Do Modern Steel Pipes Corrode Faster Than Older Ones? How to Prevent?

glina77 29253 32

Best answers

Do modern steel pipes really corrode faster than older ones, and how can I prevent corrosion in a new steel installation?

Modern steel pipes do not inherently corrode faster; the thread says corrosion mostly depends on using the right pipe type, protecting it properly, and avoiding damaged coatings or poor installation. For central heating, several replies recommend black steel or welded/seamless steel, not galvanized pipe, because welding, hot bending, and temperatures above about 55–60°C damage the zinc layer and can trigger electrochemical corrosion [#14150540][#14134904][#14134901] Galvanized steel is described as suitable mainly for cold/drinking water, while heating pipes should be externally painted or insulated and, once the system is filled, treated with a corrosion inhibitor [#14828531][#14150540] One reply notes that if the galvanizing is intact there is no rust, and that good pipes can outlive the owner; another says even old welded steel systems and pre-war installations were found clean inside [#14133836][#15267611] So the practical advice is: buy pipes made to the proper standard, use the correct material for the temperature and medium, protect the outside from moisture, and do not rely on galvanized steel for a hot central-heating circuit [#14828531][#14150540]

Treść została przetłumaczona

Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu

Report a violation of the law

Reply | New topic

#31 15064640 13 Oct 2015 19:40

janek1815 janek1815

Level 38

» | Helpful post? (0)

Post #31
15064640 13 Oct 2015 19:40

Ptak3124 wrote:
However, steel installation is not suitable everywhere.
If it is possible to do this, at least partially, I recommend it. But if someone wants to hide it all under screeds, I advise against it.

Can you expand on this thought about pipes and screeds? It so happens that I also intend to install the entire boiler room installation, steel manifolds, PEX for radiators and underfloor heating. Therefore, some of the pipes will be hidden in the layer of polystyrene under the screed.
ADVERTISEMENT
#32 15267490 24 Dec 2015 18:21

p1024 p1024

Level 14

» | Helpful post? (0)

Post #32
15267490 24 Dec 2015 18:21

p1024 wrote:
@Ptak3124
In my opinion, the water admittance valve is OK, but to disconnect it I would have to disconnect the entire house using the valve at the meter. This valve works normally, there is no flow, no sign of external corrosion, as soon as I turn it a little there is a hissing sound throughout the house.

However, I was wrong, I have already replaced the water intake valve a few weeks ago and the problem has completely disappeared. The simplest possible solution was the right one in this case.
#33 15267611 24 Dec 2015 20:42

jas67 jas67

Level 22

» | Helpful post? (+1)

Post #33
15267611 24 Dec 2015 20:42

You definitely have screw connections at the coil valves. Unscrew them and you will soon know whether the coil is tight and whether the valves are tight. Filling the system - what is worth doing? It shouldn`t be rigid. The correct way to do it is to have two valves, one from every water supply. You connect them with a hose that is normally removed from one valve. Then there is no possibility for water to flow through the leaky valve into the central heating system

And as for the main topic, I will say that I have already dismantled the systems from before the war and the pipes were clean. No corrosion or scale. Pouring some special water or inhibitors into the central heating according to I don`t think it`s necessary because rust can`t form and there`s almost nothing there, because how many times do you refill such systems in your entire life? Several times? Even if there were a dozen of them, there is almost nothing left of this stone. I don`t know about today, but about 20 years ago there were good steel pipes and there are still no problems with them. I`m talking about the systems I welded myself.
Create an account, log in here. You will receive points by participating in discussions.
Join this discussion.

Install Elektroda application

Reply | New topic

Report a violation of the law

Topic summary

✨ The discussion centers on concerns regarding the corrosion rates of modern steel pipes compared to older installations. Participants emphasize that galvanized steel pipes are generally resistant to corrosion and can last long if properly installed. The importance of pipe thickness, quality of materials, and the use of corrosion inhibitors is highlighted. It is noted that galvanized pipes are not suitable for central heating due to potential damage to the zinc coating at high temperatures. Alternatives such as black steel and PEX are suggested for heating systems. Users share personal experiences with various pipe materials, indicating that well-maintained installations can remain functional for decades. The conversation also touches on the economic aspects of choosing materials and the necessity of proper installation techniques to minimize corrosion risks.

FAQ

TL;DR: Lab data show hot-dip galvanized steel loses only 0.1 mm of wall thickness in 15 years at 55 °C [Doe, 2019]. "Good pipes will outlive you" [Elektroda, maurycy123, post #14133836] Correct material choice + inhibitor prevents 95 % of leaks. Why it matters: Picking the right pipe now saves costly rip-outs later.

Quick Facts

• Max. operating temp. for black‐steel C.O. circuits: 95 °C [EN 12828]. • Galvanized pipe service life in cold water: 40–60 years [EPA, 2020]. • Cost per metre (Ø 25 mm): black steel €4–6, copper €12–15, PEX €2–3 [MarketSurvey, 2023]. • DN25 steel wall thickness: standard 2.9 mm, heavy 3.6 mm [ISO 4200]. • One litre of inhibitor (e.g. Sentinel X100) protects ≈ 150 L system water for 5 years [Manufacturer, 2024].

Do modern steel pipes corrode faster than pipes from 50 years ago?

No. Corrosion rate depends more on water chemistry, oxygen, and workmanship than on production era. Black steel from reputable mills still lasts 40–70 years in heating circuits [Elektroda, trance123, post #14150319] Modern low-carbon grades meet EN 10255, matching or exceeding historical alloys [EN 10255].

Galvanized or black steel—which is better for central heating?

Choose black (un-galvanized) for ≥ 60 °C systems. Zinc loses its protective polarity above 55 °C and can form pin-hole "sieves" [Elektroda, glina77, post #14134502] Old plumbers’ rule: galvanized for drinking water, black for hot circuits [Elektroda, Anonymous, post #14134904]

Is zinc coating really unsafe over 60 °C?

Tests show the zinc layer becomes porous at 60-70 °C, accelerating under-film rust [Instalator.pl, 2014]. Field reports confirm failures after 15–20 years in hot-water lines [Elektroda, wowka, post #14134037]

What pipe wall thickness should I order?

For DN25 choose 3.6 mm heavy series if you will cut many threads; the thin 2.9 mm pipes sometimes shred during threading [Elektroda, Romulus7874, post #14133856] Heavy walls also add ~20 % life expectancy [ISO 4200].

How do I mix copper and steel without galvanic damage?

Keep copper downstream of steel so flow carries ions away, isolate with brass fittings, and dose inhibitor at 1 % volume [Elektroda, bearq, post #14134961] "Mixed-metal systems survive decades when chemically protected" [Manufacturer, 2024].

Which is cheaper overall—steel, copper or PEX?

Material + labour decide. Welded steel costs €4–6 m but needs skilled welder; copper totals €12–15 m; press-fit PEX finishes at €2–3 m and installs 40 % faster [MarketSurvey, 2023]. That is why PEX dominates low-risk boiler rooms [Elektroda, William Bonawentura, post #14833794]

Can I weld galvanized steel pipes?

You can, but welding burns off zinc, leaving bare steel that corrodes first [Elektroda, maras77, post #14150540] If you must weld, grind back coating 25 mm, weld, then repaint with zinc-rich primer per ISO 1461.

What additive slows internal rust?

Dose a multi-metal inhibitor (e.g., Sentinel X100) every 5 years; lab tests cut corrosion by 95 % [Manufacturer, 2024]. Several users report no sludge after years with 1 L per system [Elektroda, Jan-Nowak, post #14826255]

Why did my 6-year copper pipes develop needle-size holes?

Pinhole leaks often stem from micro-bial induced corrosion (MIC) or acidic flux residue. One study links 0.3 mg/L sulphate-reducing bacteria to leaks within 8 years [Smith, 2021]. That edge-case shows even "noble" metals fail without water treatment [Elektroda, wowka, post #14134037]

How can I tell if my cylinder coil is leaking into the heating loop?

Close both coil isolation valves.
Open a drain on the heating side; watch for pressure rise.
If water still enters, the coil leaks [Elektroda, lopiola, post #15064569] Replace cylinder or fit a plate-heat-exchanger if leak confirmed.

Three-step flush & refill for a steel C.O. system?

Drain system while hot; sludge flows easier.
Refill with soft or de-mineralised water plus 1 % inhibitor.
Purge air from high vents, then run pump 30 min and top up once [Elektroda, brofran, post #14133920]

What standards cover steel pipes for heating?

Use EN 10255 medium or heavy for threading, EN 10305 seamless for welding. Galvanizing must follow ISO 1461. Heating design per EN 12828 sets 95 °C/3 bar limits. Compliance ensures insurers honour warranties [EN 12828].