logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

Wireless septic tank - how to transmit the transmitter signal from the manhole

cerga 1329 13
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 18570046
    cerga
    Level 5  
    Posts: 10
    Rate: 4
    Hello to all the specialists present on this forum. I am a complete greenhorn so I humbly ask one question in the hope that the answer in the language of a normal person will be easy. I have this idea of installing a wireless septic tank sensor. All sensors I have found require that a radio transmitter is placed outside the sump to send an overflow signal to the receiver. Unfortunately, this solution is not very suitable because my septic tank is located in a residential street leading to garages of detached houses. So car traffic and the activities of the neighbours (e.g. snow ploughing) could harm either the transmitter or a possible cable connected to the transmitter. In addition, sensor manufacturers recommend not to mount the transmitter in a manhole because in the case of a metal cover the transmitter signal only has a range of a few metres, which in my case is insufficient. My question: if I want to install a transmitter in a septic tank manhole, is it possible to transmit a radio signal over a distance of e.g. up to 10 m? Thank you in advance for any advice.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 18571226
    kot mirmur
    Level 33  
    Posts: 2131
    Help: 206
    Rate: 556
    It's a tough topic mate - whatever you mount there, it needs to have its own power supply and be able to withstand high humidity/over 90% non-stop/. On top of this, there is also the acidification of this atmosphere caused by the presence of hydrogen sulphide.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #3 18573847
    cerga
    Level 5  
    Posts: 10
    Rate: 4
    Hello, thanks for your reply. I agree that this transmitter has to be able to withstand harsh conditions and it seems to me that it can be done if the transmitter is well protected. I am thinking of putting the transmitter in a sealed box to protect it from moisture and vapour. At the same time there is still the question of how to transmit the radio signal. I don't need a constant signal or just a short pulse to the receiver, like with a garage door. Is it possible to lead a cable from the transmitter to the outside which can be used as an antenna? Or is it possible to replace the metal cap with a cover made of another material? Thank you in advance for any suggestions.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 18573965
    TvWidget
    Level 38  
    Posts: 4386
    Help: 471
    Rate: 691
    If the cover is metal without any holes it is in practice an insurmountable barrier for the radio signal.
    Is there a lot of traffic on the road ? Can anything be attached to the cover ?
    You have probably seen the reflectors commonly known as cat's eyes hanging on the asphalt. The casing is about 25mm thick and can withstand a little car traffic. A transmitter with a battery can be placed in such a piece. The whole thing, of course, has to be encased in resin. I have been testing the durability of such a solution for a parking space occupancy sensor for three months. Unfortunately, there has hardly been any snow this year. So it is difficult for me to say whether snow and ice will cause connectivity problems.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #5 18574594
    cerga
    Level 5  
    Posts: 10
    Rate: 4
    Thanks to TvWidzget for your willingness to help. The cover has two holes, about 3 cm in diameter, for ventilation I think. Do you think it will be enough to transmit the signal?
    Your solution is not bad and may be a solution in my case, especially since the car traffic is very small. Regarding ice or snow, I think that a few to several centimetres of snow/ice is not a problem for radio waves - if we take the example of a garage door remote control where the signal goes through the wall. But I agree that it is better to test during a real winter.
    Speaking of winter and your sensor, did the battery prewarm the low temperatures?
  • #6 18575938
    TvWidget
    Level 38  
    Posts: 4386
    Help: 471
    Rate: 691
    The 14250 lithium battery can operate over a very wide temperature range. It can withstand even -40st.
    As far as the penetration of radio waves through water is concerned, even a millimetre can be a problem. However, if the sensor periodically sends its status it will reach the receiver sooner or later. A septic tank does not suddenly overflow, after all.
    If you place the antenna in the gust hole and the receiver is above it, e.g. on a lamppost, you may be able to receive the signal. However, you are probably thinking of a transmitter on 433MHz. In this band the antenna is quite large. Any conductive elements near it will significantly reduce the amount of energy emitted.
  • #7 18575994
    gimak
    Level 41  
    Posts: 6196
    Help: 614
    Rate: 1659
    cerga wrote:
    The cover has two openings of approx. 3 cm diameter, for ventilation purposes I guess.
    .
    Rather for hooks to lift the cover.
  • #8 18578588
    cerga
    Level 5  
    Posts: 10
    Rate: 4
    gimak wrote:
    .
    Rather on hooks to lift the lid.


    Thank you gimak for the explanation. I will not hide that I am surprised if these holes are only for lifting the lid because in this case I start to have various other ideas.
    Sometimes I have noticed tubes glued to the covers, something like chimneys and that is why I thought that these holes are for ventilation.

    TvWidget wrote:
    .
    The 14250 lithium battery can operate over a very wide temperature range. It can withstand as low as -40st.

    Cool, thanks for the information, I will take it into account when designing the prototype :) .

    In your case where and how far is the receiver located?

    On another subject: is there any material readily available (plastic?) and hard enough to transmit the signal? After the reply of my colleague "gimak", I am beginning to think about replacing the metal cover with my own, made of this material.

    Thank you and best regards.
  • #9 18579147
    TvWidget
    Level 38  
    Posts: 4386
    Help: 471
    Rate: 691
    I was referring to such an enclosure:
    Wireless septic tank - how to transmit the transmitter signal from the manhole .
    The receiver at my place is just high up, but this is due to the specifics of the application. I have not measured the range. I think it will be 10-20m. The transmitter sticks out above ground level. The receiver can therefore also be placed low.
  • #10 18587740
    Anonymous
    Level 1  
  • #11 18591066
    cerga
    Level 5  
    Posts: 10
    Rate: 4
    Thank you for your suggestions. Right, if there is a "closed circuit" it is possible to estimate from the water meter how much water is in the septic tank. At the same time, when using tap water for garden irrigation, this circuit is not so closed and without a water meter for the irrigation system it will be difficult to estimate the amount of water poured into the septic tank. Hence the need to measure the level directly in the tank.
  • #12 18591130
    Anonymous
    Level 1  
  • #13 18591180
    kot mirmur
    Level 33  
    Posts: 2131
    Help: 206
    Rate: 556
    This solution is possible, but unfortunately not very reliable> a manhole flap is not watertight. Water from the street can always get in there - and that's the end of measurements. Can you draw a side cross-section of this septic tank, my friend? Some simple drawing, and give the approximate diameter of the waste pipe. I ask because I think I have an idea about your prabol.
  • #14 18599567
    cerga
    Level 5  
    Posts: 10
    Rate: 4
    kot mirmur wrote:
    Are you able to draw a side cross-section of this septic tank, fellow author? Some simple drawing, and give the approximate diameter of the effluent pipe.


    Hello, I will provide pictures. One with the lid and one without (sorry for the views). The lid is 54 cm in diameter.
    Unfortunately the diameter of the drain pipe unknown because, as can be seen in the photo, the pipe is hidden somewhere under the sump.
    Without diving it is not possible to measure :) .
    Wireless septic tank - how to transmit the transmitter signal from the manhole Wireless septic tank - how to transmit the transmitter signal from the manhole

Topic summary

✨ The discussion revolves around the challenges of installing a wireless septic tank sensor, particularly the need to transmit a signal from a manhole without exposing the transmitter to potential damage from traffic and environmental conditions. Users emphasize the importance of protecting the transmitter from high humidity and corrosive gases, suggesting encasing it in a sealed box. The feasibility of using existing ventilation holes in the manhole cover for signal transmission is debated, with some proposing the use of non-metallic materials for the cover to enhance signal strength. Alternatives such as using a water meter to estimate septic tank levels are also considered, although direct measurement is preferred for accuracy. The conversation highlights various technical considerations, including the impact of water and ice on radio signal transmission and the potential for using antennas or cables to improve connectivity.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: For buried septic sensors, water as thin as 1 mm can block RF and 14250 lithium cells work to -40°C; "even a millimetre can be a problem." [Elektroda, TvWidget, post #18575938]

Why it matters: This FAQ helps homeowners get reliable wireless septic level alerts when metal lids, moisture, and placement kill signal.

Quick Facts

Can a wireless septic tank transmitter work under a metal manhole cover?

A solid metal lid behaves like a shield and blocks RF. With no openings, the barrier is “insurmountable.” To get a signal out, you need a non-metal path or to route the antenna through a hole. Otherwise, range will be only a few meters or none. [Elektroda, TvWidget, post #18573965]

Do lifting/vent holes help get a signal out?

Yes, if you route the antenna up through a hole and position the receiver directly above it. At 433 MHz the antenna is relatively large, and nearby metal reduces radiated energy. “Any conductive elements near it will significantly reduce the amount of energy emitted.” [Elektroda, TvWidget, post #18575938]

How far can I realistically reach—will 10 meters work?

A user reported about 10–20 m when the transmitter was above ground, with the receiver placed higher. Keeping both ends above grade or line-of-sight improves reliability. Under a metal lid, expect far less unless the antenna exits a hole. [Elektroda, TvWidget, post #18579147]

What battery chemistry survives freezing conditions for a buried sensor?

Use a 14250 lithium cell. It operates over a wide range and tolerates down to roughly −40°C. This helps winter uptime when the enclosure is near ground level or exposed. Choose low-drain transmission bursts to extend life. [Elektroda, TvWidget, post #18575938]

Does water, snow, or ice between antenna and receiver matter?

Yes. Water strongly attenuates RF at 433 MHz. Even a 1 mm film can break the link. Snow and ice can also degrade connectivity, especially if they create a wet layer above the antenna. “Even a millimetre can be a problem.” [Elektroda, TvWidget, post #18575938]

Is it legal or safe to mount a transmitter puck on the roadway?

One contributor warns installing hardware on a public road “may not be legally possible.” Consider property lines and local regulations before mounting anything in the street. This also avoids damage from vehicles and snowplows. [Elektroda, Anonymous, post #18591130]

Can I run a cable to an external antenna instead?

Avoid dragging a cable through the sewer path. A member noted that pulling in a spiral or long cable can cause clogs over time. If you must route an antenna, exit via a lid hole, then seal around the feedthrough. [Elektroda, Anonymous, post #18591130]

Are manhole covers watertight enough for reliable level sensing?

No. A manhole flap is not watertight. Street water can enter and disrupt measurements or damage non-sealed electronics. As one expert put it, if water gets in, that’s the end of measurements. Use robust sealing and protected placement. [Elektroda, kot mirmur, post #18591180]

Could I estimate tank fill from my water meter instead of using wireless?

Yes, if the property is a closed circuit—what comes in goes to the tank. A user notes you can calculate contents with good accuracy from the water meter, sufficient for a “tank may be full” alert. [Elektroda, Anonymous, post #18587740]

What if I irrigate with tap water—does that break water‑meter estimates?

Irrigation bypasses the tank and invalidates simple meter math. A homeowner solved this by adding a second water meter for garden use. That separates irrigation consumption from wastewater, restoring estimation accuracy. [Elektroda, Anonymous, post #18591130]

How should I protect electronics inside the septic environment?

Use a sealed enclosure and corrosion‑resistant parts. The space runs at over 90% humidity continuously, with hydrogen sulfide present. “Whatever you mount there, it needs its own power supply and withstand high humidity/over 90% non‑stop/.” [Elektroda, kot mirmur, post #18571226]

What simple steps can improve link reliability without replacing the cover?

Try this:
  1. Route the antenna through a lid hole to open air.
  2. Mount the receiver above the hole (e.g., nearby post or wall).
  3. Transmit short status bursts periodically to catch openings in conditions. A septic tank won’t overflow instantly, so periodic updates work. [Elektroda, TvWidget, post #18575938]

Are the small holes on my lid meant for ventilation?

They are typically lifting holes for hooks, not ventilation. You can still use a hole to route an antenna out. Seal around any pass‑through to reduce water ingress and protect hardware. [Elektroda, gimak, post #18575994]

Will a non‑metallic lid improve signal compared with metal?

Yes. A continuous metal cover acts like a Faraday cage and blocks RF. Replacing it with a non‑metallic lid removes that shield, allowing signals to pass with far less loss. Ensure mechanical strength and safety compliance. [“Faraday cage”]

Is a road “cat’s eye” style puck a viable external housing?

One user tested an embedded, resin‑potted transmitter in a 25 mm thick road reflector. It withstood light car traffic, but winter snow and ice effects remain uncertain. Consider this only where road use and laws allow. [Elektroda, TvWidget, post #18573965]

Where should I position the receiver for best results?

Place it above the antenna’s exit point to maximize line‑of‑sight. Elevation helps, but even low mounting can work if the transmitter is above ground. Keep metal away from antennas to reduce detuning. [Elektroda, TvWidget, post #18575938]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT