logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda
Advanced Search
logo elektroda

UPC Connect Box vs Play Kaon AR2140 router: Comparison, opinions and choice of better equipment

bandolero87 20352 14
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
Report a violation of the law
Reply | New topic
  • #1 20391266
    bandolero87
    Level 2  
    Posts: 3
    I have a question. I decided to sign a 12-month contract with UPC for PLN 50/month. It's strange because the offer I ordered included a Connect Box router, I think it was offered with a signal amplifier, from what I later found out from UPC's videos on YouTube. However, the technician installed a completely different router than the one offered because I received a Kaon AR2140 play router. He said that the one he is installing is better than Connect Box from UPC. I wonder if he was telling the truth or he was fooling me. Could you tell me which of these routers is better and more modern and whether the technician tricked me or was he telling the truth?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 20391482
    KOCUREK1970
    Network and Internet specialist  
    Posts: 35142
    Help: 3787
    Rate: 5328
    @bandolero87
    It doesn`t matter at all.
    The installer installs the modem/router/modemorouter that will be issued to him from the warehouse, depending on the technology in which the Internet is provided.

    UPC was bought by Play, so they decide.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 20419010
    bandolero87
    Level 2  
    Posts: 3
    And what is this bridge?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #5 20630361
    KOCUREK1970
    Network and Internet specialist  
    Posts: 35142
    Help: 3787
    Rate: 5328
    bandolero87 wrote:
    And what is this bridge?

    Modem router mode - this is something different than router mode.
    artaa wrote:
    Generally, it has e.g. Bridge:

    Generally, there is no such operating mode in PLAY on this device.
    bandolero87 wrote:
    Could you tell me which of these routers is better and more modern and whether the technician tricked me or was he telling the truth?

    CB has been on the market since 2015 and has its drawbacks.
    As is the case with Kaon, you have to wait a few years for the equipment to become popular - although that won`t be the case here, because PLAY introduced a completely different device: PlayBoxNet
  • #6 20836337
    arturm
    Level 12  
    Posts: 27
    Help: 1
    Rate: 5

    I'll dig up the thread a bit. Is there any solution to use your own router for fiber-optic internet from Play with the Huawei K562 router?
  • #7 20891748
    emnetstudiopl
    Level 1  
    Posts: 1

    It is not possible. It serves as an ONT or on a leased network it is a device assigned to the client according to its S/N. At most, you can connect your own one to the one received from the operator.
  • #8 20891890
    Erbit
    Level 39  
    Posts: 5364
    Help: 478
    Rate: 1308
    arturm wrote:
    I`ll dig up the thread a bit. Is there any solution to use your own router for fiber-optic internet from Play with the Huawei K562 router?


    Why do you want to have your own router?
  • #9 20892039
    arturm
    Level 12  
    Posts: 27
    Help: 1
    Rate: 5

    Erbit wrote:
    arturm wrote:
    I`ll dig up the thread a bit. Is there any solution to use your own router for fiber-optic internet from Play with the Huawei K562 router?


    Why do you want your own router?


    I want to set up my own private cloud for externally accessible media and my own websites (I am a programmer).
  • #10 20892133
    Erbit
    Level 39  
    Posts: 5364
    Help: 478
    Rate: 1308
    arturm wrote:

    ....
    I want to set up my own private cloud for externally accessible media and my own websites (I am a programmer).


    This is a bad idea for so many reasons but...

    You need a public address (preferably static) on your router`s interface. To do this, you need to replace the provider`s router or use bridge mode on it. Originally, this router has a bridge mode, but the operator may have blocked it.


    Then ask your supplier about:
    - public IP address
    - bridge mode on their router.


    Use a VPN for media available from outside (no redirections) and preferably place your own websites outside (on purchased hosting), also for security reasons.

    Making redirects is a threat of a direct attack on devices exposed through such redirects, which may result in e.g. -> https://www.elektroda.pl/rtvforum/topic4008323.html or disk encryption.
  • #11 20892950
    arturm
    Level 12  
    Posts: 27
    Help: 1
    Rate: 5

    Erbit wrote:
    arturm wrote:

    ....
    I want to set up my own private cloud for externally accessible media and my own websites (I am a programmer).


    This is a bad idea for so many reasons, but...

    You need a public address (preferably static) on your router's interface. To do this, you need to replace the provider's router or use bridge mode on it. Originally, this router has a bridge mode, but the operator may have blocked it.


    Then ask your supplier about:
    - public IP address
    - bridge mode on their router.


    Use a VPN for media available from outside (no redirections) and preferably place your own websites outside (on purchased hosting), also for security reasons.

    Making redirects is a threat of a direct attack on devices exposed through such redirects, which may result in e.g. -> https://www.elektroda.pl/rtvforum/topic4008323.html or disk encryption.


    Everything you wrote above is obvious to me. That's why I want to use my own router, configure DMZ and routing myself, etc. I'm just asking if there's any chance of replacing their router in Play? Are there any companies in Poland that can handle replacing the Play ONT/router, or possibly offer an SFP insert that I can plug into my own router?
  • #12 20892986
    Erbit
    Level 39  
    Posts: 5364
    Help: 478
    Rate: 1308
    arturm wrote:

    .... I`m just asking if there is any chance to replace their router in Play? Are there any companies in Poland that can handle replacing the Play ONT/router, or possibly offer an SFP insert that I can plug into my own router?


    I don`t think you asked about that.

    However, since this is... as a rule, it is not possible to connect your own equipment if the ISP does not agree to it or makes it impossible for technical reasons, even though it is inconsistent with the EU directive, which I can refer to if necessary. That`s why I pointed out the above-mentioned solutions that, in cooperation with the ISP, will enable the goal to be achieved in a "legal" way.

    However... I know that on another forum people replace the ONT received from the ISP with their own (or insert) and program it. The effects are very good, but for a few days some of them have had their connection banned, so... decide for yourself whether to fight or pick up the phone and call the ISP.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #13 20893468
    arturm
    Level 12  
    Posts: 27
    Help: 1
    Rate: 5

    Erbit wrote:

    However... I know that on another forum people replace the ONT received from the ISP with their own (or insert) and program it. The effects are very good, but for a few days now some of them have had their connection banned, so... decide for yourself whether to fight or pick up the phone and call the ISP.

    Could you provide a link to this forum?
  • #15 20907123
    arturm
    Level 12  
    Posts: 27
    Help: 1
    Rate: 5

    Erbit wrote:
    The UPC guys weren't crazy there.

    Orange -> https://trzepak.pl/viewtopic.php?t=51177 (for information, start from the end)

    Netia -> https://trzepak.pl/viewtopic.php?t=64891

    Or start a new topic, maybe someone has already done it somewhere


    Thanks for the links. It looks like my current carrier has wised up and will switch their router to bridge mode. If everything goes well, I will stay with them.
Reply | New topic
Report a violation of the law

Topic summary

✨ The discussion revolves around a user's experience with UPC's Connect Box router versus the Kaon AR2140 router installed by a technician. The user questions the technician's claim that the Kaon router is superior to the Connect Box. Responses indicate that the choice of router is often determined by the ISP's inventory and technology, with some users suggesting that the Kaon AR2140 may have advantages over the Connect Box, which has been criticized for its age and limitations. The conversation also touches on the possibility of using personal routers with ISP-provided equipment and the implications of doing so, including potential technical challenges and compliance with ISP policies.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: "CB has been on the market since 2015"; in Play the Kaon AR2140 generally lacks Bridge mode. Choose by features, not brand. For hosting, request a public IP and Bridge, or run your router behind theirs. [Elektroda, KOCUREK1970, post #20630361]

Why it matters: This FAQ helps UPC/Play users compare routers, understand bridge vs router mode, and safely use their own router or host services.

Quick Facts

Which is better: UPC Connect Box or the Play Kaon AR2140?

Connect Box is older hardware (released in 2015) and has known drawbacks. In Play, the Kaon AR2140 generally lacks Bridge mode, which limits advanced setups. The “better” choice depends on your needs: if you require Bridge or custom routing, plan to run your own router behind the ISP device. Play is also rolling out PlayBoxNet, so hardware may change. [Elektroda, KOCUREK1970, post #20630361]

Did the technician trick me by installing a different router than advertised?

No. Installers deploy the modem/router issued for your access technology. After Play acquired UPC, Play decides what hardware you get. "UPC was bought by Play, so they decide." If you need a specific feature, request it from the ISP in advance. [Elektroda, KOCUREK1970, post #20391482]

What is Bridge mode and why would I want it?

Bridge mode passes the public IP to your own router and disables routing/NAT on the ISP box. It enables clean inbound connections for hosting. "You need a public address (preferably static) on your router’s interface." If Bridge is blocked, use your router behind theirs and consider VPN for remote access. [Elektroda, Erbit, post #20892133]

Does the Play Kaon AR2140 have Bridge mode?

In Play, this device generally does not expose Bridge mode to users. "Generally, there is no such operating mode in PLAY on this device." Plan to use your own router downstream if you need advanced control. [Elektroda, KOCUREK1970, post #20630361]

Can I use my own router with Play fiber when I have a Huawei K562?

You cannot replace the K562. It operates as an ONT or is bound to your account by serial number. You can connect your own router behind the K562 to manage Wi‑Fi and LAN features, but the K562 stays in the chain. [Elektroda, emnetstudiopl, post #20891748]

How do I use my own router behind the ISP device (simple steps)?

  1. Ask your provider for a public IP and to enable Bridge mode on their router.
  2. If Bridge is enabled, connect your router’s WAN to the ISP device and let it obtain the public IP.
  3. If Bridge is blocked, keep your router downstream and use a VPN for secure external access instead of port forwards. [Elektroda, Erbit, post #20892133]

I want a private cloud or small websites at home—what’s the safe approach?

Use a VPN for media and keep websites on external hosting. This reduces attack surface and maintenance burdens. "Use a VPN for media available from outside... and preferably place your own websites outside (on purchased hosting)." If you must self‑host, ensure a public IP and hardened services. [Elektroda, Erbit, post #20892133]

Can I replace Play’s ONT/router or use an SFP ONT in my own router?

As a rule, no—without ISP approval. "As a rule, it is not possible to connect your own equipment if the ISP does not agree," even though the poster notes this conflicts with an EU directive. Proceed only with explicit provider consent. [Elektroda, Erbit, post #20892986]

What happens if I replace the ONT anyway?

Some users program third‑party ONTs or SFPs successfully, but there are risks. Reports note connection bans afterward: "for a few days some of them have had their connection banned." Weigh potential downtime and contract breaches before attempting. [Elektroda, Erbit, post #20892986]

Will Play enable Bridge mode if I ask?

Ask your supplier. The router model can support Bridge, but the operator may disable it. Request a public IP and Bridge explicitly. If they refuse, use your own router behind theirs and rely on VPN for remote access. [Elektroda, Erbit, post #20892133]

Has anyone actually gotten Bridge mode enabled recently?

Yes. One user reported their current carrier agreed to switch their router to Bridge mode. If your provider supports it, you can stay and proceed with your own router. Policies vary by operator. [Elektroda, arturm, post #20907123]

What do “modem‑router mode” and “router mode” mean here?

They are different operating modes that affect how the device handles connectivity. "Modem router mode - this is something different than router mode." On Play’s Kaon AR2140, Bridge mode is generally unavailable, so plan your network accordingly. [Elektroda, KOCUREK1970, post #20630361]

Where can I read more about replacing ONTs on other ISPs?

See community threads: Orange (trzepak.pl/viewtopic.php?t=51177) and Netia (trzepak.pl/viewtopic.php?t=64891). Start from the end for the latest context. Consider starting a new topic for your scenario. [Elektroda, Erbit, post #20894598]

Are there safer alternatives to port forwarding for remote access?

Yes. Use a VPN instead of exposing ports. Avoid direct redirections to internal devices to reduce attack risks, including ransomware or disk encryption incidents. Host public websites externally when possible. This approach improves security and uptime. [Elektroda, Erbit, post #20892133]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT