Mikrotik Mesh Network: Reviews, Performance & Comparison to Other WiFi Solutions

automatapl 14571 36

Treść została przetłumaczona

Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu

Reply | New topic

#31 19445155 22 May 2021 12:03

IC_Current IC_Current

Network and Internet specialist

» | Helpful post? (0)

Post #31
19445155 22 May 2021 12:03

UAP AC Lite if you have 2x2 MIMO or UAP AC Pro if you have 3x3 MIMO clients.
As for the power supply - the last time I buy it, the rule is - you buy a collective package of five or ten APs, you have no power supply, because they will probably go to a large installation with a PoE switch anyway. You buy AP by the piece in a single package, you get it with a power supply. You buy from strange sources, where the seller first bought a collective package and then sells single pieces in foil - you don't have a power supply.

Added after 50 [seconds]:

automatapl wrote:
Won't this reduce transfer over utp 6a?

PoE has nothing to do with wire bandwidth

Helpful post? Buy me a coffee.
ADVERTISEMENT
#32 19445158 22 May 2021 12:05

automatapl automatapl

Level 5

» | Topic author Helpful post? (0)

Post #32
19445158 22 May 2021 12:05

On the Mikrotik forum I found a comparison of roaming on different devices. In fact, MT performs poorly.
ADVERTISEMENT
#33 19445162 22 May 2021 12:10

m.jastrzebski m.jastrzebski

Network and Internet specialist

» | Helpful post? (0)

Post #33
19445162 22 May 2021 12:10

automatapl wrote:
@IC_Current
@m.jastrzebski
@KOCUREK1970
@chatman1

Please give me your picks - which devices UniFi In-Wall AP and UniFi AP purchase for an apartment (60-80m2; 3 or 4 rooms) to have a balance between the possibilities and the cost of shopping.
Internet access 1000/100 - the router is Mikrotik for now - I don't expect any changes here, or if I have time, I'll configure the gateway on openbsd.
it just depends on the budget. Ac lite is enough (~350 PLN). I saw that there are new versions of wifi 6, but it's PLN 550 with such a link to consider. More future-proof. Whether the ceiling or inwall version should not make a difference. I suspect it's the same in a different package.

Added after 2 [minutes]:

automatapl wrote:

KOCUREK1970 wrote:
PoE power

Won't this reduce transfer over utp 6a?

Not. Poe af / at, you are interested in such a power supply or switch. Besides, they can't be powered otherwise, they don't have a DC socket.
ADVERTISEMENT
#34 19445192 22 May 2021 12:31

automatapl automatapl

Level 5

» | Topic author Helpful post? (0)

Post #34
19445192 22 May 2021 12:31

m.jastrzebski wrote:
Whether the ceiling or inwall version should not make a difference.

In-wall - has the disadvantage that it will protrude from the socket and the advantage that it has two LAN outputs.
I don't know if a low-hanging/placed device affects transfers, I don't think it matters much.
Helpful post

#35 19446003 22 May 2021 21:06

chatman1 chatman1

Level 6

» | Helpful post? (+1)

Helpful post
Post #35
19446003 22 May 2021 21:06

m.jastrzebski wrote:
I don't think so. Power can be reduced. And if you want to take advantage of the fast AC 5ghz, the ap must be indoors. Already behind a single wall, the phone connects to 2.4ghz or its speed drops to 5ghz. I personally reduced the power to 2.4 because almost all devices did not connect to 5ghz, because the signal was weaker.

I wanted to have a decent 5Ghz and generally wanting to use it, there should be an AP in every room.
automatapl wrote:
Please give me your tips - which UniFi In-Wall AP and UniFi AP devices to buy for an apartment (60-80m2; 3 or 4 rooms) to have a balance between the possibilities and the cost of shopping.

In Wall, how do you want to convert the socket from RJ45 to AP + socket. Whether Ceiling or In Wall is almost one mushroom. In Wall only has a smaller range (it's more like 1 room = 1 AP), which you won't notice. Ceiling nanoHD. If you don't have the equipment, what will use it is a waste of money. Power from the switch (Poe) unifi (us 8 150w), I also bought a used one, because I will also want to power the ip phone with it. The router is made by unifi USG, the controller can sit, for example, on us, you do not need a Cloud key for this. For me, the whole amounted to over PLN 2,000, this is the big minus.
ADVERTISEMENT
Helpful post

#36 19446073 22 May 2021 21:55

Anonymous Anonymous

Level 1

» |

Helpful post
Post #36
19446073 22 May 2021 21:55

automatapl wrote:
I don't know if a low-hanging/placed device affects transfers, I don't think it matters much.

WiFi transfers are affected by everything, and one of the most significant factors is the location of the AP and the spatial orientation of its antennas.

Generally, the lower, the worse.

chatman1 wrote:
I wanted to have a decent 5Ghz and generally wanting to use it, there should be an AP in every room.

It's ideal for ultra-fast transmissions. Expensive.

A few hundred Mbps (say 500) can be done through the wall on ac in MIMO2x2. But the fact is, it all depends on the circumstances - in one place it is possible, in another it is not.
.
#37 19446129 22 May 2021 22:25

automatapl automatapl

Level 5

» | Topic author Helpful post? (0)

Post #37
19446129 22 May 2021 22:25

chatman1 wrote:
In Wall, how do you want to convert the socket from RJ45 to AP + socket.

We actually get AP + 2 x lan.
Create an account, log in and become active in a forum and ads will not appear. You will receive points by participating in discussions.
Join this discussion.

Install the application

Reply | New topic

Report a violation of the law

Topic summary

The discussion revolves around the effectiveness of Mikrotik devices in creating a mesh network compared to other solutions like Ubiquiti and TP-Link. Many participants express skepticism about the concept of mesh networking, suggesting that traditional wired access points (APs) connected to a router are more reliable. Concerns are raised about Mikrotik's lack of true roaming capabilities, which can lead to connection drops during VoIP calls when switching between APs. Ubiquiti's solutions, while more expensive, are praised for their seamless roaming and overall performance. Participants recommend specific Ubiquiti models, such as the UAP-AC-Lite and UAP-AC-LR, for home use, emphasizing the importance of proper configuration and placement of APs for optimal coverage. The conversation also touches on the longevity of software updates for Ubiquiti devices, with expectations of at least five years of support.
Summary generated by the language model.