logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
📢 Listen (AI):
  • 3D printer Frankenstein Mark_1

    Hello, hello and hello!

    The idea of building a 3D printer has been on my mind for about a year, I finally took it as an engineering subject and got motivated. :)
    I decided to model it after the existing Artifex, as you can see.
    In general, the main criterion for selecting components was price, unless the difference was small.

    The choice therefore fell on:
    -an aluminium profile frame;
    -rails with bogies on the X and Y axes (best idea ever!!);
    -trapezoidal screws;
    -extruder with gearbox;
    -fullmetal head from China.

    Reviewing other projects, I come to the conclusion that from a technological point of view this is a higher-end design than, for example, the Prusa i3, and I will explain why right away.
    A very popular solution is to construct the X and Y axes on shafts and linear bearings. This solution seems to be much cheaper, as the components are a few zlotys each on Allegro. I have such a solution applied to the Z-axis and what I noticed - huge clearances in the X-axis, which is perpendicular to the bearings. I calculated some 0.28 mm with free movement, and 0.06 mm in the Y axis.

    After testing, I can conclude that it is even bigger when printing faster.
    This may significantly limit the speeds we will be able to achieve. I don't know how much better the case will be if I buy decent bearings, but then the price of the rail with the carriage is no longer so high. :)
    Of course the Prussians print amazingly anyway, but if it can be better....
    Don't use plywood for the table base either, unless temporarily. It shakes like it's having an epileptic seizure.
    3D printer Frankenstein Mark_1

    Moving on.
    Putting the printer together itself is somehow not particularly difficult. The 3D printed parts make it all come together nicely. It wasn't until getting the printer up and running that I encountered another wave of problems.
    The big problem turned out to be the Chinese head, because of the heat sink. Its core right on the heat block was incredibly thick, so that cooling at the most critical point was severely limited. This caused the head to clog during operation. The problem was solved by removing the excess material and hot-tightening the nozzle to the heat block. Currently it performs quite well for heads that can be bought for $4 each. :P
    Generally the printer will work on anything that will let it move, but it is worth getting the extruder right or buying a Goliath and an E3D head. The solution is not cheap, but if someone can afford it and doesn't want to tear their hair out, it should be a pretty good solution. Or at least everyone praises them. :)

    The price of the whole thing isn't even as frightening as some people scare, it cost about £1000-1200 and a lot of costs could be cut. I bought 3 times as many screws as I needed, trapezoidal nuts with flange are 2 times more expensive than trapezoidal ones, if a friend prints the parts for us at cost, we are another 200-300 zł ahead.

    The printer is still being modified, but it is already printing quite well. Below is a sample print where I increased the speed during printing to 170%. The holes on the top could probably be avoided with cooling and the Lift Z option in the slicer. :)

    3D printer Frankenstein Mark_1

    Cool? Ranking DIY
    About Author
    kiriki-kun
    Level 10  
    Offline 
    kiriki-kun wrote 21 posts with rating 15. Been with us since 2010 year.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 15299732
    MasMas
    Level 16  
    Quite interesting. How long did it take to print the item shown? Is that red table heated? What are these heated tables for?
  • #3 15299867
    kiriki-kun
    Level 10  
    I can't cut my head off, but probably about 30-40 minutes. Some time ago I printed this :)
    Yes, that red thing is a heated table, a "PCB heatedbed" to be exact.
    It improves the adhesion of the prints which with ABS for example is very helpful.

    A more recent print on which something already looks :)
    3D printer Frankenstein Mark_1
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 15301538
    paula9jeden
    Level 12  
    Which glass do you use?
    All the ones I've used (tempered and regular) warp and I have constant problems levelling the table because of it. I'm thinking of adding an extendable z-axis probe, but I see it's not there at your place and it works.
  • #5 15301664
    kiriki-kun
    Level 10  
    Ordinary, cheap windscreen from Allegro :)
    It is not rigidly fixed, but with clamps, and is only heated to 60 degrees. Maybe that's why nothing happens to it.
    By the way, I didn't know something like that could happen.
    As for the levelling, it's very much by eye, but I'm not complaining.
    And below are another handful of prints. I have a chance to show off and in addition you can look at how the quality of the prints looks :)
    3D printer Frankenstein Mark_1 3D printer Frankenstein Mark_1
  • #6 15301803
    george2002

    Level 21  
    kiriki-kun wrote:
    An ordinary, cheap windscreen from Allegro :)
    It is not rigidly fixed, but with clamps, and is only heated to 60 degrees. Maybe that's why nothing happens to it.
    By the way, I didn't know something like that could happen.
    As for the levelling, it's very much by eye, but I'm not complaining.
    And below are another handful of prints. I have a chance to show off and in addition you can look at how the quality of the prints looks :)
    3D printer Frankenstein Mark_1 3D printer Frankenstein Mark_1


    Very nice snowflakes, as for the first cats behind the fence these are getting better and better prints, a colleague after 3 months of trials and tests finally gets amazing prints also patience and it will pay off :)

    Greetings
    George2002
    Company Account:
    GS electronic Grzegorz Stoliński
    2 Pułku Lotniczego 18, Kraków, 31-857 | Company Website: www.gselectronic.pl
  • #7 15302251
    dudik56
    Level 17  
    Nice printer :D massive.
    kiriki-kun wrote:
    Huge clearances in the X axis, which is perpendicular to the bearings. With slow movement I calculated about 0.28mm,


    Somehow this play is unbelievably large, probably loud knocking, is it the bearing? with me there is no such play. There shouldn't be any perceptible play.
    If so, it's a defective bearing and to be replaced or a shaft that is too loose.

    Do you have such play on both sides? Maybe the bearing is swaying in the printed housing? or the shaft - guide is moving.

    I wish you smooth prints :sm9:
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #8 15302735
    jacik
    Level 12  
    Hello
    What electronics did a colleague use and why ?
    I am curious because I am at the stage of wiring my printer for which I bought a reprap 1.4 with a large 128x64 LCD. This is probably the cheapest electronics apart from the LCD ;)
  • #9 15303438
    Milek79
    Level 15  
    Cool, but you write that it's a technologically superior design to the Prusa i3, but after the prints you somehow can't see that :)
  • #10 15304401
    Ayost
    Level 12  
    I would like to know which Slicer you are using and which Firmware?

    @jacik The cheapest electronics are Sinaptec on arduino nano (DIY version).
  • #11 15304549
    kiriki-kun
    Level 10  
    The printer runs on a Sanguino, but I think the popularity of this chip is falling.

    As for print quality. The printer has been running for a week, maybe two. So far it has melted less than half a kilo of filament and I haven't really had a chance to calibrate the extruder steps and temperature properly. The table is made on plywood which shakes like jelly.
    The only reservation I have is the transverse striations on the print, which are probably caused by poor cooling or a shaking table.
    To be honest I am surprised by the quality of the prints. No blobs or holes, and for smaller pieces the print is perfect, nothing to improve.
    Anyway, reliably assessing the print quality is a bit more of a problem than looking at the prints. The print head and print speeds significantly affect this.

    As far as Firmware goes, I'm going with Repetier (it was supposed to be Marlin but it wouldn't run. I have no idea why). Slicer is Slic3r :P As I fine tune other things I'll start playing with Skeinforg because from what I understand it's a bit more advanced.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #12 15305100
    Milek79
    Level 15  
    Well, probably with an in-house build it is definitely more difficult with quality. I recently had to deal with a prusa i3 kit and the print quality is much better than yours. But the Y-axis construction on twisted rods used there is hopeless, because it's hard to twist it to be perfectly straight. And when trying to print a dragon (height 14cm) the wing broke off at the very end.
    And skeinforge is probably obsolete and not developed anymore.
  • #13 15305166
    kiriki-kun
    Level 10  
    I haven't delved into slicers yet, I'm just relying on incidentally heard information so I could be wrong.
    The printer isn't actually finished yet so it's quite easy to beat it with refined models bought from the shop :)
    There is also the issue that the prints look much better in reality.
    And I don't mean my prints, but prints from FDM printers in general.
    After changing the filament you can finally see something on the print :)
    3D printer Frankenstein Mark_1
  • #14 15306623
    Ayost
    Level 12  
    @Kiriki-kun From my own experience I would advise you against Slic3r, I used it but one day my patience came to an end as it made pointless movements without printing! It just kept riding in the "air"! I switched to Cure, I wasn't convinced at first but now I won't use another Slicer! Printing time has decreased and I am really pleased with the results of this Slicer, if you only have a little time to configure it, I recommend it wholeheartedly. You wrote about ABS printing and the heated table alone is enough to hold the print? Are you not using ABS juice, vegetable glue or hairspray?
  • #15 15306873
    kiriki-kun
    Level 10  
    I don't use ABS, I just know that a heated table is highly recommended. Yet some people only print on juice.
📢 Listen (AI):
ADVERTISEMENT