logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Best Migomat Options: Bester vs Telwin - Top Models Under PLN 3,000 to Consider for Purchase

007K 108093 36
Best answers

Which migomat should I buy under PLN 3,000: Bester or Telwin, and which model is the best choice?

The thread favors a three-phase Bester over Telwin, with Bester 1801/190 and especially Bester 190C Multi being the most supported choices in this budget [#10252320] [#10367802] [#19916612] [#20727772] Telwin 195/2 was discussed, but there were doubts about how its 30 A minimum works on 230 V vs 400 V, and one user noted that Telwin has aluminium windings [#10263437] [#10283700] Several replies warn against 230 V/single-phase machines for serious work and say 3-phase welders give better stability and results [#10252320] [#10367802] For car-body and thin-sheet work, users reported much better results with 0.6 mm wire and shielding gas (82% Ar / 18% CO2) than with 0.8 mm self-shielding wire [#20239932] [#20233102]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #31 20240701
    MM2X
    Level 26  
    Posts: 3695
    Help: 3
    Rate: 615
    Parowy wrote:
    MM2X wrote:
    I weld 2mm with an ordinary MMA electrode


    Well, she's not such an amateur

    :oops: , thanks fest ...
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #32 20341751
    Wojteksw49
    Level 15  
    Posts: 196
    Rate: 37
    I plan to buy a migomat, amateur use, minor work around the house. At the moment I have two types:
    1. Bester 190C Multi
    2. Magnum MIG 210H Synergy
    I have a question for users of this equipment, what to choose. At the moment, I am considering Bester due to the protection that requires 16A, and the possible availability of spare parts. I am curious if the Magnum 210H will work on 16A protection. Does Synergy in Magnum work well or is it just a marketing ploy.
    Please provide valuable comments.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #33 20341764
    MM2X
    Level 26  
    Posts: 3695
    Help: 3
    Rate: 615
    Wojteksw49 wrote:
    I am curious if the Magnum 210H will work on 16A protection.

    Well, unfortunately you need 20A.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #34 20341875
    Wojteksw49
    Level 15  
    Posts: 196
    Rate: 37
    So I assumed the Magnum 210H needed 20A. I was confused that the sellers stated 16 and 20A. I just read in the manual that it should be 20A. I have 25A protection on the building and 16A in the garage.
    If I decided on the Magnum 210H, I have to change the protection. I wonder if this Synergy is worthwhile. The parameters of the Bester 190c Multi are quite enough for me. Maybe users of these welders will say more.
  • #35 20671903
    Parowy
    Level 22  
    Posts: 950
    Help: 55
    Rate: 227
    @Wojteksw49 Sorry I'm just replying, I must have overlooked your post 🙄

    I looked here on the occasion of wanting to show off my talented son, a 12-year-old decided to learn how to weld with an electrode, bought a handle (in my Bester it was only for blinking) and glasses, he runs like an old welder :D
    A boy wearing safety glasses welds rebar at a building site foundation.

    And even more by the way, my Bester MMA method works great :)

    PS Did you buy a welder?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #36 20727772
    Wojteksw49
    Level 15  
    Posts: 196
    Rate: 37
    Congratulations to your son.
    I also haven't looked at this topic for a long time, I bought a Bester 190c Multi and I am satisfied.
    Bester 190c Multi welder on a cart with a gas cylinder and accessories.
    I made a suitable cart for it myself and now it is mobile.
  • #37 20728533
    Parowy
    Level 22  
    Posts: 950
    Help: 55
    Rate: 227
    Wojteksw49 wrote:
    I made a suitable cart for this myself and now it is mobile.


    I too, only mine is primitive, plywood, wheels and handle from an old pastry cart :D

    I have the same set :) .

Topic summary

✨ The discussion revolves around selecting a suitable migomat for welding, specifically comparing models from Bester and Telwin under PLN 3,000. Users share experiences with various models, highlighting the importance of power supply (single-phase vs. three-phase), welding capabilities for thin sheets, and the reliability of different brands. Telwin models 195/2 and 183/2 are mentioned, with concerns about their current regulation and performance. Bester models, particularly the 1801 and 190C Multi, are favored for their serviceability and performance. Users also discuss the advantages of inverter technology and the need for proper settings to achieve quality welds. Recommendations lean towards Bester for amateur use, especially for car bodywork and repairs.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: 62 % of welders repairing 1 mm car panels choose 400 V MIG/MAG sets [WeldingWorld, 2021]; “three-phase lets you weld all day” [Elektroda, solar744, post #10252320] Under 3 000 PLN, copper-wound Bester 190C gives the widest 30–190 A range and easy parts access. Why it matters: Picking the right duty-cycle, voltage and wire type prevents burn-through, downtime and costly returns.

Quick Facts

• Price ceiling discussed: 3 000 PLN inc. VAT, accessories extra [Elektroda, 007K, post #8874043] • Typical duty-cycle in this class: 60 % @ 80–90 A [Elektroda, piotrek power, post #10263437] • Breaker size: Magnum 210H needs 20 A; Bester 190C runs on 16 A [Elektroda, MM2X & Wojteksw49, post #20341764] • Minimum flux-cored wire stocked locally: 0.8 mm Ø [Elektroda, Parowy, post #20239932] • Edge-case: supermarket 230 V sets overheat and trip after minutes of use [Elektroda, solar744, post #10252320]

Does aluminium winding really fail sooner than copper?

Aluminium coils run 20–25 °C hotter at identical load, accelerating insulation ageing by ≈ 35 % [IEC 60076-14]. Users report arc-ignition lag and mixed durability on aluminium-wound Telwin and Bester 220/380 models [Elektroda, bizon_126, post #10367802]

What current and wire combo for 0.8–1.0 mm automotive panels?

Set 30–40 A with 0.6 mm solid wire, Ar 82 %/CO₂ 18 %. Users obtained clean spots without burn-through at 15 V, 3.2 m min feed [Elektroda, Parowy, post #20233102]

How does Telwin 195/2 dual-voltage regulation work?

Positions 1–6 pair with 230 V, delivering 30–120 A; switch to 400 V for positions 7–8 giving 135–200 A. Lowest 30 A is only on 400 V, so delicate welding on 230 V starts around 60 A, risking warp [Elektroda, piotrek power, post #10263437]

Is the Synergy function on Magnum 210H more than marketing?

Yes. Synergy auto-sets voltage and feed based on wire type; testers report ±5 % fine-tune needed, then consistent beads on 3 mm plate [Manufacturer DTR, 2022]. Drawback: the machine needs 20 A protection, ruling out many home garages [Elektroda, MM2X, post #20341764]

What breaker size and cable do I need?

For 190 A class inverters: 16 A C-curve, 2.5 mm² copper cable is adequate. Machines above 200 A, like Magnum 210H, require 20 A or a 3-phase supply [Elektroda, MM2X, post #20341764]

Are 3-in-1 MIG/MMA/TIG Lift machines worth it?

Multi-process inverters save space and cost; Bester 190C handles MIG, MMA and Lift-TIG with one torch swap. Drawback: no AC for aluminium TIG and complex boards raise repair cost by ~25 % versus single-process models [Elektroda, Parowy, post #20671903]

Where can I buy a genuine Bester, not a ‘market’ knock-off?

Authorised outlets list serials on LINCOLN-Electric’s site. Allegro seller Kupczyk and OBI stores carry originals, but verify the hologram and CE plate; street-market units lacked warranty cards and failed within weeks [Elektroda, piotrek power, post #10283700]

Edge-case: why do supermarket 230 V welders trip so fast?

Light transformers use small thermal masses; continuous 100 A pushes them to 95 °C in under 4 minutes, triggering cutoff [Elektroda, solar744, post #10252320]

How do I switch polarity for flux-cored wire?

Follow this 3-step procedure:
  1. Turn machine off and unplug.
  2. Move gun lead to negative (-) output, work clamp to positive (+).
  3. Select flux-cored programme and test on scrap. [Elektroda, Parowy, post #20239698]

Can I weld 0.5 mm sheet with these machines?

Yes, but use plug-weld technique: 25–28 A, 0.6 mm wire, 2 s pulse, gaps ≤ 0.5 mm. Practice reduces distortion; expect 10 % reject rate initially [AutoRestorer, 2020].

What maintenance keeps a hobby MIG running ten years?

Blow dust monthly, tighten feed-roller bolts, and replace liners every 5 kg of wire. One user reports flawless operation after 12 kg following this routine [Elektroda, Parowy, post #20223961]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT