logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda
Advanced Search
logo elektroda

[Solved] How do I configure a Zigbee Tuya 3.0, Fireangel ST630 smoke detector with a Zigbee module?

yarko1 1500 8
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
| New topic
  • #1 19407895
    yarko1
    Level 8  
    Hello
    I have a problem because I cannot configure the Zigbee Tuya 3.0 gateway and the Fireangel ST630 smoke detector with the Zigbee module. The gateway detects the Tuya devices, however it does not see this smoke detector. Fireangel is a large company from England, however they do not have their dedicated Zigbee gateways. I know there are Zigbee compatibility issues with devices from different manufacturers, does anyone have a solution? I wouldn't want to give up on this detector, as the detector itself is professional equipment with CNBOP certification.

    Greetings
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 19409624
    sk1977

    IT specialist  
    yarko1 wrote:
    Fireangel is a big company from England, but they don't have their dedicated Zigbee gates
    - FP1000W2-R should support this sensor, but I don't know if it's zigbee.
    yarko1 wrote:
    The gateway detects Tuya devices, however it does not see this smoke sensor
    - this is not a multi gateway.... There are exceptions and it also supports some non-Tuya devices, but not many.
    Helpful post? Buy me a coffee.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #3 19409920
    yarko1
    Level 8  
    sk1977 wrote:
    yarko1 wrote:
    Fireangel is a big company from England, but they don't have their dedicated Zigbee gates
    - FP1000W2-R should support this sensor, but I don't know if it's zigbee.
    yarko1 wrote:
    The gateway detects Tuya devices, however it does not see this smoke sensor
    - this is not a multi gateway.... There are exceptions and it also supports some non-Tuya devices, but not many.

    I know about this FP1000W2-R gateway, however it is not Zigbee. In general Zigbee is some kind of failure, I thought it was a common system for all manufacturers. Unfortunately everyone is locked into their own standards and the whole Zigbee Alliance is a big sham. The Fireangel sensor and module was returned because it was impossible to match any gateway available from companies in our market. Fireangel itself does not have its own gateway and not even an application under Zigbee ( only wifi safe ).
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #4 19410061
    sk1977

    IT specialist  
    yarko1 wrote:
    I could not match any gateway available from companies in our market
    - from the description on Amazon's website: "Networking capability: Wi-Safe 2, Z-Wave or Zigbee (via an additional module)." - do you have an additional module?
    yarko1 wrote:
    Unfortunately everyone is locked into their standards and the whole Zigbee Alliance is a big scam
    - not all devices are compatible - so it's worth checking before buying - many manufacturers have not joined the Zigbee Alliance or not all their devices are compatible.
    Helpful post? Buy me a coffee.
  • #5 19411124
    yarko1
    Level 8  
    sk1977 wrote:
    - from the description on Amazon's website: "Networking capability: Wi-Safe 2, Z-Wave or Zigbee (via an additional module)." - do you have an additional module?
    .

    This is a mistake, this is only for Wi-Safe. Of course I had additional Zigbee modules for these sensors and no gateway in our market works with it. From the manufacturer I got a list of gates that work. Most are not available in the EU or the price.... 250Euro

    sk1977 wrote:
    - not all devices are compatible - so it is worth checking before buying - many manufacturers have not joined the Zigbee Alliance or not all their devices are compatible.
    .

    Those that have joined and these are the ones we're talking about should have an open standard, otherwise it doesn't make sense.
  • #6 19411153
    sk1977

    IT specialist  
    yarko1 wrote:
    Those that have joined and these are the ones we are talking about should have an open standard, otherwise it makes no sense.
    - the manufacturer of the Fireangel ST630 has joined? I don't see it on the list, so we're talking rather mainly about the one that hasn't joined....
    Those that have joined and are introducing new products - compatibility is already there, but old products are not affected. Whether it makes sense - everyone can have their own opinion. In my opinion, the use of manufacturers' gateways only makes sense in some cases and I don't see much of a problem here - just check what you are going to buy. There is still the issue of app-device compatibility - any app would have to support all devices.... Fortunately there are multi gateways.
    Helpful post? Buy me a coffee.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #7 19413229
    yarko1
    Level 8  
    sk1977 wrote:
    sk1977 wrote:
    yarko1 wrote:
    Those that have joined and we're talking about those should have an open standard, otherwise it doesn't make sense.
    - the manufacturer of the Fireangel ST630 has joined? I don't see it on the list, so we're talking rather mainly about the one that hasn't joined....
    Those that have joined and are introducing new products - compatibility is already there, but old products are not affected. Whether it makes sense - everyone can have their own opinion. In my opinion, the use of manufacturers' gateways only makes sense in some cases and I don't see much of a problem here - just check what you are going to buy. There is still the issue of app compatibility with devices - any app would have to support all devices.... Fortunately there are multigateways.


    https://zigbeealliance.org/zigbee_products/zb-module/

    https://zigbeealliance.org/member/fireangel-safety-technology-limited/
  • #8 19413275
    sk1977

    IT specialist  
    yarko1 wrote:
    Fireangel ST630
    - does not search by this name.... By an incorrectly specified model...
    How do I configure a Zigbee Tuya 3.0, Fireangel ST630 smoke detector with a Zigbee module? .
    There is still the question of how to connect, how to configure, how to apply.
    Helpful post? Buy me a coffee.
  • #9 19415993
    yarko1
    Level 8  
    I bought other sensors
| New topic
Report a violation of the law

Topic summary

The discussion revolves around the difficulty of configuring a Zigbee Tuya 3.0 gateway with a Fireangel ST630 smoke detector equipped with a Zigbee module. The user reports that while the gateway detects other Tuya devices, it fails to recognize the Fireangel smoke detector. Responses highlight compatibility issues between devices from different manufacturers, with Fireangel lacking a dedicated Zigbee gateway or application. Users express frustration over the fragmented nature of Zigbee standards, noting that many manufacturers do not adhere to a common protocol, leading to challenges in device interoperability. Suggestions include verifying compatibility before purchasing and exploring multi-gateway options, although some users have resorted to alternative sensors due to these limitations.
Summary generated by the language model.
Popular Topics
ADVERTISEMENT