logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Can a Differential Circuit Breaker Be Powered From Either the Top or Bottom Terminals?

tytan58 107122 29
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 5297618
    tytan58
    Level 20  
    Tu.
    I have this question for electricians; whether the differential can be powered from any side (up and down)
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 5297628
    fuutro
    Level 43  
    Well, not too much - looking at the description, but it should work anyway. . You give the power supply from the top and the receivers from the bottom.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #3 5297647
    Akrzy74
    Rest in Peace
    The direction of the current flow is not important for the correct operation of the RCD - connection from the top or the bottom. / It may only affect the speed of disconnecting from the power supply /. The apparatus can be attached at the top or at the bottom.
  • #4 5298127
    marian_em
    Level 25  
    The differential device will work regardless of the direction of the supply, it is important not to install the switch "upside down".
  • #5 5298347
    filip.s
    Level 23  
    marian_em wrote:
    it is important not to install the switch "upside down".


    And a friend can explain why?
    Many times at concerts and other festivities I saw tiny switchboards for powering the square which were, for example, upside down :)

    I myself am curious if it has any effect on the operation of the RCD switch, I think I will have to break some faulty and see :)
    My opinion is that it shouldn't have an effect, but I'm not sure.

    Greetings!
    Philip
  • #6 5300236
    Akrzy74
    Rest in Peace
    marian_em-wrote-
    Quote:
    The differential will work regardless of the direction of the power supply
    -Exactly yes, but the same marian_em-wrote-
    Quote:
    it is important not to mount the switch "upside down"
    This already clashes with what you wrote earlier. The assignment of the power cables to specific terminals of the apparatus (even / odd) does not have the slightest importance in the process of detecting the difference in currents flowing through this switch. provides a guarantee for them-and the same manufacturer on the sheet supplied with the RCD defines the method of connection ... / any-to be as universal as possible / However, for the sake of clarity of the system / diagrams / connection is used - terminals 1,3,5
  • #7 5300245
    fuutro
    Level 43  
    There is a smile, so it was upside down -> when you turn on the wajcha, you give it down.
  • #8 5301163
    marian_em
    Level 25  
    dj_stopa wrote:
    And a friend can explain why?
    Of course, any module mounted upside down is a great trap for the unaware user, who will be rummaging around the socket, contact etc ... be sure that everything is "turned off".
  • #9 5301204
    Wirnick
    Level 30  
    There is a sign -> o on the casing (maybe not all).
    Rhetorical question - can N after the difference be called N (neutral).
  • #10 5301239
    Akrzy74
    Rest in Peace
    Wirnick-
    Quote:
    There is a sign -> o on the casing (maybe not all).
    There is a sign N on the casing. Show me the RCD where it is 0, not N / I haven't met yet /
  • #11 5301248
    Wirnick
    Level 30  
    To Akrzy74
    It's not 0, it's just about (point).
  • #12 5301566
    Anonymous
    Anonymous  
  • #13 5302573
    Akrzy74
    Rest in Peace
    geguś wrote-
    Quote:
    Wirnick wrote:

    Rhetorical question - can N after the difference be called N (neutral).


    Maybe and must. The name of the wire is closely related to the function.
    I share my friend's opinion. Speaking of the N terminal on the RCD off. This track disconnects later / starts earlier / than the phase lines ... If, however, there is no N marking, then all current lines disconnect in the same way.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #14 5304443
    Wirnick
    Level 30  
    The theory about the functions of the N conductor is known to me.
    However, there are doubts on the forum whether the N cable can be used freely (with and without a differential). My answer is also NO. Therefore, this is a rhetorical question (N after the difference is different from N).
  • #15 5304506
    marian_em
    Level 25  
    I don't know what you mean by "arbitrarily", but the wires that will "pass" through the differential cannot be connected anywhere anymore. It is not only about the N conductor, but about all four active conductors, each differentiator simply makes a separate branch of the installation, which means that we can have several "different" N conductors at home (+ several different sets of phases :) ). Each connection in the installation of the cable to the differential and without the differential will do the same as the bridge on the rcd terminals, and what will work in this case is probably known:]
  • #16 5304533
    Anonymous
    Anonymous  
  • #17 5304740
    Wirnick
    Level 30  
    geguś wrote:

    And what? Just enough? NO BECAUSE NO ? What also ?


    My question is not even for electricians (they are to perform installations according to rules and regulations).

    For developers, there is function inheritance.
    The function N is inherited if and only if the differential is on. If the differential is off, N (after the differential) only has the name "N".
  • #18 5304933
    patryk-84a
    Level 28  
    And as usual in these types of topics, a mess and not responding to the topic. as usual, one grabs each other's words and tries to be smarter without adding anything to the topic. Get over yourselves people! A million such topics on elce and the same thing every time. If you don't know otherwise, don't answer any more questions like this. And I advise the author to search on the forum because not long ago the same topic was exactly the same. Is this a problem from which side will you feed it? See the manual or feed in advance and after the problem. May be? I request that this topic be closed according to points 4, 8.1, 10.4, 14 of the regulations.
  • #19 5368248
    januszkdom
    Level 11  
    I have a question whether you can connect 4 differentials, i.e. a 1-phase 3-phase differential, and make it the main differential and switch off the remaining 3 single-phase differentials that are connected to the receivers through the mains sockets, connect them so that when N and PE in the mains socket are contacted, it turns off the differential of course, the one to which the socket is attached
  • #20 5368424
    GBW
    Level 31  
    Januszkdom.
    the connection of the N and PE conductors turns off the differential.
    I read the first part of the question several times and I cannot understand how the 1-phase differentials are to be connected. If you explain, we will do something better.
  • #21 5368544
    marian_em
    Level 25  
    GBW wrote:
    the connection of the N and PE conductors turns off the differential.
    It causes switching off only when the circuit is loaded or the device which supplies the circuit "from the rear" is connected.
  • #22 5369186
    januszkdom
    Level 11  
    I just have 3 single-phase differentials connected to the main differential, i.e. one phase from the main differential goes to the 1st differential, the 2nd phase from the main differential goes to the 2nd differential, and the 3rd phase from the main differential goes to the 3rd differential and all three differentials are connected via the N conductor which comes from the output of the main differential.
    In the system I have, I connect the L and N wires to one of the single-phase differential at the output and now, when I connect the N and PE wire, it does not crash the differential to me, and I shouldn't know, maybe I'm doing something wrong, so I'm asking for help.
  • #23 5369373
    mczapski
    Level 40  
    It is a bit difficult to understand for what purpose you create such a circuit that the differential switches are connected in series. It should be assumed that it will be like yours. Part of the current will flow to PE and the current balance will differ from the switch tripping threshold. Each loaded circuit breaker is required to trip. I don't know what you are going to, but I would suggest giving up the three-phase circuit breaker.
  • #24 5369708
    GBW
    Level 31  
    Error. Differentials are not cascading. You have to change that.
    In this combination, either faster will work.
    The power cable of the switchgear is connected to the 3-phase and the 1-phase is connected with a bridge (there are special rails for bridging, but you can use the wire). Of course, there may be an overcurrent (main) protection in front of the differential. with circuits of other differentials. (except PE, of course)
  • #25 5369791
    Dariusz Goliński
    Level 22  
    Can I interfere?
    As for differential differentials, their main task is to guard the 1st Kirchoff law in the power supply system, i.e. preferably in the switchboard first. They are to ensure that the sum of the incoming currents is equal to the sum of the outgoing currents. So, assuming a differential, we make sure that the current does not run out of the circuit, e.g. through the washing machine and mother-in-law to the ground. (It depends a lot on the mother-in-law)
    So much for the theory.
    Can the differentials be mounted upside down? You can only need what. Each of us is used to the fact that when the lever is up, there is electricity and when it is down, there is no current. And let it stay that way. Of course, there are cases where it cannot be otherwise, but from the mechanical and electronic point of view, it does not bother you at all.
    Can the differential be connected from any side? Yes. And it will work and the response time will be correct. But as a rule of thumb, never leave the power on the knives when unplugged. It came from the old disconnectors with spring drive and three knives hammering into the sockets made of metal plates when switching on. Therefore, there are drawings on the differentials and on the pins and the side from which the knives are and the power contacts are marked.
    Can I cascade the differentials? You can and sometimes you have to. But these are special cases. (Often used in computer labs) At home it doesn't make sense (in some cases in bathrooms)
    If there are any ambiguities, write it. I had to pass the difference item, so I had to wear it. Anyway, I am a practicing electrician.
  • #26 5369967
    GBW
    Level 31  
    Dariusz Goliński.
    Of course, you are right, but the topic covers at least several dozen pages. Personally, I find it unnecessary to consider special cases, e.g. connecting type AC with type S or 500mA with 30mA, because less experienced colleagues may have a problem with it, and in residential buildings they still use one type.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #27 5370370
    Akrzy74
    Rest in Peace
    Dariusz Goślński - wrote-
    Quote:
    But as a rule of thumb, never leave the power on the knives when unplugged.
    Don't write crap. What regulation or rule requires that the power to the RCD should be connected to fixed contacts? What about switches having both movable contacts? Or both stationary? Note what the manufacturer writes on the piece of paper supplied with the RCD switch - any flow direction ... As for connecting several RCDs - selective / fire / e.g. 300mA is used first, and then the 30 mA RCD is used. Only then does it make sense ...
  • #28 5372125
    GBW
    Level 31  
    The tension on the knives.
    It's kind of like the electricians' dialect. With the current gear it is only applicable at medium to high voltage. Habits remain irrespective of the voltage.
  • #29 5372324
    Łukasz-O
    Admin of electroenergetics
    Fellow electricians, when it comes to modular devices such as ESS and differentials, it does not matter whether the power supply is "from the top" or "from the bottom". There is no such thing as bare knives or conductive parts available to the user.
  • #30 5372541
    januszkdom
    Level 11  
    Dear colleagues, thank you for your explanation and I will probably modernize it a bit and connect it differently. Thanks again.

Topic summary

The discussion centers on whether a differential (RCD) can be powered from either the top or bottom. Responses indicate that the direction of power supply does not affect the operation of the RCD, as long as it is not installed upside down. The consensus is that the RCD will function correctly regardless of the connection orientation, although it is recommended to follow standard wiring practices for clarity and safety. Some participants express concerns about the implications of incorrect installations and the importance of adhering to manufacturer guidelines. Additionally, there are discussions about the connection of multiple differentials and the role of neutral conductors in the system.
Summary generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT