logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Aluminum Etching: Comparing Acids & Techniques for 0.3-0.5mm Plate (200x200mm) & PCB Foil

PawelSloniewicz 8823 16
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 16607590
    PawelSloniewicz
    Level 7  
    Good morning,
    I would like to etch the pattern through on an aluminum plate and I'm not a chemist ? I am asking for help.
    Aluminum plate: 0.3 or 0.5 mm 200x200mm

    Reading the topic I read that:

    1. It is worth buying the foresist film for PCBs
    - This PCB foil is etched:
    H2SO4 - Sulfuric acid (VI)
    H2O2 - Hydrogen peroxide / Perhydrol
    CH3COOH - Methane carboxylic acid / Ethane acid / Acetic acid)

    3. Aluminum etches:
    - H3PO4 - Phosphoric acid (V)
    - HNO3 - Nitric acid (V)
    - CH3COOH - Methane carboxylic acid / Ethane acid / Acetic acid
    - HF - Hydrogen fluoride
    - NaOH - Sodium hydroxide
    - hydrofluoric acid
    - iron-chloride-iii
    - or according to this movie: watch? v = 5eCDTgaxp58 such a mixture:
    a) copper sulfate / cuso - 20gr
    b) baking soda / sodium bicarbonate - 2 tablespoons
    c) salt

    I have a few questions:
    1. Which digestion acid is best to choose:
    - one that can be ordered online,
    - I want to do the experiment at home
    - one that I can pour into a plastic / metal / glass bowl and will not blow through ?
    - one that will digest aluminum through!
    - one that does not digest PCB foil
    2. The resulting pattern on aluminum must ultimately be polished to a mirror - how to do it? Sandpaper?

    Thank you very much for all your help.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 16607600
    kkknc
    Level 43  
    What pattern is this? By the way, it's a milling machine or a laser.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #3 16607604
    rumpelek
    Level 11  
    My idea is a bad idea ... too thick material, the edges will come out uneven and in general the quality of it will be under the dog ... the easiest way to give this material to the first better company dealing with metalworking - waterjet cutters are already popular in them and how I know life the cost may be small.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 16607622
    PawelSloniewicz
    Level 7  
    Thanks for the answers
    Aluminum plate: 0.3 or 0.5 mm too thick? Can you buy any thinner?
    The pattern is a small company logo, a lot of lowercase letters.
    I treat the whole project as fun ;) besides, thin aluminum is said to be able to cut the laser problem.
  • #5 16607667
    Freddy
    Level 43  
    NaOH-based baths are used for pickling aluminum.
    PawelSloniewicz wrote:
    besides, such thin aluminum is supposedly a problem with laser cutting
    Who said that?
  • #6 16607684
    rumpelek
    Level 11  
    I wrote about waterJet - water cutting.
  • #7 16607861
    PawelSloniewicz
    Level 7  
    Thank you very much for the hints :)

    @rumpelek - I was referring to the first answer (user @kkknc ) because I have friends in my company from laser machining.

    @Freddy
    Quote:
    NaOH-based baths are used for pickling aluminum.

    as I wrote in the first post - all these acids digest aluminum - the question is if anyone knows which is best for me :)
    Quote:
    Who said that?

    An industry man. He ate his teeth on lasers and said that the thin aluminum bends (?) (But we did not talk about the exact thickness of the sheet, so maybe he thought about thin as aluminum foil :) )

    Thanks again for the answers.
  • #8 16607869
    Freddy
    Level 43  
    NaOH, it's not acid :)
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #11 16607948
    PawelSloniewicz
    Level 7  
    @Freddy - thank you very much for help. I have already done research on the net - I gave everything in the first post. Now I would like to get help from a practitioner who will tell me what to use. Will NaOH process such a plate through, or will I wait half a year, for example :)
    On average, it would be wise to buy all acids (and bases) ;) ) and testing one after another. Not with my lack of experience ;)
  • #12 16607953
    Freddy
    Level 43  
    It all depends on the thickness. You have practical information, supported by theory.
    PawelSloniewicz wrote:
    I have already done research on the net - I gave everything in the first post
    Something bad :) .
    By entering "aluminum digestion" in the first answer you get the link I gave and information that aluminum is digested with alkalis, not acids.
  • #13 16608015
    PawelSloniewicz
    Level 7  
    Thank you very much for your interest in the topic and for trying to help,
    @Freedy
    Quote:
    Something bad :) .
    By entering "aluminum digestion" in the first answer you get the link I gave and information that aluminum is digested with alkalis, not acids.


    Noto, do not base your opinion on one link and accuse others of doing something poorly - it's a simple way to quarrel online :)

    I don't know if these links are true:
    https://www.elektroda.pl/rtvforum/topic2281315.html#10829669 - acids
    http://www.lerncoach.li/laboratorium-2/wytrawianie- uprzedrzchni-metali-stali-aluminium - acids
    https://www.elektroda.pl/rtvforum/topic48993.html#231500 - acids
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5eCDTgaxp58 - a mix from the first post
    https://www.elektroda.pl/rtvforum/topic666062.html#3441656 - here a valuable post
  • #14 16608025
    Freddy
    Level 43  
    PawelSloniewicz wrote:
    Noto do not base your opinion on one link and accuse others of doing something poorly ...
    I based on my many years of experience and supported a link to the thematic page, but if you know better and think that I am wrong, I am sorry for that - keep looking for yourself.
    If there is no information about NaOH in any of the links and you think YouTube is reliable, please forgive, but keep looking for yourself.

    PawelSloniewicz wrote:

    Quote:
    I agree with this several times prubowalem and I can say that the plate digests faster [but now I have an aquarium and grass in b327]

    ps: once when I had a lot of chloride I did such an experiment with aluminum [I wanted to check if I could make an "aluminum" plate :D ], I say in advance -> it doesn't work, but I noticed that aluminum digests quickly [Readuje] and sei wytwaza A lot of energy, which heats the chloride to around 40 ° C :D , I just don't know if it would be possible to use such chloride again, but it warmed up very quickly :D

    Very valuable, especially for Professor Miodek. ;)

    PS. Wait, I will post on YouTube a video about digestion of aluminum in distilled water with the addition of pepper :)
  • #15 16608150
    PawelSloniewicz
    Level 7  
    Returning to the question from the topic:
    Will NaOH etch a 0.3mm aluminum plate through?
    can it be done at home without severe burns? :)
    I would like exactly something like aluminum: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ilJg-MfYg2s
  • Helpful post
    #16 16608483
    Nori2
    Level 22  
    PawelSloniewicz wrote:
    Will NaOH etch a 0.3mm aluminum plate through?

    Etching.
    The digestion rate will depend on the NaOH concentration, solution temperature and mixing intensity.
    There is only a small problem ..... concentrated sodium hydroxide dissolves both unexposed and exposed photosensitive film.
  • Helpful post
    #17 16608736
    telecaster1951
    VIP Meritorious for electroda.pl
    PawelSloniewicz wrote:

    An industry man. He ate his teeth on lasers and said that the thin aluminum bends (?) (But we did not talk about the exact thickness of the sheet, so maybe he thought about thin as aluminum foil :) )
    The laser will tear. Too thin sheet for laser cutting, and too thick for ablation.

    PawelSloniewicz wrote:

    Will NaOH etch a 0.3mm aluminum plate through?
    Etching. But not selectively.

    Why aluminum? This thick sheet will bend like stupid. Brass would be 100 times better. I do not see a real possibility of etching aluminum components at home.
    Freddy wrote:
    that aluminum is digested with alkalis, not acids.
    Not true! Etched with diluted nitrogen. However, this will be annoying, because before etching you need to remove oxide from the digested surface. The rules are not entirely true either. Only strong Brönsted bases can complex aluminum oxide.

    Added after 1 [minutes]:

    PawelSloniewicz wrote:

    2. The resulting pattern on aluminum must ultimately be polished to a mirror - how to do it? Sandpaper?
    First paper from 100 to 2500 (wet) and finally a minimum of 60 paste.

Topic summary

The discussion revolves around etching aluminum plates (0.3-0.5mm thick, 200x200mm) using various acids and techniques. The user seeks advice on the best acid for etching, considering options like sulfuric acid, phosphoric acid, nitric acid, and sodium hydroxide. Responses highlight the challenges of etching aluminum at home, particularly the risk of uneven edges and bending due to the material's thickness. Suggestions include using waterjet cutting services for better quality results. The effectiveness of sodium hydroxide for etching is debated, with emphasis on the need to remove aluminum oxide before etching. The conversation also touches on the limitations of laser cutting for thin sheets and the importance of solution concentration and temperature in the etching process.
Summary generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT