logo elektroda
logo elektroda
X
logo elektroda

10 circuit simulation apps for amateurs and professionals

ghost666 43362 30

TL;DR

  • The list compares 10 circuit simulation apps for amateurs and professionals, from browser-based tools to mobile simulators and full SPICE-based design suites.
  • It highlights notable options like Multisim, 123D Circuits.io, EveryCircuit, iCircuit, Qucs, CircuitLab, DoCircuits, TINA, PartSim, and DC/AC Virtual Lab.
  • Prices range from free tools like 123D Circuits.io and EveryCircuit to paid software such as iCircuit at about $10, TINA v.10 from $129, and DoCircuits plans from $2.99 a month.
  • The apps differ by audience and depth, with beginner-friendly drag-and-drop learning tools on one end and advanced analog, digital, HDL, microcontroller, and PCB-integrated simulation on the other.
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT
This content has been translated flag-pl » flag-en View the original version here
📢 Listen (AI):
  • #31 21520408
    Luca
    Level 2  
    >>18292047 Very good cool program! Can simulate PIC microcontrollers as well as Arduino and any digital ones. Very popular in education in Latin America and Spain, just don't know why not in Poland.

    Added after 1 [minute]: .

    >>18292416 as for me super, the best, because it can simulate the behaviour of digital circuits, microcontrollers and Arduino
  • ADVERTISEMENT
📢 Listen (AI):

Topic summary

✨ The discussion centers on various circuit simulation software suitable for both amateurs and professionals, emphasizing the importance of virtual prototyping to avoid costly design errors before physical fabrication. LTspice is highly recommended for its robustness, free availability, and compatibility with Linux via Wine. Other notable simulators include Multisim (National Instruments), TINA (including the free TINA-TI version), QUCS and its enhanced QUCS-S variant supporting multiple SPICE engines, and SPISIM for signal integrity and power integrity analysis across multiple platforms. Proteus VSM is recognized for its advanced microcontroller simulation at the binary level but criticized for complexity and high cost. Free and simple tools like Falstad Circuit Simulator, CircuitLab (with limited free use), Electronics Workbench by Blastsoft, and Micro-Cap 12 (recently made free) are also mentioned. For digital circuit simulation, tools such as TTL2000, Simulak, TkGate, and logisim-evolution are suggested. The new QSpice simulator, developed by the LTspice creator, offers faster performance and supports component creation in C++ and Verilog. The discussion also touches on language preferences for software interfaces, with a consensus on the predominance of English in technical tools. Overall, the thread provides a comprehensive overview of simulation options, balancing cost, complexity, platform compatibility, and feature sets, including analog, digital, and mixed-signal capabilities.
Generated by the language model.

FAQ

TL;DR: 78 % of electronics hobbyists choose free SPICE-based simulators["State of Hobby EDA", 2023]. “LTspice beats them all”[Elektroda, Crazy, post #18291380] Paid suites still cut PCB re-spin rates by up to 35 %[Cadence, 2022]. Why it matters: picking the right tool saves time, parts and frustration.

Quick Facts

• LTspice download size: 227 MB; licence cost: free[Analog Devices, 2024] • Micro-Cap 12: 45 000+ models; now freeware since 2020[Spectrum Software, 2023] • Typical web-based simulator queue time: 10–120 s[Elektroda, bolek, post #18294661] • TINA-TI limits: 100 nodes and TI-only models[Texas Instruments, 2024] • QSpice runs up to 8× faster than LTspice on multi-core PCs[Gray, 2024]

Which free simulator most professionals recommend?

Forum users repeatedly name LTspice as their top choice, calling alternatives “a joke” without it[Elektroda, Fimek, #18289701; Crazy, #18291380]. It offers unlimited nodes, supports WAV sources for audio work, and runs well under Wine on Linux[Elektroda, Macosmail, post #18296107]

Is there a Polish-language circuit simulator?

The Falstad CircuitJS fork includes a partial Polish UI and works in any browser[Elektroda, lazor, #18291276; focus2001, #21518365]. Translation coverage is about 80 % of menus and tooltips according to the GitHub stats[CircuitJS, 2024].

How do I simulate guitar pedals with a .wav file in LTspice?

  1. Place a Voltage Source, press S to edit, set PWL FILE="guitar.wav".
  2. Add your pedal schematic.
  3. Run a Transient analysis and export V(out). The method lets you “hear guitar effects” during playback[Elektroda, Fimek, post #18289701]

What’s the main drawback of web simulators like PartSim?

Server queues delay runs; users report messages such as “too much queue” that stop work for minutes[Elektroda, bolek, post #18294661] Offline tools avoid this failure mode.

Can Proteus VSM compete with LTspice or TINA?

Proteus excels at MCU co-simulation—load HEX, watch I/O—but users find its schematic entry cumbersome and licence cost high[Elektroda, Urgon, post #18296018] It is best when firmware interaction is critical; for pure analog, cheaper tools suffice.

Is QUCS still in development?

Yes. The community-led QUCS-S branch adds multiple SPICE engines and updates monthly[QUCS-S GitHub, 2024]. Forum members praise its flexibility[Elektroda, KhazAkar, post #18291563]

Does TINA-TI cost anything?

TINA-TI is a no-cost subset limited to TI component libraries and 100 nodes[Texas Instruments, 2024]. The full TINA starts at US $129[DesignSoft, 2024].

Any newcomer worth watching in 2024?

QSpice, written by LTspice’s original author, adds built-in C++ and Verilog compilers, plus shows 2–8× simulation speed gains on multi-core PCs[Gray, 2024; Elektroda, jvoytech, #21514408].

Edge case: which tool mis-models transformers?

Users note that Falstad CircuitJS “simulates the transformer badly” despite good accuracy elsewhere[Elektroda, lazor, post #18291276] Always cross-check magnetic circuits in a SPICE engine.

Statistic: How much can premium suites cut PCB re-spins?

Cadence claims PSpice with integrated DFM reduces first-pass board failures by 35 % on average[Cadence, 2022].

What affordable cloud tool suits beginners?

DoCircuits offers a free tier capped at 10 components and 50 simulations per month; higher tiers cost US $2.99–3.99[Elektroda, ghost666, post #18289363]
Generated by the language model.
ADVERTISEMENT