logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Evaluating Tauron G11 Contract: Is 4kW and 25A Pre-Counter Sufficient for New Apartment?

Radek_19 16341 22
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 18682737
    Radek_19
    Level 4  
    Hello,
    I bought a flat, I replaced the electrical installation which is adapted to 3 phases with connection to an induction cooker for the future. (5 x 2.5mm? wire pulled up ;)
    The electrical system in the building was also replaced.

    I don't have an induction hob and I'm not going to change it for now.
    The devices I have are a 3.6kW oven, dishwasher (0.95kW/cycle), washing machine (0.91kW/cycle), A++ fridge and the rest is rather basic (TV, 2x laptop, vacuum cleaner, coffee machine, etc.).

    Currently, I do not disconnect the fuses, but there is something strangely connected by an electrician :) or rather this 5 x 2.5mm? wire to which only the oven is connected. This wire is connected to the fuse and the 3-phase differential and the test does not work on the differential, probably because there is one phase.

    And my question is whether this 1 phase and these 4kW contractual with 25A pre-counter protection is enough for me?? I have a contract with Tauron G11.
    I'm asking because I'm thinking about upgrading or applying for phase 3.
    I also don't fully understand what 4kW means.

    Thanks in advance for the hints.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 18682901
    bumble
    Level 40  
    Pre-meter protection is probably more than 4kW. I have 25A in a single-family house and the power is probably 9 or 11, I don't remember. If it's 25A you'll be fine. The test button on the RCD does not work because either l1+l2+l3+N is to be connected incorrectly, and if one phase is, for example, L1+N, or it is faulty.
  • #3 18682947
    kokapetyl
    Level 43  
    Radek_19 wrote:
    I replaced the electrical installation, which is adapted to 3 phases with connection to an induction cooker for the future. (5 x 2.5mm wire pulled up)
    Radek_19 wrote:
    this 5 x 2.5mm wire to which only the oven is connected.

    Are we talking about the same cable?
    If so, this is an error, because there is no separate circuit for the oven.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 18683321
    Radek_19
    Level 4  
    Yes, it's the same wire pulled up there. But in the kitchen I have a total of 4 circuits. One bottom socket and fridge. Next Upper sockets and dishwasher, third washing machine and fourth 5x2.5mm and the oven is currently connected to it. If you connect the hob, the oven will go under one of the sockets, but I don't plan the hob in the near future, so it will stay that way for some time.
  • #5 18683352
    kokapetyl
    Level 43  
    Radek_19 wrote:
    If the hob is connected, the oven will switch to one of the sockets

    And it will still be an error. Appliances that consume more power (washing machine, dishwasher, oven and hob if it is a separate appliance) are all to have a separate power circuit. In addition, there is a fridge, which should also be on a separate circuit, but for other reasons.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #6 18683599
    Pan.Kropa
    Level 34  
    Radek_19 wrote:
    I also don't fully understand what 4kW means.
    Because the contractual power means that you are guaranteed power consumption up to 4 kW. But actually with 25A fuse you can draw around 5750 watts.
  • #7 18683642
    Anonymous
    Level 1  
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #8 18683821
    Radek_19
    Level 4  
    Ehch, and here I am wondering whether to change it to 3 phases for peace of mind while increasing the power.
    Although I washed, washed, baked at the same time and nothing happened, so here I do not know if I did not exceed these 4kW or something is wrongly connected to this one phase on this 3-phase differential, which its test does not work.

    Or maybe you know what connection power these days, i.e. 2020. is such an optimal power for an apartment in a multi-family building??
  • #9 18683886
    Anonymous
    Level 1  
  • #10 18684197
    Ktoś_tam
    Level 39  
    If the pre-counter protection does not disconnect you, there is no point in pushing yourself into costs and increasing the power.
    Differential text may not work because it is 3f and you only have 1f drawn. The test can work between two phases and not between L and N, check the differential diagram how the test is connected.
    As for the standards, at 1f such a standard is 25A before the meter. Perhaps a few million flats, and certainly several hundred thousand flats in Poland have such protection. 25A will not disconnect at this current, 30A will also withstand the more so in an apartment where there are no continuous loads for many hours.
  • #11 18684208
    bumble
    Level 40  
    You can apply for an increase in power if you have a flow meter in the shower, a 7kW hob and many other crap, but in a standard apartment with gas I would give it a rest, especially since the protection is 25A. I checked because it seemed to me 9 or 11 kW at 25A in the house, but I have a contract power of 7.5 kW. Maybe it used to be calculated differently for security. Maybe they will increase your power and you will pay more and the security will stay.
  • #12 18685760
    bartekfigura
    Level 29  
    If the protection is 25 A and the contractual power is 4 kW, the protection should be 20 A. This is called tariff abuse and if someone is annoying, they will get attached. It's best to do this installation properly because it can't be that the RCD doesn't work. There are probably more flowers like this in this installation. Installation for checking and taking measurements. And increase the power to approximately 10-11 kW on 3 phases, which gives 3 x 20 A protection in front of the meter.
  • #13 18685807
    Pan.Kropa
    Level 34  
    bumble wrote:
    Maybe they will increase your power and you will pay more and the security will stay.
    In households, the contracted power does not affect the size of bills.
    bartekfigura wrote:
    And increase the power to approximately 10-11 kW on 3 phases, which gives 3 x 20 A protection in front of the meter.
    I would advise such power that the protection was 3x25A. In terms of the amount, it may be a small difference.
  • #14 18686335
    Radek_19
    Level 4  
    @bartekfigura but I did not set up this pre-counter protection myself and no one touched it. I have this information from Tauron's website when I log in to my account. in the collection point details tab.
    Power type: 1-phase
    Read date: 05/02/2020
    zone 1: 0
    Read Type: New
    Contractual power: 4
    Pre-meter protections: 25 A
    Multiplicand: 1

    As for my installation, I don't put my fingers there, the electrician did it, he just said that the test did not work probably because one phase and basically it was supposed to be increased to 3 phases, although at the moment I am wondering whether to increase it because if not, then these RCDs would have to be done properly somehow.
  • #15 18686721
    Ktoś_tam
    Level 39  
    As I wrote, the test probably does not work because the RCD is 3f and the power supply is 1f. The test is connected between terminals L1 and L2. The differential itself works otherwise, but it's still incorrect.
    Regardless of whether you stay at 1f or change to 3f, I would still throw this differential and put 3x1f. The board will most likely not require an RCD. So only receivers 1f remain to be secured. At the moment you can't check whether the RCD actually works. Any leakage in the installation or receiver will shut down the electricity in the whole apartment, sometimes for many hours or days (refrigerator) until the electrician comes. With 3 RCDs, you will have no electricity in only 1/3 of the apartment. Searching for damage is now 3x harder. Failure of the N track in RCD 3f will damage many receivers.
    This is roughly written why 3 RCDs 1f are better than one RCD 3f.
  • #16 18686825
    bumble
    Level 40  
    Ktoś_tam wrote:
    The board will most likely not require an RCD

    Nothing required. This is additional protection and applies in wet rooms.


    Ktoś_tam wrote:
    and so I would throw this differential out and put 3x1f.

    What's the meaning of that? the smallest. apart from that:
    Ktoś_tam wrote:
    power is turned off throughout the apartment

    Ktoś_tam wrote:
    why 3 RCDs 1f are better than one RCD 3f.

    The possibility of separating the circuits, but the colleague has not yet mentioned that there are RCDs with a redundant element, i.e. a built-in fuse, such two in jwdny.
    Moderated By Topolski Mirosław:

    Please expand your knowledge and then speak up.
    3.1.11. Don't post messages that add nothing to the discussion. They are misleading, dangerous or do not solve the user's problem.

  • #17 18687614
    Ktoś_tam
    Level 39  
    bumble wrote:
    Ktoś_tam wrote:
    The board will most likely not require an RCD

    Nothing required. This is additional protection and applies in wet rooms.

    If you're talking about lighting, you're right. All general purpose sockets require an RCD.
    bumble wrote:

    Ktoś_tam wrote:
    and so I would throw this differential out and put 3x1f.

    What's the meaning of that? the smallest. apart from that:
    Ktoś_tam wrote:
    power is turned off throughout the apartment


    In the post above I have already written why 3x RCD 1f is better in single-phase circuits than 1x RCD 3f.
    bumble wrote:

    Ktoś_tam wrote:
    why 3 RCDs 1f are better than one RCD 3f.

    The possibility of separating the circuits, but the colleague has not yet mentioned that there are RCDs with a redundant element, i.e. a built-in fuse, such two in jwdny.
    [quote="bumble"]
    The colleague, however, did not mention how much his proposal costs and how much space in the switchgear it takes up.
    Let a colleague give literally one example in which 1 RCD 3f is better than RCD 1f in SINGLE-PHASE CIRCUITS. There are no 3f devices in the apartment. The board does not require an RCD.
    RCD 3f should be considered as a malpractice and very limited functionality, no electricity in the entire apartment with any leakage. Even an efficient installation and receivers can trip an RCD. Grain to grain and several mA accumulate, especially when there are many receivers. RCD, like any apparatus, can be faulty. Does your friend know what will happen to 1f receivers if the N contact is damaged?
    If the author of the topic would stay with the 1f power supply, how to conduct the test?
    In addition, it is logistically easier to carry out a test on 1/3 of the apartment than on the entire one at the same time. The point is that someone is using the computer, someone else is watching the game and someone else is cooking and no one wants to agree to a power failure in the whole apartment at once. Then most often you forget about the test once and for all because it is annoying. With several RCDs, you can test at different times or days so that no one will feel it.
  • #18 18688394
    e-sparks
    Electrician specialist
    Ktoś_tam wrote:
    The board does not require an RCD.
    You repeat it like a mantra.
    Tell at least why the board does not require an RCD?
  • #19 18692841
    Ktoś_tam
    Level 39  
    e-sparks wrote:
    Ktoś_tam wrote:
    The board does not require an RCD.
    You repeat it like a mantra.
    Tell at least why the board does not require an RCD?

    PN-HD 60364
  • #20 18692852
    e-sparks
    Electrician specialist
    Ktoś_tam wrote:
    PN-HD 60364
    But you signed up .... there will be a lot to read in a week.
    Moderated By Topolski Mirosław:

    3.1.11. Don't post messages that add nothing to the discussion. They are misleading, dangerous or do not solve the user's problem.
    3.1.9. Don't be ironic or mean to the other side of the discussion. Please respect dissent and other opinions on the forum.

  • #21 18698111
    Anonymous
    Level 1  
  • #22 18698325
    CYRUS2
    Level 43  
    Pan.Kropa wrote:
    le actually with 25A fuse you can draw about 5750 watts.
    Non-stop and the fuse will not turn off.
    The value of this fuse determines the ZE and therefore seals it.
  • #23 18699183
    Radek_19
    Level 4  
    Evaluating Tauron G11 Contract: Is 4kW and 25A Pre-Counter Sufficient for New Apartment? Evaluating Tauron G11 Contract: Is 4kW and 25A Pre-Counter Sufficient for New Apartment?

    I think I misled, I actually have 20A in the box, although the website shows 25A if it's this fuse.
    The stove remains gas. I think I will leave it as it is, only with this 3-phase fuse, I will take someone to make it work properly and safely. If it starts blowing fuses somewhere, I'll start thinking about increasing the power.

Topic summary

The discussion revolves around the adequacy of a 4kW contract with 25A pre-counter protection for a new apartment's electrical system. The user has replaced the electrical installation and is currently using various appliances, including a 3.6kW oven, dishwasher, washing machine, and refrigerator. Concerns were raised about the wiring configuration, particularly the connection of high-power devices to a single circuit, which is deemed incorrect. Responses indicate that while 25A is generally sufficient for typical apartment usage, simultaneous high-demand appliance operation could lead to overload. Suggestions include considering a three-phase system for increased reliability and safety, especially if future upgrades to electric cooking appliances are planned. The importance of proper circuit separation for high-power devices and the functionality of residual current devices (RCDs) was also emphasized.
Summary generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT