added after 13 [minutes]:

    I will only tell you that I was interested in the Baofeng uv-5r device, but I do not know if it is suitable ... Railway range:
    150.050 - 151.975
    153.000 - 154.775


    The most suitable, you program the frequencies of the railway channels and you can scan.
    On the other hand, in the amount of up to PLN 200, a sensible new scanner is not real.
  • #3 16570615
    Ture11
    Level 39  
    Dude, maybe it's worth trying with SDR?
    Look at least here:
    https://www.elektroda.pl/rtvforum/topic2353101.html#11180605

    funny amount, because it is only PLN 40-60. The disadvantage is low mobility, but you did not write that there must be a hand radio :D

    In this case, I would recommend the simplest "blue" dongle with the RTL2832U chip and 820T2 head, e.g. https://kamami.pl/tunery-dvb-t/562282-tuner-dvb-t-usb-dongle-z-ukladem -rtl2832u-and-head-820t2.html.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 16570768
    kzk kolejarz
    Level 8  
    AdamC wrote:
    kzk kolejarz wrote:
    I am interested in some cheap scanner (up to PLN 200)

    Added after 13 [minutes]:

    I will only tell you that I was interested in the Baofeng uv-5r device, but I do not know if it is suitable ... Railway range:
    150.050 - 151.975
    153.000 - 154.775


    The most suitable, you program the frequencies of the railway channels and you can scan.
    On the other hand, in the amount of up to PLN 200, a sensible new scanner is not real.

    So this would be good? What does it look like with the range of such a receiver?

    Added after 1 [minutes]:

    Ture11 wrote:
    Dude, maybe it's worth trying with SDR?
    Look at least here:
    https://www.elektroda.pl/rtvforum/topic2353101.html#11180605

    funny amount, because it is only PLN 40-60. The disadvantage is low mobility, but you did not write that there must be a hand radio :D

    In this case, I would recommend the simplest "blue" dongle with the RTL2832U chip and 820T2 head, e.g. https://kamami.pl/tunery-dvb-t/562282-tuner-dvb-t-usb-dongle-z-ukladem -rtl2832u-and-head-820t2.html.

    I know this solution, but I would care about the portability of this device :) And at what distance will such a tuner receive?
  • #5 16570909
    Ture11
    Level 39  
    kzk kolejarz wrote:
    And at what distance will such a tuner receive?
    Everything would really depend on the antenna and its location.
  • #6 16571034
    kzk kolejarz
    Level 8  
    In that case, I'll think about the Baofeng uv-5r, but I read somewhere that this radio has a very weak antenna, and is not very suitable as a scanner ... Is that true? And with it could I connect with Motorola T40? I am very sorry for the absurd questions, but unfortunately I don't know anything about radio communication ...
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #7 16571463
    yes2mike
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl
    Take baofeng and don't bother ;) It can handle PKP without changing the antenna.
    Crappy antennas usually have scanners. It's hard to design one that will pick up everything and at the same time be handy, so it is, because it is.

    You can get along with Motorola T40.
    Scanner? There are 9 trail channels, and there are maneuvers, so there is no problem with scanning, the more so that not everyone will talk to you.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #8 16571586
    kzk kolejarz
    Level 8  
    yes2mike wrote:
    Take baofeng and don't bother

    Ok, now some purely technical questions. Do I need a license to own this radio? Can I accidentally connect to the radio I'm listening to in scan mode? If so, what threatens me for this? In general, this radio only needs to listen, or to connect with Motorola ... Is it possible to program only PMR446 channels? So that the ability to connect with others is limited to a minimum ...
  • #9 16572288
    yes2mike
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl
    Unfortunately, even broadcasting in the PMR band from a radio that does not meet the requirements for PMR is a lefty.
    You can make a license, but this is nothing to do with the T40 moto or other bands except the amateur ones indicated in the license.
    So, for the sake of peace, don't touch the broadcast button outside PMR, where a free American has been ruling for many years and nobody will do it, and you won't do anything out of ignorance.
  • #10 16572760
    kzk kolejarz
    Level 8  
    yes2mike wrote:
    So for the sake of peace, don't touch the transmit button outside of PMR
    So without a license on this radio I can't use the PMR band?
  • #11 16573191
    sq7gvu
    Level 18  
    There is no such thing as a PMR license. Only dedicated devices with original antennas can be used there.

    However, this bandwidth is hardly monitored or not monitored at all, so you would have to be unlucky to be caught using a device not dedicated to this band.

    It would be different if you used Baofeng on other bands or caused interference - then the probability of "catching" increases.

Topic summary

The discussion revolves around finding affordable scanners for listening to PKP frequencies, specifically under PLN 200. The Baofeng UV-5R is mentioned as a potential option, with users confirming its capability to handle PKP frequencies without needing an antenna upgrade. However, concerns about its weak antenna and suitability as a scanner are raised. An alternative suggestion is to use an SDR (Software Defined Radio) dongle, which is cheaper but less portable. The conversation also touches on licensing issues related to using the Baofeng UV-5R and PMR446 channels, clarifying that while no license is needed for PMR, using non-compliant devices can lead to legal issues. Overall, the Baofeng UV-5R is recommended for its functionality, despite some limitations.
Summary generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT