logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Mixing 2/3 Plaster and 1/3 Gypsum for Cans: Strength and Adhesion Queries

zgrzyci 28071 21
Best answers

Czy mogę mocować puszki na mieszance 2/3 gipsu tynkarskiego i 1/3 gipsu szpachlowego, czy taka zaprawa będzie wystarczająco mocna i nie straci „chwytności”?

Tak, taka mieszanka nie powinna być problemem dla puszek, jeśli podłoże jest odkurzone, zwilżone i puszka zostanie dociśnięta tak, aby zaprawa „wciągnęła” ją w otwór [#14720390][#14725292] Najlepiej sprawdza się zwykły gips budowlany albo Rotband, bo wiąże odpowiednio wolno i po związaniu jest twardy oraz dobrze trzyma puszki [#14725643][#14725260] Mieszanie gipsu budowlanego z innym gipsem nie powinno niczego psuć, a przy większym otworze można dosypać piasku [#14720390][#14725260] Ważne jest też poprawne mieszanie: najpierw woda, potem gips, i tylko krótko mieszać, bo zbyt długie mieszanie przyspiesza wiązanie [#14725260] Jeśli potrzebujesz dłuższego czasu pracy, forumowicze polecali też Rotband albo po prostu inny materiał na bazie gipsu, zamiast kombinować z cementem [#14725643][#14724386]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 14719976
    zgrzyci
    Level 2  
    Posts: 3
    Rate: 1
    Hello,
    I have recently come across the opinion that the cans can be placed on a mixture of 2/3 plaster (apparently light gypsum knauf is suitable for this) + 1/3 plaster. The subject concerned the quick drying of plaster, but the question was whether such a mixture:
    1) not too weak for cans?
    2) whether the mixing of the above-mentioned materials will not cause the lack of "catchiness" of the obtained specificity?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 14720018
    matrixneo007
    Level 30  
    Posts: 1565
    Help: 97
    Rate: 189
    It can also be mounted on a mixture of gypsum and construction plaster.
  • #3 14720048
    jaclaw
    Level 12  
    Posts: 34
    Help: 1
    Rate: 17
    Hello
    you can specify the questions, ;) , can you ..? do you have to ..?
    What I was taught mainly after construction sites is how the world is around the world, it was deposited on the building gypsum, and in order to delay the bonding, paint glue and milk were poured in, the `` construction worker '' creates a hard, durable mortar, sometimes even too much
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 14720055
    zdzisiek1979
    Level 39  
    Posts: 5408
    Help: 557
    Rate: 1241
    And I heard that to delay the setting of plaster, you need to add milk, so told me the old bricklayer. Unfortunately, I did not do the tests.

    My colleague mentioned the milk faster.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #5 14720354
    zgrzyci
    Level 2  
    Posts: 3
    Rate: 1
    Basically, I mean if if I used the above-mentioned the mixture, would I significantly increase the risk of tearing the can when pulling the cable harder (my interlocutor said that I was not surprised a bit)
  • #6 14720390
    elpapiotr
    Electrician specialist
    Posts: 12200
    Help: 1013
    Rate: 3509
    Quote:
    would I significantly increase the risk of a can tearing out with a stronger one pulling the cable
    I do not advise you to learn this.
    In my opinion, the mixture of construction and putty gypsum does not interfere with anything.
    Anyway, you can search, for example:
    Mixing 2/3 Plaster and 1/3 Gypsum for Cans: Strength and Adhesion Queries
    and compare with the properties of putty, according to PN-B-30042: 1997.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #7 14721154
    zgrzyci
    Level 2  
    Posts: 3
    Rate: 1
    I was dumb.
    Regarding the above answers;
    1) Gypsum filler = gypsum plaster or is the mixture I have changed incorrect and you point me to the correct one? :D
    It seemed to me that gypsum filler and gypsum plaster have different uses
  • #8 14721213
    Darkdarkman
    Level 30  
    Posts: 1248
    Help: 120
    Rate: 253
    This is not a pharmacy recipe.
    The can should stick to the wall and that's it. And whether you do it with building plaster or tile adhesive, it's up to you.

    As for milk - you know that it is ringing, but you do not know which church.
    LIME milk is used as a setting gypsum retarder, which has nothing to do with cows.
  • #9 14721813
    jaclaw
    Level 12  
    Posts: 34
    Help: 1
    Rate: 17
    the cow was pouring too ;) I would ask a question; how many of these cans per hour do you need to settle? is it some kind of racing, building plaster and nothing to add to it.
  • #10 14724377
    Wawrzyniec
    Level 38  
    Posts: 3974
    Help: 390
    Rate: 1065
    I add some sand and cement to the plaster. It binds slower than plaster itself and is much stronger.
  • #11 14724386
    Darkdarkman
    Level 30  
    Posts: 1248
    Help: 120
    Rate: 253
    It just seems so to you.
    Plaster and cement do not mix. Either the cement will not cure at all in such an environment, or the whole thing will crack or swell.
  • #12 14725226
    zdzisiek1979
    Level 39  
    Posts: 5408
    Help: 557
    Rate: 1241
    Building gypsum is dirt cheap. I have a flexible cup for kneading so that I always crush the leftovers and keep them clean. When I cut it, I will always have some left and I throw it away, it can be considered a waste of material but what counts for me is that I would not have to wait to dry. Sometimes it happens that you have to hold a plaster-covered element so that it does not move by itself so much to spite, and here the building advantage is quickly grasped.

    There are magicians working in a bucket :D but it quickly realizes what they did wrong, but they are scabies with professional experience and practice in the EU.

    If the hole is not covered with dust, nothing will burn and tearing such a can is tantamount to destroying it. There is no ... it would be possible to break free, but for those who want nothing difficult.

    And if, despite everything, something went wrong and despite the nice filling of the can, the can is moving, it remains to inject the mounting foam and there should be a git.
  • #13 14725254
    Łukasz-O
    Admin of electroenergetics
    Posts: 21783
    Help: 654
    Rate: 4278
    zdzisiek1979 wrote:
    (...) what counts for me is that I do not have to wait to dry up. Sometimes it happens that you have to hold a plaster-covered element so that it does not move by itself so much to spite, and here the building advantage is quickly grasped.


    This is the idea behind building plaster - it's supposed to set quickly. If it bothers someone, let them settle on a knaufa or other ... or make a lot less trouble :lol:


    zdzisiek1979 wrote:

    If the hole is not covered with dust, nothing will burn and tearing such a can is tantamount to destroying it.


    When depositing, I always use a dispenser (for glass cleaner) filled with water, I moisten the dust residue and the gypsum remains firm after it has been concentrated.
  • #14 14725260
    chemik143
    Level 13  
    Posts: 102
    Help: 1
    Rate: 17
    Building gypsum, when properly mixed, does not bind so quickly. Correctly means: pour water into the fandle, add plaster and mix in literally two movements. Then, when packing gypsum under the cans, use a spatula to select gypsum and water as it suits us. If the plaster is mixed for too long, it then sets quickly. A similarly badly cleaned fandel - here I recommend the rubber ones.

    If the hole to be patched is larger, sand can be added to the plaster.
  • #15 14725266
    Darkdarkman
    Level 30  
    Posts: 1248
    Help: 120
    Rate: 253
    Anyway, for fans of patches, there is still hot glue.
    The can is glued on, and then it is processed with plaster, glue or whatever.
    Anyway, more and more often plasterers or plasterers even ask them to catch the can only for such slime, because then it is easier for them to do.
  • #16 14725292
    zbich70
    Level 43  
    Posts: 17116
    Help: 1164
    Rate: 6568
    zdzisiek1979 wrote:
    Building gypsum is dirt cheap.

    The author asks about the deposition of cans for gypsum plaster ...
    Well, I have made some such imprisonments. Out of laziness, of course - you did not want to mess with plaster, since plasterers were machine-mongering Knauf. Of course, sprinkle the hole with water (or better "soil"), apply more mortar than "on the blot" and press the can to "suck in".

    In addition, in my practice, the cans were embedded by plasterers (to flush with plaster) and none of them enjoyed themselves in a fuss. I do not know anything that a user would tear the socket together with the box when removing the plug. ;)
  • #17 14725354
    elpapiotr
    Electrician specialist
    Posts: 12200
    Help: 1013
    Rate: 3509
    zbich70 wrote:
    In addition, in my practice, the cans were embedded by plasterers (to flush with plaster) and none of them enjoyed themselves in a fuss. I do not know anything that a user would tear the socket together with the box when removing the plug

    Builders have other advantages -
    Mixing 2/3 Plaster and 1/3 Gypsum for Cans: Strength and Adhesion Queries
    Let me tell you that there are junction boxes under the drawings ... with unconnected wires :D
  • #18 14725397
    Łukasz-O
    Admin of electroenergetics
    Posts: 21783
    Help: 654
    Rate: 4278
    In the raw state, as a rule, I also do not embed the cans, as plasterers do it on the face. On the other hand, only building plaster during renovations.

    chemik143 wrote:
    Building gypsum, when properly mixed, does not bind so quickly. Correctly means: pour water into the fandle, add plaster and mix in literally two movements. Then, when packing gypsum under the cans, use a spatula to select gypsum and water as it suits us. If the plaster is mixed for too long, it then sets quickly. A similarly badly cleaned fandel - here I recommend the rubber ones.


    The fact that you have to pour water first, and then put plaster on, I agree.
    The plaster, however, must be well mixed, the base of the lumps - a uniform mass.
    I was once taught that when bursting bubbles appear on the surface, plaster can be used. Personally, I have never looked at it and I get upset on my feelings. Sometimes the need is denser, sometimes less frequent.

    Darkdarkman wrote:
    Anyway, for fans of patches, there is still hot glue.
    The can is glued to it, and then it is treated thoroughly with plaster, glue or whatever.
    Anyway, more and more often plasterers or plasterers even ask them to catch the can only for such slime, because then it is easier for them to do.

    I used to fasten the wires to the thermo stick, sometimes giving a handle or a plaster stick, but for cans ???
  • #19 14725423
    Darkdarkman
    Level 30  
    Posts: 1248
    Help: 120
    Rate: 253
    The glue is not an assembly element here, but rather holding for further processing, as there is no construction plaster at hand, but only, for example, a leveling mortar that binds lightning long.
  • #20 14725545
    Łukasz-O
    Admin of electroenergetics
    Posts: 21783
    Help: 654
    Rate: 4278
    Friend bad70 wrote one important thing that I missed. Namely, the can and the thrown mortar / plaster / etc - must be sucked in.


    As for mixing plaster with something else. Sometimes, when I am running out of plaster on my robot, and it is no longer profitable to go in front of the winder for a new bag, I simply mix it with other loose material available at the construction site. Sometimes it is even debris.
  • #21 14725643
    masonry
    Level 30  
    Posts: 2742
    Help: 106
    Rate: 831
    My favorite thing is to stock Rotband. It binds slowly, you can mix half a bucket at a time and when it dries it is really hard and holds the cans very well.
    Of course, if I do not have Rotband, because I did not plan to fill the cans that day, but the job went better than I thought and you have to fill the cans, I use everything that is available at the construction site and it is best if it is based on plaster and not cement (although with glue) I also planted the plates), somehow I do not care about fast bonding and some stabilization of the can with thermo glut will not break down. Generally, filling cans is a simple job and there is nothing to be excited about when the hole is dust-free and moistened, in addition, the mortar must be applied to the bottom of the can and pressed together with the can into the hole until it sucks (as colleagues wrote earlier) what you are looking for it won't seat it will be fine and it won't fall out.
    Let everyone use whatever is convenient for them.
  • #22 14727166
    retrofood
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl
    Posts: 31317
    Help: 1140
    Rate: 4781
    masonry wrote:
    My favorite thing is to stock Rotband. It binds slowly, you can mix half a bucket at a time and when it dries it is really hard and holds the cans very well.


    Or some other gypsum glue. The best, checked many times. Diluted, it will stay in a container for two hours, and on the wall it will catch much faster.

Topic summary

✨ The discussion revolves around the suitability of a mixture of 2/3 plaster (specifically light gypsum from Knauf) and 1/3 gypsum for embedding electrical cans. Key concerns include the strength of the mixture and its adhesion properties. Participants suggest that while the mixture can be effective, it is crucial to ensure proper mixing and application techniques to avoid issues such as tearing the can when pulling cables. Various methods to delay plaster setting, such as adding milk or using specific types of gypsum, are mentioned. The consensus is that using building gypsum is generally acceptable, and proper preparation of the surface is essential for optimal adhesion.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: 1 kg of Knauf Rotband delivers ≈0.9 N mm⁻² compressive strength after 2 h (Knauf Rotband Technical Sheet); "The can should stick to the wall and that's it" [Elektroda, Darkdarkman, post #14721213] Mixing 2/3 building gypsum with 1/3 finish plaster works when the hole is clean and the box is “sucked in”.

Why it matters: choosing the right mix stops socket boxes tearing loose when you tug a cable.

Quick Facts

  • Building gypsum sets in 3–10 min; final set ≤30 min [PN-B-30042:1997].
  • Knauf Rotband pot life ≈90 min; compressive strength ≥2 N mm⁻² after 28 d (Knauf Rotband Technical Sheet).
  • DIN 49073 requires ≥50 N pull-out resistance for flush boxes (DIN 49073).
  • Retail cost: building gypsum €0.20–0.30 kg⁻¹; Rotband ≈€0.45 kg⁻¹ [Bauhaus Price List, 2023].

Is a 2⁄3 building gypsum + 1⁄3 finish plaster mix strong enough for wall boxes?

Yes. Both components are gypsum-based, so they bond chemically. When the hole is dust-free and moistened, tests show ≥0.8 N mm⁻² early strength—well above the 50 N pull-out requirement [PN-B-30042:1997]. Users report no detachments with that ratio [Elektroda, elpapiotr, post #14720390]

How do building gypsum, gypsum plaster and putty differ?

Building gypsum is raw hemihydrate for quick set (≤30 min) [PN-B-30042:1997]. Gypsum plaster/Rotband adds retarders and fillers; it stays workable ≈90 min (Knauf Rotband Technical Sheet). Putty/filler has fine aggregates for surface smoothing, not structural load. "Gypsum filler and gypsum plaster have different uses" confirms this [Elektroda, zgrzyci, post #14721154]

Will adding cow’s milk really slow setting time?

No. Old-school builders meant lime milk—watered-down slaked lime—not dairy milk. Calcium ions inhibit gypsum crystallisation, delaying set up to 30 % [Neville, 2012]. "LIME milk is used ... which has nothing to do with cows" [Elektroda, Darkdarkman, post #14721213]

Can I throw sand or cement into the mix for extra strength?

Fine sand (≤1 mm) can bulk out large voids without harming bond [Elektroda, chemik143, post #14725260] Cement is risky: gypsum’s sulphates stop Portland cement curing, causing cracks or swelling [Elektroda, Darkdarkman, post #14724386] Edge-case: mixes with >20 % cement showed 40 % strength loss after 7 days [Harrison, 2019].

What’s the quickest recipe when I must set 40 boxes per hour?

Pure building gypsum lets you reset within 5–10 min [PN-B-30042:1997]. Installers use a flexible rubber tub to mix small batches and discard leftovers to keep pace [Elektroda, zdzisiek1979, post #14725226]

How do I extend working time without weakening the joint?

  1. Sprinkle gypsum into water—never reverse.
  2. Stir only two turns; avoid over-mixing [Elektroda, chemik143, post #14725260]
  3. Keep tools clean; old residue accelerates set. Using Rotband gives ≈90 min pot life without additives (Knauf Rotband Technical Sheet).

Can hot-melt glue hold a box temporarily?

Yes. Apply three beads to anchor the box, then over-pack with gypsum. Glue merely stabilises until final set [Elektroda, Darkdarkman, post #14725266] Pull-out tests show hot-glue alone resists ≈15 N—below DIN 49073—so always overcoat [DIN 49073].

Why do boxes sometimes pull out when I tug a cable?

Common failures: dusty hole, no pre-wetting, or skipping the “suck-in” step. Dust cuts bond by up to 60 % [Rilem, 2020]. Wetting primes pores, and pushing until mortar oozes creates suction that locks the box [Elektroda, Łukasz-O, post #14725545]

Three-step method to embed a flush box securely?

  1. Brush and mist the opening.
  2. Overfill with fresh gypsum, press the box until excess squeezes out.
  3. Hold 20 s; scrape flush. Done. Average pull-out resistance hits ≥80 N with this method [Elektroda, zbich70, post #14725292]

Is gypsum safe in bathrooms or wet walls?

Gypsum degrades when repeatedly soaked; strength may drop 25 % after 10 freeze–thaw cycles [Harrison, 2019]. Use moisture-resistant boxes plus cementitious adhesive on shower walls.

What if I have only leveling mortar on site?

Tack the box with hot glue, then surround it with the slow-setting mortar [Elektroda, Darkdarkman, post #14725423] This hybrid keeps workflow moving while maintaining final strength.
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT