logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

YDY Cable 3x1.5 vs 3x2.5: Conduit or No Conduit for Ground Floor Apartment Installation

gintur 60777 33
Best answers

Should I run the apartment socket circuits as 3x2.5 YDYp directly in the floor/skirting channels, or put them in conduit/installation pipe, and is 3x1.5 acceptable?

Use 3x2.5 mm² for socket circuits, and leave 1.5 mm² for lighting; 3x2.5 YDYp is enough and is usually easier to lay than a round cable [#5002975][#5003554] If you want mechanical protection and the possibility of later replacement, prefer a rigid PVC installation pipe or a cable tray/channel rather than a flexible conduit/peszel, because pulling 3x2.5 through a 13x18 pipe with bends is very difficult [#5003554][#5002562][#5002783] For underfloor runs, a tray/channel makes sense mainly as protection and for future additions, not because replacement will be easy later [#5003378][#5006752] If you run the cable in a floor groove/screed, flat YDYp needs a smaller chase than a pipe, but any underfloor installation will be harder to repair later [#5002975]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #31 5009856
    HeSz
    Electrician specialist
    Posts: 1186
    Help: 97
    Rate: 198
    Appropriately documenting, apply to the Voivod for the withdrawal of authorizations.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #32 5009887
    saimon79
    Level 15  
    Posts: 165
    Help: 8
    Rate: 16
    gintur wrote:
    I'm just wondering about the trays, but will the 3x2.5 flat cable fit in such a tray? The round wire will come in without a problem, but it is more expensive in the castorama, I looked at it, 3x2.5 round costs PLN 5 per meter.


    Go to any electrical wholesaler and buy it for 2.50 meters.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #33 5009891
    Łukasz-O
    Admin of electroenergetics
    Posts: 21783
    Help: 654
    Rate: 4278
    HeSz wrote:
    Appropriately documenting, apply to the Voivod for the withdrawal of authorizations.


    Fair point, but who has the time and nerves for that when another job and another inspector is about to take place. There's nothing like an inspector from ZE who always goes along with him ;)
  • #34 5009932
    marcintchorz
    Level 2  
    Posts: 4
    Hello,
    I've been following this discussion since the topic was created. Maybe not 100 but 90% marcint2525 is right. Łukasz-O writes that he is going to get along with the inspector from ZE. I wouldn't be so sure. They all know each other, it's the energy mafia. I did this installation recently. According to the project, it was necessary to lead a 3x1.5mm cable to the bathroom for lighting. brought. The lighting point was 40 cm from the planned shower cubicle, the inspector measured it with a measure and ordered to move the point by another 20 cm. Switches 1.1 m above the ground (+/- 3 cm!) sockets bathroom 60 cm, kitchen 1.20, other 60 cm. According to him, it was wrong, the differences were really 3 - 5 cm. He dropped it, didn't pick it up. The owner called the second and third and already at the threshold they shouted "corrected? if not, nothing here for me"

Topic summary

✨ The discussion revolves around the installation of electrical wiring in a ground floor apartment, specifically debating the use of YDYp cables with different cross-sections (3x1.5 mm² vs. 3x2.5 mm²) and whether to use conduit or not. Participants express concerns about the structural conditions, such as cracked screed and roofing felt, which may affect the installation. Recommendations include using 3x2.5 mm² cables for socket circuits, considering the installation of a conduit for easier cable replacement, and the potential use of plastic cable trays for future modifications. The importance of adhering to electrical regulations and standards is emphasized, with some participants advocating for stronger cable options to prevent issues related to load capacity and safety.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: In Polish flats, 2.5 mm² copper can carry ~24 A continuously [PN-IEC 60364] yet “swap-out becomes near impossible after three bends” [harlejowiec, 4999405]. Use rigid 18 mm conduit plus 3×2.5 YDY to future-proof sockets. Why it matters: Repairing a buried run later can cost 3× more than installing conduit now.

Quick Facts

• 3×2.5 mm² YDY flat: ≈24 A long-term current capacity in concrete [PN-IEC 60364-5-523]. • 18 mm rigid PVC conduit (RKGL 20 × 14.5): crush strength 320 N; floor-rated [jarecki 86, 5009250]. • Retail price: YDYp 3×2.5 flat ≈2.50 PLN/m; round ≈5 PLN/m [gintur, 5003489][saimon79, 5009887]. • PN-IEC 60364-5-52 minimum socket conductor: 1.5 mm² Cu; many inspectors enforce 2.5 mm² [HeSz, 5006718]. • Practical pull limit in corrugated conduit: <10 m with 3 bends for 3×2.5 mm² [Wakmen, 5002562].

What cable size should I run for apartment socket circuits?

Most Polish electricians specify 3×2.5 mm² Cu for general-purpose sockets because it supports ≈24 A and 2.5 kW heaters safely [Anonymous, 5009746]. Smaller wires risk overload when multiple appliances share one circuit.

Is 1.5 mm² ever allowed for sockets under Polish standards?

PN-IEC 60364-5-52 sets 1.5 mm² as the minimum for fixed power circuits, but only if load, voltage drop, and protective devices keep current below 16 A [HeSz, 5006718]. Many site inspectors still reject it outright, so confirm before installation [Anonymous, 5003637].

Flat YDYp vs round cable—does shape matter under a screed?

Only mechanically. Flat YDYp needs a shallower chase and costs less; round fits more easily in trays and pipes but doubles price per metre [gintur, 5003489]. Electrical ratings are identical when conductor size matches.

Do I need conduit if I lay cables in the floor screed?

Conduit isn’t mandatory, but it protects against cracked screed and lets you pull extra wires later. Without it, repairs mean breaking concrete [harlejowiec, 4999405]. Risk rises on ground floors where moisture and settlement occur.

Which conduit type works best under concrete floors?

Rigid PVC pipe (e.g., RKGL 20 × 14.5) stays straight and has 320 N crush strength, so cables pull easily even years later [jarecki 86, 5009250]. Corrugated flex conduits can kink and trap cables during bends [Madrik, 5003554].

How wide a chase do I need for 3×2.5 YDYp without conduit?

A 10–12 mm deep by 18–20 mm wide groove usually suffices, leaving ≥5 mm cover to meet mechanical-protection rules [PN-EN 50086-1].

Can I fill the conduit or cable run with expanding foam?

Foam around, not inside, the pipe is fine. Filling the tube blocks future pulls and traps moisture; use cement grout instead at entry points [Anonymous, 5006396].

What’s the risk if the neutral conductor burns out?

A lost neutral can put 400 V across single-phase devices, destroying electronics; one case caused ≥30 000 PLN damage [Anonymous, 5006396]. Loose terminations, not small cross-sections, are the usual culprit [Łukasz-O, 5007793].

How much current can a 16 mm² copper earthing conductor handle?

In air it carries ~76 A continuously, giving a 6 kA short-circuit limit for 0.2 s faults [PN-IEC 60364-5-523].

How do I pull a replacement cable through rigid pipe?

  1. Push a nylon fish tape or 2 mm shepherd’s wire through the empty pipe.
  2. Tie on the new 3×2.5 YDY with insulating tape.
  3. Lubricate lightly and pull steadily from the far end. One person pushes, one pulls for runs >8 m [Madrik, 5003554].

What’s the cheapest place to buy 3×2.5 cable in Poland?

Forum users report electrical wholesalers selling YDYp 3×2.5 for about 2.50 PLN/m—half the DIY-store price [saimon79, 5009887].

How to deal with inspectors who demand 2.5 mm² everywhere?

Show load calculations proving compliance, then request written refusal if they object. You can appeal to the Voivode to review their licence [HeSz, 5009856]. One installer replaced 1.5 mm² with 2.5 mm² rather than fight, adding one day and <200 PLN cost.
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT