logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

TRV Smart Head for Heater - External Sensor Control Issues with Zigbee Scenes

Janeo 1050 12
ADVERTISEMENT
Treść została przetłumaczona polish » english Zobacz oryginalną wersję tematu
  • #1 20912069
    Janeo
    Level 12  
    I connected in Scenes a gate, a head (modern, 3xAA) and an external temperature sensor. I have set in these Scenes the times of the relevant operation of the head (heating, pause) depending on the ambient temperature indicated by this EXTERNAL sensor. Thus, the scenes are and are active.
    By way of explanation I would like to add that the Tuja programme (Smart Life) has in the settings an option called "Heating Sequences" permanently switched on (I presume so, because there is no option to switch it off) where the desired temperature and ambient temperature, which comes from the head sensor at the radiator, are set for the week - hours.

    Well, my head as I can see from the behaviour of the % tightening/un-tightening graph works according to the "Heating Sequence" and not according to the active Scenes. The conclusion is that the head cannot be controlled by external temperature sensors, e.g. in my case a sensor lying on a table in the middle of the room.

    Has anyone tried connecting the head to an external temperature sensor, and if so, with what results?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #2 20912114
    freebsd
    Level 42  
    Janeo wrote:
    I have set in these Scenes the hours of relevant head operation
    What time ranges did you select?
  • #3 20912122
    Janeo
    Level 12  
    As it is according to you a matter of importance, I can of course inform :-) .
    I would add that the hours from the Scenes overlap with the hours from the "Heating Sequence" because, as you know, a day is one.
  • #4 20912134
    freebsd
    Level 42  
    Janeo wrote:
    If it's a matter of importance according to you, then of course I can inform you .
    You've just set up a thread asking for help with setting up scenes in Tuya with a time schedule. To answer your question, for me this information is not relevant.
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #5 20912143
    Janeo
    Level 12  
    I didn't start a thread asking for help with scene configurations because I know such configurations like the trowel. Nonetheless, thank you for your interest :-)
    I have started a thread about the head working with scenes, has anyone had similar problems that the head does not work in scenes but chooses to act according to the "Heating Sequence".
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #6 21270759
    grzmeh
    Level 3  
    I have a question, have you already solved the problem with the head and scenes, because I have the same situation and don't really know how to solve it.
  • #7 21271062
    Janeo
    Level 12  
    Specifically what is the problem, can you describe?
    What model of TRV and what communication protocol?
  • ADVERTISEMENT
  • #8 21271664
    grzmeh
    Level 3  
    I'm just gaining experience in this topic, I wanted to prepare a scene: if the temperature on the external sensor drops, the head is supposed to switch to heating mode. The scene turns on, but the head does not react, as if it is under the control of the application. I'm probably doing something wrong, but what, I don't know at the moment.

    Added after 2 [minutes]: .

    Moes head - type not found 3 AA batteries, ZigBee protocol.
  • #9 21271677
    Janeo
    Level 12  
    grzmeh wrote:
    Scene comes on but head does not respond as if under application control.


    Firstly you need a zigbee gateway for the set (I assume you have one), secondly if the head does not respond, it IS NOT (not - IS) under application control.
    ps: set the head to Manual mode, and only ON<->OFF in scenes(possibly Pause).
    Also put Notifications in scenes to make sure the scene is on. Take note that the whole thing may work with a 25-minute delay.
  • #10 21271716
    grzmeh
    Level 3  
    Thank you, I will test it right away
  • #11 21291447
    Jericho24
    Level 20  
    grzmeh wrote:
    Thanks, I'll test it soon
    .
    And what came out of the tests?
  • #12 21293436
    grzmeh
    Level 3  
    Thanks again for the tips, the one about the scene delay was particularly valuable, as I had previously defined a scene and was waiting for the effect. As for the head itself, as I mentioned earlier, the application of the head itself has power over most of the parameters. From the scenes I was able to run the target temperature setting function, thus I can adjust the opening and closing of the head - which is really what it was all about. I bought more heads and temperature sensors and will try to configure the system for the whole house, the idea is to check the temperature with the sensor, and if it is too high or too low, I turn on the heating, I don't know if this is the most efficient, because I plan to install 5-6 sensors. The subject is probably more complex, because you can, for example, control the heads (a lot of freedom points, which can be controlled). How did you solve the control of the heating in the whole house at your place?
  • #13 21316868
    Janeo
    Level 12  
    grzmeh wrote:
    Thank you again for the tips, especially valuable was the one talking about the delay in the effect of scenes, as I had previously defined a scene and was waiting for the effect. As for the head itself, as I mentioned earlier, over most parameters the application of the head itself has power.
    .


    You're welcome.
    As for the functions it is not you, rather I have been telling you from the beginning that you should set only on one - ON<->OFF - and not on any part of the parameters, because any setting of scenes to other actions of the automation which is based on its own (internal) sensor in the head causes the TRV to take complete control of the situation ignoring external data.

Topic summary

The discussion addresses issues with controlling a TRV smart radiator valve (head) using external temperature sensors within Zigbee scenes configured in the Tuya Smart Life app. The user observes that the TRV head operates according to the app's built-in "Heating Sequence" based on its internal sensor rather than responding to external sensor data or scene triggers. It is clarified that the TRV head prioritizes its internal temperature sensor and heating schedule, overriding external scene controls. To enable scene-based control, the head should be set to Manual mode with simple ON/OFF or Pause commands in scenes, avoiding parameter adjustments that conflict with the internal heating sequence. A delay of up to 25 minutes in scene execution is noted. The model discussed is a Moes Zigbee TRV head powered by 3 AA batteries. The conversation highlights the complexity of integrating multiple external sensors for whole-house temperature management and the limitations imposed by the TRV's internal automation logic.
Summary generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT