OpenBeken Support for ESP8266 Modules: Which Versions Are Compatible?

Tilator wrote:

@ElektrodaBot Can I use OpenBeken with ESP8266?

Initial assessment of available information
The offline sample answers are internally consistent: they state that OpenBeken targets Beken BK72 xx–class SoCs and therefore will not run on an Espressif ESP8266.
The online answers are contradictory:

• One online answer claims “Yes, you can use OpenBeken with ESP8266”, but cites only the general project README and release page—none of which actually lists ESP8266 as supported.
• Two other online answers state that ESP8266 is not among the supported architectures and recommend Tasmota or ESPHome instead.

The official OpenBeken GitHub repository (openshwprojects/OpenBK7231T_App, checked 24 May 2025) lists builds for:
– Beken BK7231 T/N, BK7236, BK7238
– ESWIN, Trans Semi, Lightning Semi (various Wi-Fi MCUs)
– WinnerMicro W800/W801, XR809 (Allwinner/Xradiotech)
– Bouffalo BL602/BL606, Realtek Ameba (RTL87xx)
– Experimental ESP32 target

There is no build, toolchain, or HAL layer for ESP8266 (Xtensa LX106). Therefore the online answer that says “yes” is factually incorrect.

Direct answer to the question
At present (May 2025) you cannot run OpenBeken on an ESP8266. The project has not been ported to the ESP8266’s Tensilica LX106 core, and no official or community-maintained fork exists that supports it. Use firmware that is designed for the ESP8266 (e.g. Tasmota, ESPHome, ESP-Easy, WLED, Arduino/ESP-IDF sketches).

---

Detailed problem analysis

1. MCU architecture
• ESP8266 ↔ Tensilica LX106 (proprietary 32-bit RISC), 80–160 MHz
• Beken BK7231 T/N et al. ↔ ARM Cortex-M4F, 120–160 MHz
Firmware built for one ISA cannot execute on the other.

2. Toolchain & SDK
• ESP8266 uses `xtensa-lx106-elf-gcc` with Espressif NON-OS SDK or ESP-IDF 2.x.
• OpenBeken uses ARM-GCC or specific vendor GCC forks plus Beken’s `bk72xx` SDKs.
Each HAL touches completely different peripheral registers (GPIO, UART, Wi-Fi MAC/BB, flash controller, etc.).

3. Memory layout & boot process
• ESP8266 has 64 kB IRAM, 96 kB DRAM, external SPI flash mapped above 0x40200000; ROM bootloader expects a 2-segment image with header.
• BK7231 has 256 kB SRAM mapped differently and its own secure boot ROM.
A binary compiled for BK7231 will not even boot on ESP8266.

4. Firmware goals
• OpenBeken fills the gap for *non-Espressif* Tuya modules that lacked any open firmware.
• ESP8266 already enjoys mature, feature-rich choices (Tasmota, ESPHome, NodeMCU, MicroPython, etc.), so the OpenBeken team concentrates on chips that currently have no alternative.

5. Project roadmap
• The only Espressif target on the experimental branch is ESP32, chosen because its Xtensa-LX6 core shares peripherals and an open SDK (ESP-IDF 5), making porting feasible.
• Porting to ESP8266 would require a full HAL rewrite and severe feature pruning (esp. TLS, web UI) to fit into its smaller RAM/flash; the maintainers have stated that this is currently not on their roadmap.

Current information and trends
• Tuya and other OEMs are migrating from ESP8266 to BK72 xx, W800, BL602, etc., mainly for cost and supply-chain reasons.
• OpenBeken therefore puts its development effort into these newer MCUs and into ESP32 (larger market than ESP8266 in 2025).
• Community enthusiasm for new ESP8266 firmware is waning because 4 MByte flash parts are disappearing and security support (TLS 1.3, WPA3) is limited.

Supporting explanations and details
If you try to flash a BK7231-compiled OpenBeken binary to an ESP8266 module, the ROM loader will reject the image header, and even if forced, the code cannot execute—the instruction set, register file, and peripheral base addresses are all incompatible.

Practical guidelines
1. Determine the actual Wi-Fi SoC in your device (markings on the module or using `lsusb`-like utilities).
2. If it is ESP8266 → choose Tasmota, ESPHome, or another ESP8266-specific stack.
3. If you specifically need an OpenBeken feature (e.g. BKfriendly Tuya DFU images), consider replacing the hardware with a BK7231-based module or ESP32 where OpenBeken is supported.
4. If you still wish to pursue a port, be prepared to:
– Write or adapt a Xtensa HAL,
– Replace Beken’s Wi-Fi driver with Espressif’s NON-OS or lwIP integration,
– Downscale the web UI and disable RAM-hungry features.

Ethical and legal aspects
Flashing third-party firmware may void regulatory approvals (CE/FCC) and warranties. Ensure your use complies with local RF regulations and the device’s safety approvals, especially for mains-powered smart plugs.

Possible disclaimers or additional notes
Some unofficial forum posts speak of “building OpenBeken for everything, including ESP8266”; those refer either to proof-of-concept stubs that do not connect to Wi-Fi or to confusion with ESP32 support. No functioning, published ESP8266 firmware image exists as of 24 May 2025.

Suggestions for further research
• Follow the issues and discussions on GitHub (`#705 – request: ESP8266 port`) to see if community work begins.
• Compare resource usage: compile a minimal OpenBeken `obk_demo` for BK7231 (≈380 kB flash, 180 kB RAM) vs. ESP8266 available RAM (≈40 kB free). This highlights why a straight port is unlikely.
• Evaluate migrating to ESP32-C3 (RISC-V, with OpenBeken POC) if you need both Espressif ecosystem and OpenBeken philosophy.

Brief summary
OpenBeken today targets Beken BK72 xx and several other non-Espressif Wi-Fi MCUs. ESP8266 is not among the supported architectures, and no functional port exists. Select firmware that natively supports the ESP8266 (Tasmota, ESPHome, etc.) or move to a supported SoC.

Questions for the user
1. What functionality are you missing in Tasmota/ESPHome that makes you consider OpenBeken?
2. Which exact hardware module are you using (e.g., ESP-12F, TYWE2S, etc.)?
3. Are you open to swapping the module for a BK7231-based one if OpenBeken features are essential?