logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Best Home Multifunction Device Under PLN 300: Canon PIXMA MG3650 vs MG5750 & Alternatives

kamil_77 7311 11
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 17046760
    kamil_77
    Level 7  
    Posts: 25
    Rate: 6
    Hi
    I need to buy an MFD (printer, photocopier, scanner). The equipment will be intended for home use mainly for printing various types of documents. First of all, I care about reliability as far as possible because in the last 15 years two such devices have broken down, although they were not heavily used, and also on consumables, i.e. that the cost of toners was not too expensive compared to other devices.
    As for the budget, I could allocate up to PLN 300 and the equipment interested me Canon PIXMA MG3650 and Canon PIXMA MG5750 but due to the fact that two multifunction devices have already dropped out (bad luck do they have it?) that the service did not want to repair because it did not pay or parts were not but for this you pay for the cost of expertise from 40 to 60 zlotys so again it will not be it was worth repairing and that's why I'm thinking about buying a cheaper device.

    What do you think about my Canon proposals, and what else do you propose? Is there anything better in this price range?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 17064542
    Krzysztof Druś
    Level 21  
    Posts: 387
    Help: 35
    Rate: 85
    I give up I suggested several printers were to be good cheap in operation up to PLN 300
    I gave 3 models that I know and know how they work, but they do not answer in terms of the lack of guarantee that it is to be new.

    Added after 1 [minutes]:

    Hp B110
    Hp B111

    Added after 41 [seconds]:

    HP DESKJET 3520
    Hp Photosmart 5514
  • #3 17064579
    helmud7543
    Level 43  
    Posts: 12618
    Help: 1216
    Rate: 1563
    But stupidity is food.
    MFP is a general term for multifunction devices, it was good to understand this term when writing about printers.
    HP, if anything, often uses the term All in one, but it doesn't have to be written either.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 17064590
    Krzysztof Druś
    Level 21  
    Posts: 387
    Help: 35
    Rate: 85
    So how do you know each other so please advise the author to buy up to PLN 300 so that it would be cheap to use the printer, photocopier, new scanner and still with a 2-year warranty
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #5 17064608
    helmud7543
    Level 43  
    Posts: 12618
    Help: 1216
    Rate: 1563
    Whatever HP with a scanner will be good (heads with ink, in those with permanent heads fall extremely often). 15 years - I don't know if it's achievable, a matter of chance, the quality of workmanship has long gone to dogs and you can't do anything about it. My PSC 1410 survived 15 years and it still works. But it won't be cheap in operation. I do not know if it is possible to buy new, durable, cheap to buy and use at the same time. HP is not cheap to operate, but it is relatively durable.

    EDIT> My error - given by a colleague HP have a built-in head. Maintenance (ink) cheaper, but the death of the head is a serious economic problem. And this is the scourge of today's printers.
  • #6 17073323
    rys57
    Moderator
    Posts: 5819
    Help: 212
    Rate: 436
    I cleared the topic of posts with little or nothing to add to the case.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #7 17626615
    limak00
    Level 10  
    Posts: 109
    Rate: 23
    Hello,
    what do you recommend today ???
    home use (cheap inks)
    because my brother dcp-115 finished
    maybe already wi-fi
    thanks for the help :)
  • #8 17626647
    helmud7543
    Level 43  
    Posts: 12618
    Help: 1216
    Rate: 1563
    How much can you spend to buy? What print outlays? Cheap inks are the head in the printer, and this means that if it falls and the equipment after warranty, the repair will exceed the value of the device. Do you accept this solution or do you expect something permanent?
  • #9 17626748
    limak00
    Level 10  
    Posts: 109
    Rate: 23
    I think about PLN 300 (whether to wait and spend more) I would like it to be cheap to use, I occasionally print some document from photocopying or printing (usually not :D )
  • #10 17639627
    fifek62
    Level 23  
    Posts: 455
    Help: 66
    Rate: 285
    I recommend the Epson Xp-245 or XP-342 on eternal inks + bottles
  • #11 17662280
    limak00
    Level 10  
    Posts: 109
    Rate: 23
    Hello
    How are these eternal inks mounted? Where is the best, cheapest to buy?
  • #12 17669362
    fifek62
    Level 23  
    Posts: 455
    Help: 66
    Rate: 285
    I think it's the cheapest to buy a device with eternal inks installed on the auction site.

    Moderated By rys57:

    The house ad part was deleted.

Topic summary

✨ The discussion revolves around selecting a reliable multifunction device (MFD) for home use under PLN 300, focusing on the Canon PIXMA MG3650 and MG5750. Users express concerns about the reliability and cost of consumables, particularly ink and toners, given past experiences with malfunctioning devices. Recommendations include various HP models (B110, B111, DeskJet 3520, Photosmart 5514) and Epson models (XP-245, XP-342) with "eternal inks" for cost-effective operation. The conversation highlights the importance of warranty and the potential high repair costs associated with devices that have built-in ink heads.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: Under PLN 300, expect trade-offs: 15 years is exceptional and “the death of the head is a serious economic problem.” For reliability choose cartridge‑head models; for cheapest pages consider CISS‑ready Epsons. [Elektroda, helmud7543, post #17064608]

Why it matters: It guides home users in Poland to pick a reliable, cheap‑to‑run MFD under PLN 300 without costly mistakes.

Quick Facts

What’s the best home MFD under PLN 300 for reliability and low costs?

Pick a priority. For reliability, choose models with printheads in the cartridge. For the cheapest pages, use a permanent‑head inkjet with CISS. As one expert warned, “permanent heads fall extremely often.” Match the risk to how much and how often you print. [Elektroda, helmud7543, post #17064608]

Canon PIXMA MG3650 vs MG5750 — which fits this budget better?

Both are consumer inkjets. Decide by consumables and head design. If they use permanent heads, inks can be cheaper but a head failure costs dearly. If reliability matters more, consider cartridge‑head alternatives. “The death of the head is a serious economic problem.” [Elektroda, helmud7543, post #17064608]

Are HP all‑in‑one printers more durable?

Yes, one user notes HP is relatively durable. Their HP PSC 1410 still works after 15 years. That’s exceptional, not guaranteed. The bigger factor is head type and how you use the printer. “HP is relatively durable,” but expect trade‑offs in ink cost. [Elektroda, helmud7543, post #17064608]

Can I get a new MFD with a 2‑year warranty and low running costs under PLN 300?

It’s difficult. The adviser listed several low‑cost models but noted they didn’t meet the “new with warranty” requirement. At this price, expect to compromise on either warranty status, features, or running costs. [Elektroda, Krzysztof Drub, post #17064542]

Which specific models were suggested in the thread?

Suggested options included HP B110, HP B111, HP Deskjet 3520, and HP Photosmart 5514. Verify availability and condition, as the recommendations did not guarantee brand‑new stock with full warranty. [Elektroda, Krzysztof Drub, post #17064542]

How long can a home MFD last?

One report cites an HP PSC 1410 still working after 15 years. That’s an outlier. Build quality has declined, and permanent heads can fail after warranty. “Quality of workmanship has long gone to dogs,” said an experienced user. [Elektroda, helmud7543, post #17064608]

What are eternal inks (CISS) and when should I consider them?

CISS adds external tanks feeding ink continuously, slashing page costs. A user recommended Epson XP‑245 or XP‑342 with CISS and bottles for home savings. Consider CISS if you print often and want minimal ink expense. [Elektroda, fifek62, post #17639627]

How do I get eternal inks installed cheaply?

How‑To:
  1. Choose a printer sold with CISS preinstalled from a trusted auction listing.
  2. Buy the preinstalled bundle and keep all included setup instructions.
  3. Follow the seller’s steps exactly for first power‑up and priming. [Elektroda, fifek62, post #17669362]

Are repairs worth it on budget inkjets?

Often no. Diagnosis alone can cost PLN 40–60, and services may decline uneconomical repairs. For low‑priced devices, replacing the unit is frequently cheaper than fixing it. Factor this into your initial purchase decision. [Elektroda, kamil_77, post #17046760]

I print rarely. Should I avoid permanent‑head printers?

Yes. Permanent‑head designs can fail when underused. As one expert put it, “in those with permanent heads [they] fall extremely often.” Cartridge‑head models better tolerate sporadic use because replacing the cartridge refreshes the head. [Elektroda, helmud7543, post #17064608]

I had a Brother DCP‑115. Whats a cheap‑to‑run replacement with Wi‑Fi?

Consider Epson XP‑245 or XP‑342 paired with CISS for very low ink costs. If you need Wi‑Fi, choose a variant that lists wireless in its specs before buying. This balances convenience with cost per page. [Elektroda, fifek62, post #17639627]

What hidden costs come with cheap‑ink setups?

Cheap inks often pair with printer‑integrated heads. If that head fails after warranty, repair can exceed device value. As noted, “the repair will exceed the value of the device.” Budget for the risk or choose cartridge‑head models. [Elektroda, helmud7543, post #17626647]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT