logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

C4 Picasso 1.6 HDI FAP 2009 - After replacing the EGR valve still errors and ign

daniel13m 29973 17
Best answers

Why does a 2009 Citroën C4 Picasso 1.6 HDi still show EGR faults after replacing the EGR valve, and what replacement or checks can fix it?

The most likely cause is a bad or incompatible replacement EGR valve, because users reported the same faults with cheap NTY valves and said the problem went away only after fitting a Valeo or original valve and doing the adaptation [#17398369] [#17398822] [#18028657] One reply also notes that in French cars the EGR connector pins can have poor contact, so the plug and terminal pressure should be checked even if the connector is new [#17398069] Another user observed that when the valve did not click during the Diagbox test, 12 V was also missing at the actuator, so the control/wiring side should still be verified if a known-good valve does not work [#17398107] The thread’s practical recommendation is to use an OEM-quality valve, confirm the connector/wiring, and then repeat the adaptation procedure [#17399347]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 17397860
    daniel13m
    Level 10  
    Posts: 6
    Rate: 5
    C4 Picasso 1.6 HDI car with FAP 2009 109 km. Mileage 171 thousand km. MCP gearbox.
    I am asking for your understanding. This is my first post :)

    I have a car for 2 years. In May, the "check engine" light and the message "antipollution system fault" lit up.
    After connecting Diagbox ver. 7.02 I read the following errors:
    P0405 - EGR valve electrical connection signal
    P1459 - EGR valve electrical connection signal
    P0409 - EGR valve electrical connection signal
    P0490 - EGR valve electrical connection signal
    P0489 - EGR valve electrical connection signal
    (error descriptions can be supplemented later when I reconnect the tester)

    The following errors remained after deletion:
    P0490 - EGR valve electrical connection signal
    P1459 - EGR valve electrical connection signal

    I replaced the EGR valve with a NTY replacement

    C4 Picasso 1.6 HDI FAP 2009 - After replacing the EGR valve still errors and ign

    Unfortunately, after replacing the valve, unsuccessful adaptation and deletion, I have the following errors:
    P0490 - EGR valve electrical connection signal
    P1459 - EGR valve electrical connection signal
    P0409 - EGR valve electrical connection signal - valve stuck during learning
    (adaptation carried out on a cold engine after night brought nothing)

    Then I replaced the new one - the plug and installation from the plug to the controller (the new plug completely with new pins, installation soldered about 5 cm from the plugs at the controller). Old installation cut and removed. And nothing helped.

    When testing the components, the EGR valve works once and you hear clicking after some time does not work.
    Even if the valve works during tests, it is not possible to carry out the adaptation, and after removal immediately, before firing the engine errors P0490 and P1459 and P0409 appear if the adaptation was performed.

    I will add that the "check engine" indicator lights up when driving with a heavy load, eg overtaking uphill at high speed or when driving uphill at a speed of 120-130 km / h. Then the car goes into emergency mode and reaches a maximum speed of about 2750. Cruise control also stops working. After restarting the engine the "check engine" indicator lights up but the revs and cruise control return to normal.

    Recently during the performance of EGR tests using Diagbox, EGR worked 2-3 times out of 10-15 tests. Sometimes it helps temporarily disconnect the battery. When driving with the tester, the "RCO value of the exhaust gas recirculation solenoid valve" was constant at level 0. Sometimes the "EGR throttle position" value changed on the graph.

    I organized 2 used, original EGR valves (I have no idea if they are working) and after connecting the same.

    Is the problem only a non-original EGR valve?
    Does anyone have to sell a used, functional EGR or can recommend a new replacement that will work 100%.
    Maybe someone from Jelenia Góra or the surrounding area has a functional EGR or can help in the diagnosis?

    Moderated By CameR:

    I deleted the link to Allegro.
    Reg. 3.1.18. Do not send links that will stop working after some time. This will cause the discussion to lose any meaning.

  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 17398069
    gregor_pn
    Level 16  
    Posts: 110
    Help: 16
    Rate: 30
    I am not a specialist but ...
    1. new may be damaged.
    2. I heard that in the French in the case of EGR there is a problem with the plugs - you have to squeeze them because they do not give contact. Anyway, they have the same injection plugs, etc. I know that it may be stupid but a lot of cars I repaired and when the plug is not on the prong but flat, there are often some loose and it doesn't touch.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #3 17398107
    daniel13m
    Level 10  
    Posts: 6
    Rate: 5
    The cable plug is completely new.

    I will add that when I measure 12V between contacts 2 and 3 on a connected valve, if I can't hear the valve working during the Diagbox test, I don't have voltage on the meter either (measurement on the wires a few centimeters from the controller).

    The 5V voltage between pins 1 and 5 is.
    I just don't know what to have on signal pin 4 (should it be 0-5V or can you only measure on the oscilloscope?)

    To be honest, this driver falls under my control, only that the diagnostician / electronics from Citroen excludes the driver from working once and not once and betting on the EGR valve and that it should only be original.
  • #4 17398369
    Tiamath30
    Level 10  
    Posts: 23
    Help: 3
    Rate: 17
    I also had a problem with Eger and I had to buy for over 500 onions but now it's ok. Valeo company.
  • #5 17398388
    daniel13m
    Level 10  
    Posts: 6
    Rate: 5
    To Tiamath30
    You can describe your problems, errors with the EGR valve before replacement and after replacement for a cheaper replacement.
    If you can, give the link to the EGR valve that you used and is now OK.
    Let me know if you did an apprenticeship for the EGR valve and on a cold engine?
  • #6 17398822
    Tiamath30
    Level 10  
    Posts: 23
    Help: 3
    Rate: 17
    I had a problem with the Christmas tree on the anti-evolution check engine esp abs and something else + full of errors on the computer. It turned out that the egr died. He replaced a mechanic for this one
    C4 Picasso 1.6 HDI FAP 2009 - After replacing the EGR valve still errors and ign

    And he did adaptations. He previously ordered cheaper but it was lime.

    Moderated By CameR:

    The link to Allegro has been removed.
    Reg. 3.1.18. Do not send links that will stop working after some time. This will cause the discussion to lose any meaning.

  • #7 17398986
    milejow

    Level 43  
    Posts: 13047
    Help: 1558
    Rate: 5104
    I recently had the opportunity to test NTY products, namely the level and temperature sensor, oil for the VAG group, each showed a different and false oil temperature (one even -66 * C :D )
    Company Account:
    Działalność własna
    Mętów 99, Lublin, 20-388
  • #8 17399347
    daniel13m
    Level 10  
    Posts: 6
    Rate: 5
    Thanks for the info.
    Maybe someone else had problems with cheap EGR replacements and describe what were the problems.
    I guess I will buy a Valeo valve the same as I bought Tiamath30.
    I hope this solves the problem.
  • #9 17687024
    Izythor
    Level 9  
    Posts: 56
    Rate: 12
    Hello, I'll dig up the topic a little. 9HZ engine, so probably the same. I had no visible problems with the car, I have had the car for 2 months, I connected the DB. It showed errors as in the attachments. Initial P0488 and P1161 removed them, but after a while they appeared again, plus errors P1162 and P0401. In history you can see that errors appear and disappear from time to time. In addition, in the parameters I found in one calculator, the error of learning egr (I do not remember whether the valve or the throttle), the value of the air flow per cylinder (as in error p0401) at ease almost 2 times greater than the set value, after adding the gas the difference is eliminated and almost disappears . Does cleaning the egr can help or is there anything to worry about, because these errors are temporary, not permanent, and nothing bad happens with the car while driving. Can this egr behavior have a bad effect on the FAP filter?

    C4 Picasso 1.6 HDI FAP 2009 - After replacing the EGR valve still errors and ign C4 Picasso 1.6 HDI FAP 2009 - After replacing the EGR valve still errors and ign C4 Picasso 1.6 HDI FAP 2009 - After replacing the EGR valve still errors and ign
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #10 17687133
    jurekk55
    Level 36  
    Posts: 3698
    Help: 182
    Rate: 1575
    Do you have two air cycles in your car? Direct and via intercooler?
  • #11 17688654
    Izythor
    Level 9  
    Posts: 56
    Rate: 12
    As far as I know, yes.
  • #12 17693958
    jurekk55
    Level 36  
    Posts: 3698
    Help: 182
    Rate: 1575
    What's up Which system do you have?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #13 17694206
    Izythor
    Level 9  
    Posts: 56
    Rate: 12
    Two circuits.
  • #14 17694376
    jurekk55
    Level 36  
    Posts: 3698
    Help: 182
    Rate: 1575
    Make a proper calibration of the system you have in the car, according to the manufacturer's recommendations. You've got hints in the program.
  • #15 17694410
    Izythor
    Level 9  
    Posts: 56
    Rate: 12
    I did not exchange any parts. The only adaptation (not calibration) I can do is egr and throttle. I understand that you write about the throttle.
  • #16 17910892
    see_boo
    Level 2  
    Posts: 4
    I'm connecting under the topic.
    1.6 HDI 80kW engine in 308 from 2008 without FAP, errors from Diagbox are P1459 and P0490. I have had the car for a month, I do not know if there was something done with the EGR, but the check engine does not light up, the car accelerates at every rpm, the exhaust gases are transparent regardless of the engine load. I have an appointment with the mechanic only after the May weekend. Any ideas what this could be? Blinded EGR would generate such errors?
  • #17 18028657
    smykm
    Level 11  
    Posts: 38
    Rate: 28
    daniel13m wrote:
    Thanks for the info.
    Maybe someone else had problems with cheap EGR replacements and describe what were the problems.
    I guess I will buy a Valeo valve the same as I bought Tiamath30.
    I hope this solves the problem.


    Did you solve the problem?
    I have similar errors except that my car jerks and does not display the check engine. I have already done 2 EGR valves NTY and one Valeo.
  • #18 18424292
    Natalka1172
    Level 1  
    Posts: 1
    Hello. We recently have a problem with Egr. We have a Toyote Corolla Verso. Several times we were in Toyota for diagnostics, only EGR error burns. Replacement for a replacement. The car lint, there is no power when it is cold (does not exceed 2 thousand revolutions). It turned out that the replacement did not work well.Toyota took the old broken original to resuscitate him (put in acid) they replaced ... I left without a fingerstick lights, standing on the door a new orange light (engine error, VSC, TRC OFF). Return for diagnostics .It turned out that you need a new original. Next Tuesday I have an exchange contract, but now I came back from the store and the controls went out. The car does not pull, it runs smoothly even when it is cold. Earlier we heard that when the new Egr we need to burn it ( high speed but low gear). I was stupid because I do not know what to do? I did not call refuse to exchange because I do not know if it will not catch fire yet. I have time until Tuesday. See.

Topic summary

✨ The discussion revolves around issues with the EGR valve in a 2009 Citroën C4 Picasso 1.6 HDI FAP. The user reports persistent error codes related to the EGR valve even after replacing it with a NTY part. Various contributors suggest potential causes for the ongoing errors, including the possibility of a faulty new valve, issues with electrical connections, and the need for proper adaptation of the EGR system. Some users recommend using original parts, such as those from Valeo, to avoid problems associated with cheaper replacements. The conversation also touches on the importance of calibration and diagnostics using tools like Diagbox to address the EGR-related faults effectively.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: On PSA 1.6 HDi, if RCO stays at 0% and "valve stuck during learning" appears, suspect EGR control, wiring, or non‑OEM parts; use Valeo and recalibrate in Diagbox. For C4 Picasso owners fixing P0490/P1459/P0409 after EGR swap. [Elektroda, daniel13m, post #17397860]

Why it matters: It helps PSA diesel owners fix stubborn EGR code loops without guesswork or repeat parts.

Quick Facts

What do P0490, P1459, and P0409 mean on a C4 Picasso 1.6 HDi?

They indicate EGR control circuit and learning faults. Diagbox described P0409 as “valve stuck during learning.” The RCO command stayed at 0%, showing no EGR actuation. That combination suggests a non‑responsive valve or a power/command issue. Clear codes, then command EGR and watch RCO change. [Elektroda, daniel13m, post #17397860]

Why does EGR adaptation fail right after installing a new valve?

Learning fails when the ECU cannot move the valve reliably. The NTY replacement worked in only 2–3 of 10–15 tests, then codes reappeared immediately. The ECU re‑logged P0490 and P1459 after erasing. That pattern points to control integrity or part quality issues. Use a proven unit and recalibrate. [Elektroda, daniel13m, post #17397860]

Is a non‑original EGR valve the problem? Which brand actually works?

Yes, users reported cheap replacements failed. Switching to a Valeo EGR fixed the issue after adaptations. As one owner put it, “He previously ordered cheaper but it was lime.” Use a known-good unit and complete learning. [Elektroda, Tiamath30, post #17398822]

How do I calibrate EGR/throttle correctly in Diagbox?

Run the guided routine with the engine in the specified state. Follow the intake configuration prompts exactly. “Make a proper calibration of the system you have… You’ve got hints in the program.”
  1. Clear EGR faults and warm/cool as prompted.
  2. Run EGR and throttle learning in Diagbox.
  3. Verify RCO and position track during a road test. [Elektroda, jurekk55, post #17694376]

What should I see on the EGR connector pins during testing?

Expect a 5V reference between pins 1 and 5. Expect 12V across pins 2 and 3 only when the ECU commands movement. Pin 4 carries the position signal; observe change while commanding, ideally with an oscilloscope. If 12V disappears during tests, suspect the command path or supply. [Elektroda, daniel13m, post #17398107]

Can bad connectors cause intermittent EGR errors?

Yes. French looms often suffer from loose flat terminals. “You have to squeeze them because they do not give contact.” Slight play causes dropouts under vibration. Tighten the terminals or replace the plug to restore reliable contact. [Elektroda, gregor_pn, post #17398069]

Why does the check engine appear only under load and cruise control stop?

Heavy load can trigger limp mode when EGR control fails. The car reported the MIL during uphill overtakes at 120–130 km/h. The ECU limited revs to about 2750 rpm and disabled cruise. After restart, power and cruise returned, but the MIL remained. Fix EGR control to stop limp events. [Elektroda, daniel13m, post #17397860]

Will cleaning EGR help with P0488, P1161, P1162, P0401 that come and go?

Your logs show an EGR learning error and idle airflow per cylinder nearly twice the target. After throttle, the difference almost disappears. Clean the EGR and throttle, then run calibration. Recheck that measured airflow aligns with the setpoint. This stabilizes control and reduces recurring flags. [Elektroda, Izythor, post #17687024]

Could a blanked EGR cause P1459 and P0490 without a check engine lamp?

Yes. Those codes reflect EGR control mismatch even if the cluster does not light the MIL. Your car accelerates normally, which fits a disabled or blanked EGR scenario. Inspect for a blanking plate, restore flow control, and then recalibrate. [Elektroda, see_boo, post #17910892]

What if two NTY and one Valeo EGR still leave jerking and no MIL?

Look beyond the valve for the root cause. Verify power and ground integrity to the actuator. Check the throttle shutter, intake leaks, and MAF readings. Perform calibration after each intervention. Jerking suggests airflow or control issues, not only the EGR element. [Elektroda, smykm, post #18028657]

Are NTY sensors reliable for engine management diagnostics?

Use caution. A user tested NTY oil level/temperature sensors that reported false temperatures. One read −66°C, an obvious failure. Bad feedback can mislead diagnosis and adaptations. Prefer reputable brands for critical inputs. [Elektroda, milejow, post #17398986]

Does having two air circuits change calibration steps?

Yes. The routine must match your intake routing. “Make a proper calibration of the system you have.” Follow the Diagbox prompts for your specific two‑circuit layout to ensure correct learned values. [Elektroda, jurekk55, post #17694376]

Toyota Corolla Verso shows EGR fault with VSC and TRC OFF. Replace with OEM?

The dealer found only an EGR fault. An aftermarket unit didn’t work, so the shop acid‑cleaned the original. After refit, MIL, VSC, and TRC OFF appeared, then extinguished, but cold performance stayed poor. Proceed with the planned OEM EGR and adaptation. [Elektroda, Natalka1172, post #18424292]

How do I separate ECU or harness faults from a bad EGR?

Measure during commanded tests. If 12V across pins 2–3 is present only sometimes, the ECU isn’t always driving the valve. The plug and a section of harness were renewed, yet faults persisted. That points to control electronics or upstream supply issues. Verify continuity and grounds to the controller. [Elektroda, daniel13m, post #17398107]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT