logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

[Solved] Comparing SDS+ Drills: Black&Decker KD1250K vs Profix Tryton TMM10533 vs Modeco Expert MN-90-215

dikoj 10269 7
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 18162597
    dikoj
    Level 9  
    Hello,

    I moved to a block of flats from the big plate and the usual impact drill, which worked well in brick, relied completely on concrete.

    I oriented myself a little on the subject of SDS+ drills and narrowed the choice to a few models at a price of up to 500zł. Amateur use for drilling holes for shelves, etc. I will probably drill a few dozen holes now, and then the drill will be used once in a dozen months. Please help me choose between:

    Black&Decker KD1250K 500zl
    Profix Tryton TMM10533 400zl
    Modeco Expert MN-90-215 350zl

    I was still recommended Stanley, but it seems to me that in this price category has a low impact power. The models I chose have between 3.2 and 3.5J.

    Greetings,
    dikoj
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 18162629
    Anonymous
    Level 1  
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #3 18162657
    robin161
    Level 25  
    Wouldn't it be better to rent a professional drill for those few dozen holes in the rental shop? Respect the ears and nerves of your neighbors and do not use blunt drills. Try to get it done quickly and what is most necessary (at reasonable hours). Thank you on behalf of your neighbors (living longer you will feel it on yourself).
    Returning to the topic of purchase: buy a hammer drill in the market for half this price (in Leroy I saw for 169zł) - certainly enough for your purposes. Most of the branded products once (such as the mentioned Black&Decker) - are Chinese (only the company name and a higher price remain).
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 18163096
    dikoj
    Level 9  
    I just borrowed a Hilti TE 7-C for a while. It went into concrete like butter at an impact of 2.6J. Maybe indeed above 3J is too much. The block is just from the 1970s.
    Drilling machine I would prefer to have permanently. Not often, but nevertheless it comes in handy.

    So lowering the parameters and price range, what company do you recommend? And so everything is Made in China, but of course quality unequal.

    PS.
    I am aware of the inconvenience of the renovation and respect the rules of neighborly coexistence. So far there have been no complaints or hostile stares.
  • #5 18163168
    palmus
    Level 34  
    Parkside from Lidl.It heats up a lot with 15 minutes of continuous forging.But it is unlikely to threaten you.The price is ridiculous.
    Don't consider knocking out the crater on the 2nd side of the wall.In concrete fi 6 drill bit for 99% of applications.The depth of the hole to 4 cm and git; kitchen cabinets on a fi10 dowel will do.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #6 18166171
    dikoj
    Level 9  
    After another search on the battlefield remained two Einhell-e

    Einhell TH-RH 900
    Power 900 W
    Pneumatic impact energy 3.0 J
    Ampact speed 4000 min^-1
    Rotation 0 – 850 rpm
    300zł

    Einhell RT-RH 20
    Power 500 W
    Ampact energy 1.6 J
    Ampact frequency 5800 strokes / min.
    Rotation 0-1200 rpm
    190zł

    Knows that this is a German Chinese and probably the parameters are inflated, so I'm worried whether with this weaker model I will not tire myself (and neighbors) when drilling. With this more powerful model, drilling theoretically should go faster.
  • #7 18166248
    palmus
    Level 34  
    Neighbors are not the parameter Without noise will not get around. Still check the clearances ( and possible runout)on the SDS holders / furs. With small holes and a small tolerance of their location is important.
    Take a stronger one. You will drill faster and without wrist fatigue.
  • #8 18441208
    dikoj
    Level 9  
    The matter ended with the purchase of an Einhell TH-RH 900. I invested in drills and bought a basic set of HILTI for 150zł. To this grease for 19zł.
    So far I have used only impact drilling in concrete. I even happened to drill in an old concrete ceiling full of pebbles. Everything went like butter. For my needs, this set works perfectly.
    Of course, Einhell-Poland is an importer, and the production takes place in China.
    For sure, such equipment must be taken care of and always shield the head from dust, and after work clean the entire drill.
    The instructions clearly state that the equipment is not for professional use. It will work well for home renovation and occasional drilling, but it will not withstand continuous, long-term work, for example, in a renovation company.

    PS. As for the noise, it is less than with a regular drill, because drilling takes less time :)

    Topic to close.

Topic summary

The discussion revolves around selecting an appropriate SDS+ drill for amateur use in a concrete environment, specifically for drilling holes for shelves in a block of flats. The user is considering three models: Black&Decker KD1250K, Profix Tryton TMM10533, and Modeco Expert MN-90-215, all priced under 500zł. Participants suggest considering the impact energy of the drills, with recommendations leaning towards models with 3.0J or lower to avoid excessive noise and damage. Alternatives like renting a professional drill or opting for brands such as Einhell are also discussed, with Einhell TH-RH 900 being highlighted as a suitable choice after the user’s search. The conversation emphasizes the importance of balancing power, noise, and practicality for occasional home use.
Summary generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT