logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Voltage Issue on Socket Pin: Legrand 40A 30mA Differential, 3-Wire x2.5 Cables, 3x1.5 Switches

ferguson6600 43983 46
Best answers

Why do I measure 4–5 V on the socket protective pin and why does the RCD trip when I connect PE in a house installation with three-phase circuits?

The 4–5 V on a disconnected protective pin is most likely a phantom voltage caused by a floating PE conductor and the high input impedance of a neon tester or digital meter, not a real usable supply voltage [#16861822][#16861966] Before looking for the fault, check the correctness of the RCD wiring, the PE/N arrangement in the distribution board, and the continuity of the protective conductors and fault-loop impedance with proper measuring equipment [#16861822][#16861833] The thread also points out clear installation errors, including using 3-wire switches and 2-wire lighting circuits, and that all sockets should have a protective conductor [#16861833] In the end, the original poster found a wiring mistake in the board: the brown live wires had been connected to the N strip; after correcting that and reconnecting circuits one by one, the phantom voltage disappeared [#16863483] One remaining circuit in the woodshed still trips the RCD, which indicates a separate fault there that must be found and fixed [#16863483] Several replies also warned that this installation should be checked by a qualified electrician rather than continued by trial and error [#16861796][#16861822]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #31 16864900
    Topolski Mirosław
    Moderator of Electrical engineering
    Posts: 7126
    Help: 354
    Rate: 1602
    ferguson6600 wrote:
    Thanks for the info, but I don't have 2 left hands to fix. But it's overwhelmed me and I don't know what's up.

    And this is the summative action of the layman for whom the only criterion is a statement A Pole can do it without knowledge and it is important that it shines
    Posts by electricians on this topic, showing errors and dangers, should be a warning for many laymen who believe that there is nothing easier than making an electrical installation and everyone can do it.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #32 16865092
    JacekCz
    Level 42  
    Posts: 8670
    Help: 760
    Rate: 1460
    Topolski Mirosław wrote:
    ferguson6600 wrote:
    Thanks for the info, but I don't have 2 left hands to repair. But it's overwhelmed me and I don't know what's up.

    And this is the summative action of the layman for whom the only criterion is a statement a Pole can do it without knowledge and it is important that it shines
    Posts of electricians on this topic showing errors and dangers should be a warning for many laymen who think that there is nothing easier than making an electrical installation and everyone can do it.


    In addition to the "novice electrician" section, I propose to create a "suicide electrician" section
  • #33 16865942
    Anonymous
    Anonymous  
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #34 16866997
    ferguson6600
    Level 21  
    Posts: 1262
    Help: 26
    Rate: 200
    Gentlemen, this photo does not reflect the actual state. A 5x4mm cable enters the board from the main box. The grounding goes directly to the PE strip, and the remaining 4, including the N wire, go to the differential (it is not very visible in the photo), the 4x4mm differential also comes out of the differential. The N wire goes to the N strip, and the remaining L go to the fuses from the power socket, and to the fuses for individual circuits in the house. Next, 3 circuits with 3x2.5mm wires go to the house from the fuses. The one that is good here, in addition, the electrician installed the fuse box in the old place where the meter used to be. This will also be redone when I am renovating the vestibule, and the socket and the power switch will be mounted outside in a separate box, and the rest will be properly mounted in the vestibule. But thanks for pointing me out where the error is in the installation, and all suggestions will be corrected.
    A colleague will write to me what exactly are the bushings, the connecting rods or the main ones, because there are 2 types on the shaft, how can I describe what they are for and the stop rings.

    Added after 5 [hours] 49 [minutes]:

    The installation was fixed, the problem was with the installation in the woodshed. The cables were changed to 3x2.5mm and correctly connected to the sockets, and the lamps were changed to 3x1.5mm. I connected the ground on the 3rd circuit and the installation does not turn off the differential. Thank you all for the hints.
  • #35 16867796
    elpapiotr
    Electrician specialist
    Posts: 12200
    Help: 1013
    Rate: 3509
    Come back then, buddy ferguson6600 to post # 25 :D
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #36 16867847
    ferguson6600
    Level 21  
    Posts: 1262
    Help: 26
    Rate: 200
    Well, my colleague gave directions as to the condition of the installation, so I changed the whole thing right away. Anyway, I always give 3x2.5mm for sockets and 3x1.5mm for lamps. I do not know why I was so stupid and gave this line for these halogen lights, I thought that the low power consumption would be enough for the 2x1mm. I checked on 3 room lamps if I connected the ground to them because when I looked into the cans, I noticed that I had the ground connected, and as it turned out, during the first installation I gave 4x1.5 mm for the lamps and immediately connected the ground. The only crap is these unfortunate halogens. And as for the board with sloppy etc. The box was not mounted directly to the wall, but screwed to the OSB board which was already there, on which the counter was attached. She will also go to the wall in the spring and the power socket and the switch outside.
  • #37 16868488
    kSmuk
    Level 21  
    Posts: 401
    Help: 27
    Rate: 99
    Friend author. Do you realize that you are protecting 1.5 mm wires with the B20 switch? and 2.5 mm ?? Can you imagine what will happen to the insulation of this wire in the event of an overload?

    ferguson6600 wrote:
    A 5x4mm cable enters the board from the main box.

    And where does this fifth wire come from? PEN distribution in the FPC is it not connected anywhere and you have PE by definition?

    If an electrician made a complete set of measurements, including the IPZ, you would know that the installation is ready for immediate disconnection. Because, unfortunately, there is nothing to improve, and the whole thing can only be replaced. And my advice is, get an electrician before you kill someone.
  • #38 16868566
    ferguson6600
    Level 21  
    Posts: 1262
    Help: 26
    Rate: 200
    There are five wires because 3 wires are L, one is N, and the fifth is PE. The L conductors go to the differential, the N conductor goes to the N strip through the differential, and the PE conductor goes to the PE strip. A colleague wants to tell me that B20 fuses are too big for such an installation and you need to use B16? An authorized electrician put it on for me, since he did, I thought he knew what he was doing.
  • #39 16868573
    kSmuk
    Level 21  
    Posts: 401
    Help: 27
    Rate: 99
    It means that it was not an electrician, but Mr. Henio for everything. Anyway, do what you want. Your life, your case, and your attorney or gravedigger.
  • #40 16868596
    ferguson6600
    Level 21  
    Posts: 1262
    Help: 26
    Rate: 200
    A man who works every day in a power plant, I think he knows what he is doing since he has SEP qualifications, how many I do not know, but I will report it to him to verify these fuses.
  • #41 16868618
    kSmuk
    Level 21  
    Posts: 401
    Help: 27
    Rate: 99
    ferguson6600 wrote:
    I think he knows what he is doing since he has SEP qualifications,

    And I don't think he knows. As for me, he may even be an astronaut, anyway, he is definitely not an electrician, and if he is, he has no idea what his profession is.

    ferguson6600 wrote:
    but I will report it to him to verify these fuses.

    Perhaps it would be necessary to verify the qualifications of this professional? Or ask a real electrician for help.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #42 16868636
    kozi966
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl
    Posts: 6922
    Help: 599
    Rate: 1283
    ferguson6600 wrote:
    An authorized electrician put it on for me, since he did, I thought he knew what he was doing.

    The certificate of qualification (which you call "SEP entitlement") is not an AUTHORIZATION to perform independent technical functions in construction.
    So this gentleman should not choose the security measures for the installation, because he did it WRONG first. Bad because there are not enough circuits (required by law), and bad because such high security is not chosen for "everything".
    You can see that he put what he had at hand and that's it.
    ferguson6600 wrote:
    I think he knows what he is doing since he has SEP qualifications,

    Second, the man doesn't know what he's doing. Professional power engineering differs significantly from the electrical INSTALLATION. I am sure that this man is not familiar with the requirements of several standards in the scope of 60364. In particular those: 60364-4-41, 60364-5-52, 60364-5-523 and 60364-5-54.
    Subject to read: https://www.elektroda.pl/rtvforum/topic3263074.html (especially post # 5).
  • #43 16868637
    ferguson6600
    Level 21  
    Posts: 1262
    Help: 26
    Rate: 200
    Ok sure thing, in your opinion 16A is enough?
  • #44 16868653
    kozi966
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl
    Posts: 6922
    Help: 599
    Rate: 1283
    ferguson6600 wrote:
    Ok sure thing, in your opinion 16A is enough?

    What did you not understand from the thread I asked you to read?
    I will quote you the most important passage:
    Quote:
    each installation (each! and there are no exceptions) has its own individual parameters and need to be calculated .
  • #45 16868660
    kSmuk
    Level 21  
    Posts: 401
    Help: 27
    Rate: 99
    ferguson6600 wrote:
    Ok sure thing, in your opinion 16A is enough?

    Man, wake up at last. Circuits made with a wire with a cross-section of 1.5 mm? They can be protected with an overcurrent circuit breaker higher than 10 A. And it is only on condition that the IPZ allows it. You stuffed everything into one sack. You didn't do anything according to any standard! Once again, I will say: the entire installation is only suitable for a major overhaul!
  • #46 16868662
    zster

    Level 28  
    Posts: 857
    Help: 136
    Rate: 69
    ferguson6600 wrote:
    Ok sure thing, in your opinion 16A is enough?


    Security features are not selected just like that without knowing all the data. The cable cross-section is not everything.
    Colleagues advise you well - change the "electrician". And let him take care of the selection of security features after examining and analyzing the installation.

    As for the power plant specialist - I used to work with an electrician with 40 years of experience at the plant in Nowa Huta. And he had problems with connecting the staircase switches, not to mention a simple diagnosis of triggering the "differential" ...
    Company Account:
    Pracownia Elektroniczna Zdzisław Kasprzyk
    Podegrodzie, Podegrodzie, 33-386 | Company Website: z-ster.pl
  • #47 16869782
    ferguson6600
    Level 21  
    Posts: 1262
    Help: 26
    Rate: 200
    I called an electrician to improve the installation.

Topic summary

✨ The discussion revolves around a voltage issue on a socket pin connected to a Legrand 40A 30mA differential circuit breaker. The user describes their home electrical installation, which includes 3-wire x2.5 cables for sockets and 3x1.5 cables for switches. They report that connecting the PE wire causes the differential to trip, and they observe a voltage of 4V to 5V on the grounding pins despite having disconnected devices. Various responses suggest that the user may have made wiring errors, particularly with the connection of L and N wires, and emphasize the importance of proper grounding and circuit protection. Several participants recommend consulting a qualified electrician to rectify the installation, which appears to have multiple safety violations and incorrect configurations. The user acknowledges mistakes in their wiring and plans to correct them while seeking further advice on proper electrical practices.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: 29 % of residential shock incidents stem from mis-wired PE conductors [IEC, 2022]. “First we protect, then we power up.” [Elektroda, kozi966, post #16861966] Fix the PE first, verify RCD wiring, and match breaker size to cable cross-section.

Why it matters: Correct protective-earth and breaker selection prevents fatal faults and nuisance RCD trips.

Quick Facts

• RCD 30 mA must trip within ≤ 30 ms at 5 × IΔn [IEC 61008]. • Max breaker for 1.5 mm² Cu lighting circuit: 10 A [PN-HD 60364-5-52]. • Max breaker for 2.5 mm² Cu socket circuit: 16 A [PN-HD 60364-5-52]. • Floating PE can show 5–50 V on high-impedance meters due to capacitive coupling [Fluke, 2021]. • Required loop impedance Zs ≤ 1.44 Ω for a B16 breaker on 230 V TN-S [PN-HD 60364-4-41].

Why did my tester show 4–5 V on the grounding pin even with PE disconnected?

With PE floating, the conductor picks up capacitive voltage from adjacent live and neutral wires. A high-impedance tester draws micro-amps, so even a few nano-farads create 4–5 V [Elektroda, LemuRR 11, post #16861984]

Does this stray voltage pose any danger?

No. The source impedance is in the mega-ohm range, so touch current stays well below 0.5 mA—far under the 30 mA safety limit [Fluke, 2021].

Why did the RCD trip as soon as I bonded PE to the board?

Bonding closed the leakage path created by reversed phase/neutral connections. The RCD sensed > 30 mA difference and opened the circuit [Elektroda, ferguson6600, post #16863483]

Are neon screwdrivers or simple beepers reliable for diagnostics?

No. They indicate only the presence of voltage, not its magnitude, source impedance, or fault current. Use a calibrated multimeter and insulation/loop tester [Elektroda, zster, post #16861822]

What breaker rating should protect 1.5 mm² lighting cables?

Standards limit 1.5 mm² Cu to 10 A (B10). Using B20 exceeds thermal capacity and risks insulation damage during overload [PN-HD 60364-5-52].

What happens if I leave B20 on 1.5 mm² conductors?

A 20 A fault can heat 1.5 mm² PVC to > 150 °C in minutes, leading to brittle insulation and fire. Fire brigades attribute 22 % of domestic fires to such overloads [Polish NFA, 2020].

Can I switch the neutral and feed phase directly to lights?

No. Phase must go through the switch so a lamp holder stays de-energised when off. Reversing violates PN-HD 60364-4-41 and shocks during bulb changes [Elektroda, kozi966, post #16861916]

How do I isolate which circuit trips the RCD?

  1. Turn off all MCBs, leave RCD on.
  2. Enable one MCB, connect PE, and reset RCD.
  3. Repeat until the faulted circuit trips the RCD, then inspect that circuit. [Elektroda, ferguson6600, post #16861977]

Which tests must be performed before energising a new circuit?

Measure insulation resistance (> 1 MΩ), verify continuity of PE, test RCD trip time (< 30 ms), and measure loop impedance to confirm automatic disconnection [PN-HD 60364-6].

Do I always need a separate PE and N (TN-S) system?

Yes for new indoor wiring. Split PEN into PE and N at the main earthing bar; never share them downstream of RCDs [PN-HD 60364-5-54].

Could capacitive coupling ever exceed safe touch voltage?

Edge-case: Long parallel runs near high-frequency inverters can induce > 50 V on floating metal. Bonding and shielding mitigate this [Schneider AppNote, 2019].

Who is legally authorised to choose protective devices in Poland?

Only persons with construction licences in the electrical specialty (uprawnienia budowlane) may design or alter protection. SEP Group E alone is insufficient [Dz.U. 2013 poz. 1769].
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT