Negative Reviews on HDD Regenerator: Comparing with MHDD, Effects on Disk & Data Preservation

As Nirvanowiec wrote, there is a description on the forum MHDD . AND Here there are also extended MHDD instruction descriptions.

I can see that Petruchenko is on someone's skin, I consider hddregenerator to be a great program, it has helped me many times and I am not going to denigrate him in any way. There are many better and worse software, the most important thing is that it should work and give some results.
I have read this Russian article (fortunately they taught me Russian at school) and I see in it only an attempt to prove its worthlessness from the programmer's and analyst's point of view, the issues and causes of failure, rather than its effects. No matter how it works, it is important that it is effective. The same technical argument with a causal analysis can be written about the flail and considered a useless device, but it works and brings the expected effect. This article stinks of Russian envy and jealousy, this is what this nation does. Why such an article was not written by a person from another country, who does not have access to it, does not use it? Somehow the whole world works on it and no one came up with the idea to lynch it like that.
This is my opinion as an objective person who knows a bit about Russian customs and their mentality, I have worked with them for too long to think otherwise.

greetings

Moderated:

On the other hand, we do not care about your nationalist prejudices, there are plenty of articles about this program, not only written by Russians, just look for it. Additionally, if you think that people who professionally deal with data recovery are wrong in this aspect, you are wrong, we do not really favor or slander anyone in this forum. They are simply proven in practice and characterized by the most effective methods to which, unfortunately, HDD Regenerator does not belong.

I'm sorry for myself, but I have my views and my stubbornness, so maybe I will proactively shut up before I get banned.

Greetings to the nationalists (to which I do not belong)

Sorry again, please delete my threads in order not to arouse more emotions on this topic, I do not want to be the perpetrator of national wars. If you find me unworthy, please delete my account!
The statement was not intended to offend anyone, but it came out as it turned out and I admit it, I got into my blood for too long being with people who, unfortunately, think as I wrote, but I do not identify with them, but my tongue is not burned out and it always stands out in front of the head, that is, before I think I write it, and then I have it for mine, but I deserve it.
I apologize to the Russians and everyone who felt offended. I will try to improve.

My friend jacknn the program mentioned here can be considered sensational if:
- there is no data or unnecessary data on the disk before its use,
- the disc has a slight defect and shows a lot of willingness to live,
- the owner of the disk has a vague (which is not an offense) idea about the structure and operation of the device,
- and the belief that anything other than a program like fdisk or format is considered black magic at least.

And so it can take a very long time until the so-called "kuku" or the disk after the whole operation will not report in the BIOS.
Apparently, my colleague has not found such a disc yet and hence this kind of statement.

While the use of this software at your own discretion and needs in your own backyard and at your own risk is not subject to evaluation, recommending it on the Forum to a User who has lost his data for some reason is delicately inadvisable.
Unfortunately, at the Forum, we cannot afford (at least those people who care a little bit about the existence of this Department) to experiment on Users.
We also operate based on our own experience and that is why we do not recommend this software.

And in conclusion.
Friend, if my colleague is looking for nationalists, I do not recommend this Forum.

P.

Where was nationalism here? On the other hand (to jacknn ), okzo He seems to be Lithuanian, so rather "Russian envy" has nothing to do with it.
And the third issue: since when does the moderator in the red frame speak substantively on a given topic? It's so hard to write a simple post to add an HDD Regenerator argument (like Przemcio )?

Colleagues, instead of writing about nationalism, it is better to read what it is nationalism . Secondly, it's better to write about the program and its effects, and how it works and why the program should be good or bad.

My friend kaem I think the description was prepared by a colleague okzo with very precise and factual arguments
enough to consider this program unsafe to use in the event of data loss (and more).
So what if these arguments do not appeal to Forum users who, as usual, use it first
then there are questions what happened and how could it happen if there are so many statements praising this soft.
So far, I have not found a method of operation and there are already a dozen examples on the Forum - even if only this in order to
do not go further.

From my own backyard - I can not imagine scanning, for example, a damaged 750 Gb disk with this program since
it happens that the HDD Regenerator is not able to "chew" the 40 GB disk overnight.
I will not mention the effects of operating on disks produced in the new technology.

It seems to me that enough has been written here for you to form your own opinion about this program.
And not in the category - good or bad program but rather useful / helpful or unhelpful / harmful .

Using my rights - I close the topic.
If anyone has questions, comments, etc. on this topic, please contact me via the PW system.

Przemcio